Not sure what the over reviewer was watching, but my 3 year old LOVED this show. One of the few that caught his attention from moment one & that he would look forward to & WAKE up for. (If you knew him, you'd know how rare that is)
I liked the show too. Had a good combination of repetition (with the recurring theme of each animal) and creativity (with the way they solved each challenge).
Did it have flaws? Of course. But I still found it more enjoyable that a lot of shows geared to that age group.
I would probably give it an 8 or 8.5, but upped it to make up for the other person's 1.