I don't understand Arthur Godfrey's apparently huge power and popularity in the early 50's that propelled him to several shows including a weekday morning series, all with the same cast of singers, Marion Marlowe, Julius LaRosa, Haleloke, Frank Parker, The Mariners Quartette, The McGuire Sisters, etc. He was on the cover of TV Guide dozens of times, second only to Lucille Ball, and maybe more times if you counted in the pre-national(1953) issues.
He was ppresented as a quirky, folksy guy who loved to play a ukelele. He was just a regular kind of guy who charmed sponsors by gentle kidding. His cast were referred to as his "Family" or "The Little Godfreys".
In reality, that's not the story. Arthur Godfrey is to this day probably best known for his live, on-air firing of Julius LaRosa for his "lack of humility". This was seen as quite shocking to the audience, but if you spend any time with the old Kinescopes of the programmes, you will see that Godfrey and his performers are closer to a cluster of scared court jesters trying to keep their king amused.
The set of him morning show, "ARTHUR GODFREY TIME" has Arthur on an elevated chair and desk as his cast sits in rows of theatre type seats facing him. They do all their numbers in a certain sequence, and quitely, politely return to their seats. Arthur seems to have them riveted to whatever topic he rambles on and on about, until he runs out of steam. Nobody interrupts him, nobody kids around with him. they speak only when spoken to. Things that his "Family" do say to him are often held to ridicule, though they aren't ridiculous people. They're scared people.
One often can't tell if he's happy with them or not; he speaks in a monotone, and wears a sleepy, half smirk all the time, as if he's endlessly sizing up his next opponent.
The fake smiles and nervous laughs of the cast is unpleasant. In one extant segment, Arthur has Frank Parker called up to the mike, and says he thinks that there's going to be some changes made around here. the poor guy's fake happiness desolves, he visibly sweats and swallows hard. It's chilling. Arthur doesn't say what he's got in mind, and moves on to new business. Maybe he just needed a mini-power trip to get through the hour. Maybe that was considered high dramatic entertainment. Eventually he sacked nearly everyone on his shows. It's clammy televiewing.
Conversely, when "Artha" is absent for the day, and substitute M.C.s like Robert Q. Lewis or Peter Lind Hayes take over, Everyone is bright and cheerful and having a good time; they laugh and can talk freely with their guest host, and a relaxing feeling of sheer relief can be felt. When Godfrey imploded on himself, and dropped from the tube, It was all for the better.