TV.com will be making changes to the Private Message system the week of Jan 26, 2015. For more information click here

America's Got Talent

Season 1 Episode 5

Episode # 105

0
Aired Tuesday 9:00 PM Jul 12, 2006 on NBC
7.8
out of 10
User Rating
9 votes
2

EPISODE REVIEWS
By TV.com Users

Episode Summary

EDIT
Episode # 105
AIRED:
Contestants compete in the first week of the semifinals. Only one act will make it to the next round.

Who was the Episode MVP ?

Thursday
No results found.
Friday
No results found.
Saturday
No results found.
SUBMIT REVIEW
  • The contestants return for another shot.

    6.0
    Yep I agree totally that the bulk of the first acts returning weren't as good. The only ones that stood out in my mind where Jordan, Taylor Ware, and the Miller Brothers.



    However, I found Pier's comments attacking the dog owner John to be pathetic and disgusting. Pier is also a major hypocrite because none of this was brought up in the first act, so the second act bombs and you attack the owner? Wow what a first rate loser. John did get in the last word and humiliated the moron "My dogs have the best life". All Pier do could shake his head like an idiot.



    The cabaret act by Shawn Ryan I think the name was entertaining but nothing I haven't seen before in other cabaret acts. The same thign goes for the Ventriliquist with the dummies. Yeah he was pretty talented to change the voices around but the judges and I were still expecting something much more spectacular.



    The girl named Jordan was amazing. The judge's said she should picked a better song but I think they were wrong and comeon she's only 14 years old, do you expect to be Whitney Houston in one night? It's another sign of how the judges sometimes give out the worst judgement instead of focusing more on the positives than the negatives.



    The Miller Brother's were outstanding, they'll probably be in the finals. Still as a whole the show was average.moreless
  • Contradictory That pretty much sums it up

    4.0
    Firstly, I thought America was supposed to choose who goes on. So, why do the judges get to eliminate 5 of the 15 right of the bat before they get a chance to prove themselves? We know that some people didn't deserve to go on, like that dog guy. Who of which, took his chance into the forest and SHOT IT DEAD! Metaphorically of course. That's really fair to the people.

    Secondly, why do only 2 of 10 acts get to go on to the finals? What's the rush people? I know that there were people who didn't deserve to make it to the semi-finals. But people work hard to make it to the semi-finals and yet they were either eliminated or have a 1:10000 to get through.

    Thirdly, why do the judges still have influence over who goes to the finals? There are 15 people, so 5 people are taken off, so that makes 10. From there, only 2 can make it to the finals. And then the judges choose one act to go on to the finals automatically. So now America can vote but only one act will be let on to the finals.

    This show is so fair to the viewers.moreless
LD Miller

LD Miller

Himself

Guest Star

Cole Miller

Cole Miller

Himself

Guest Star

Shawn Ryan

Shawn Ryan

Himself

Guest Star

Alexis Jordan

Alexis Jordan

Herself

Recurring Role

Trivia, Notes, Quotes and Allusions

FILTER BY TYPE

More
Less