So, when they brought back Are You Afraid of the dark? I think I watched maybe two episodes. Then one day I caught them airing these three episodes. I totally thought they were the series finale but I see now that I was wrong. But I was totally shocked by these ones. They were SO great compared to the other ones I had seen of the new seasons. Granted, I hadn't seen many at the time but I've caught up on those episodes & good they weren't. I thought this story line was actually really fun because we got background to the midnight society & well Gary was in it. Surprising that these are the best episodes from those seasons? I think not. Of course it was since it had one of the old members in it besides Tucker.