Goof: Gary appears at the start of the episode, but is totally absent during the closing scene.
The brand of harmonica Old Man Corcoran owns is Chromatic.
One of the tombstones is for Bill Cutter. This is likely a reference to a later episode entitled the Tale Of Cutter's Treasure.
David Francis, who played Old Man Corcoran in this episode also guest starred in the episodes "The Tale of the Hungry Hounds" as Giles and "The Tale of Station 109.1" as Daniel Carpenter.
Cissy: Well, look a little closer next time.
Kiki: (Opening line to story) Jack and Kenny Harris just moved in to the neighborhood, and hadn't made many friends yet. It's never easy being the new kids on the block, so you'll do almost anything to fit in. But Jack and Kenny are about to find out, that that's not always such a good idea.
Cissy: Go find your own grave!
Old Man Corcoran: You look like you've just seen a ghost.
Kenny: I don't want friends that bad!
Old Man Corcoran: Give me...my...harmonica!
This meeting of the Midnight Society was never declared closed.
Spoiler: Marshal Mclain died in 1978 when he was 13 years old.
Adam Bonneau, who played Jack in this episode, played Zack in an episode of Goosebumps called "Let's Get Invisible".
A headstone in the graveyard reads "Ron Oil." This is probably a reference to the director, Ron Oliver.
This story was told by Kiki.
The way the hide and seek gang hide in the empty graves foreshadows the ending.
S 5 : Ep 11
Aired 2/3/96
S 5 : Ep 9
Aired 1/20/96
S 5 : Ep 1
Aired 10/7/95 (25:00)
S 4 : Ep 10
Aired 12/10/94
User Score: 202
User Score: 691
User Score: 471
User Score: 414
User Score: 117
User Score: 114
User Score: 69
User Score: 56
User Score: 35
User Score: 34