Jorgito Vargas Jr. who played Felix, would later star in another children's show Power Rangers as Blake Bradley the Navy Thunder Ranger in Ninja Storm
In this episode, Elisha Cuthbert plays the young girl. In the next season, she became a member of the Midnight Society, playing Megan.
Sam starts the story off by speaking about illusions and seeing something that wasn't there before. Sam's story represents her growing affection for Gary.
Felix: Hello, Amanda. Amanda: Felix. But you're...you're... Felix: Dead? (chuckles) Sort of. (Amanda and Colin run away and stop in another room) Colin: (to Amanda) How can you be sort of dead? (Felix comes in through the door) Felix: Oh, it's not so bad, really. You'll soon find out for yourself.
Sam: I've been saving this story for a long time. And I think tonight's the best night to tell it. It's a story about illusion and and deception. Some things may look familiar but they could be hiding a secret that you'd never expect. It could be beautiful or mysterious or, like in my story, something evil. Submitted for the approval of the Midnight Society, I call this story...The Tale of the Night Shift.
Vampire: (dangling Amanda over a ledge) I should drop you and lick up what's left.
(Talking about dead body in the morgue) Amanda: It's Felix! Colin: Who? Amanda: Felix, he works on maintenance. Colin: Not anymore. He's like really dead!
Jack: Is that a body? Amanda: No, it's a pinball machine!
Amanda: Tell your friend I'll be upstairs! Margo: Tell me yourself.
Vampire: There's no use in hiding.. I'm far too good a hunter.
Nurse: Margo Amanda, meet Amanda Margo.
Margo: It'll be much less painful if you just give in.
Vampire: I should drop you and lick up what's left!
Sam and Gary become a couple.
This episode, had the highest death toll of any other episode. 4 characters were shown being lured to their deaths, and a total of 7 characters were shown after they had been killed.
This meeting of the midnight society was never declared closed.
This story was told by Sam.
Zeebo: At the beginning of the story, the manager calls Felix "Zeebo". Zeebo is a clown from the earlier Are You Afraid Of The Dark episode "The Tale of Laughing in the Dark."
S 5 : Ep 11
Aired 2/3/96
S 5 : Ep 9
Aired 1/20/96
S 5 : Ep 1
Aired 10/7/95 (25:00)
S 4 : Ep 10
Aired 12/10/94
User Score: 147
User Score: 691
User Score: 471
User Score: 414
User Score: 117
User Score: 114
User Score: 69
User Score: 56
User Score: 35
User Score: 34