Threatening to take a wrong turn again...
5.0
"Mediocre"
As a set-up for the season finale, LDYB-1 again demonstrates the weakness of this entire series. We\'re reliant on plotlines that served as padding for the first 5 episodes when Adama was out of action (\"resistance\" on Caprica), and a filler linking us to off-camera goings-on that again rings hollow (Tyrol\'s \"am I a Cylon?\").
Indeed, compare this episode with Season\'s 1\'s Kobol\'s Last Gleaming 1, and you can see how far things have slipped. KLG-1 represented the culmination of all the plot strands that had been cultivated throughout season 1, bringing them together in a powerful, intense and moving two-parter that catapulted the storyline into what should have been immensely powerful new arcs. My main problem with LDYB-1 is that it kicks back to the whole resistance thing on Caprica. Sorry, but this, and the \"breeding farms\" has never hung together for me. Perhaps I\'m biased as RDM did admit the resistance idea spun out of fans\' demands for such, rather than being a natural outgrowth of the story. Throughout season 1, the Cylons were cold-bloodedly bent on the extermination of humanity, totally nuked-out the 12 colonies and would no doubt worked hard to stamp out any attempts at resistance - yet hey presto, here on Caprica we have not only a highly-organised resistance movement - but one made up of pampered sports stars who in a remarkably short period of time have not only managed to train themselves very thoroughly, they\'ve also managed to get themselves well-armed. Erp. Sorry, doesn\'t work from where I\'m sitting.
Leaving these gripes aside, the whole SAR mission is still questionable. To quote Trek: The Needs of the Many and all that. Throughout Season 1, Galactica was stressed out due to her lack of Vipers and Raptors. Okay - so now the Pegasus has arrived, presumably with the majority of her fighter and recce squadrons intact - but that still doesn't mean they have ships to spare, and yet at the outset, they can muster around 17 Raptors. Whichever way you look at it, that must be the fleet's entire contingent of the craft. Risking ALL of them on a SAR mission of questionable outcome is simply not good military thinking.
Certainly, sending 17 Raptors, each with at least 4 crew each aboard to satisfy Kara Thrace's promise is bordering on a monumental military blunder. As we've seen elsewhere, Raptors form an essential part of the fleet's search and recce ops. Putting so many at risk in one go is certainly reducing the fleet's current and future capabilities and options. There are other major flaws surrounding the "rescue" mission as well, but these I'll leave for now. Even without mentioning them, the whole thing doesn't hang together. The only thing of the remotest interest is whether the Download/Six and Download/Sharon are with the resistance... Then there is Tyrol. OK - there were mutterings about his potential identity in some quarters following the revelation surrounding Galactica/Boomer, but throughout it all, his actions suggested that at his core, he has never seriously considered himself to be Cylon. In this, he\'s been as stoic as Helo. Yets here, boom-bang-a-bang, he\'s suddenly saddled with all of Galactica/Boomer\'s doubts and insecurities. If this is to lead to the revelation that he is indeed a Cylon, then it is at best a clumsy manipulation of the audience (\"see, he\'s not a Cylon - oh, frak! he IS!\"). If it is an attempt merely to introduce Dean Stockwell\'s character (whose choice of phrasing at times strongly suggests he IS a Cylon), then it is a very weak and is again a clumsy means of handling the introduction. Where this story does shine is in the political intrigue. The election is rife with the tensions that made some much of Season 1 an explosive mix. Why the writers didn\'t focus on this - perhaps counterpointing Roslin\'s state of mind now to how she had been in KLG more strongly - we\'d have had an outstanding episode. Certainly, the interactions between Baltar and Zarek, and Six\'s responses to Zarek make their scenes very beautifully crafted, and worthy of the best of Season 1. But even here there is something jarring. Caprica/Sharon wants to help the humans - or at least, help Helo. There is no way she CANNOT know the truth behind Baltar\'s betrayal - yet never once has she mentioned it, not even in passing to Helo. If the reason for this turns out to be because she is \"indebted\" to him for trying to save her baby after Roslin ordered her pregnancy terminated, than I for one am going to be disappointed. Overall a return to the middle-of-the-road storytelling that has marked far too much of this season. Perhaps a cut above many earlier episodes, but certainly a long way below the standards set in the last couple of weeks. And for those who thing this episode is \"revealing\" or \"outstanding\" - I politely suggest you go back and watch Season 1 and particularly Kobol\'s Last Gleaming 1 & 2. I think you\'ll find the shine quickly fades on this episode after you do...