Battlestar Galactica

Season 1 Episode 9

Tigh Me Up, Tigh Me Down

7
Aired Friday 10:00 PM Mar 04, 2005 on Syfy
SUBMIT REVIEW

Episode Fan Reviews (19)

8.4
out of 10
Average
791 votes
  • The one where: Tigh's other half joins the fleet.

    4.0

    A slight reprieve from the recent batch of drama-heavy event episodes, the hour's frilly-nillyness is ultimately its own undoing. Bill Adama is acting slightly off, and given Leoben's startling claim during the last episode (that the old man is a toaster), it's only adding fuel to Roslin's fire. It turns out that Adama is off his game because he had received Intel that Tigh's wife, Ellen, was found on The Rising Star ship. Could she be a cylon?


    Any attempt to ring drama from Roslin doubting Bill, and Bill's suspicions that Ellen is a cylon herself, are completely mute by a meandering script and some very forced slapstick comedy. Let this be a lesson for future episodes: BSG is not a comedy, nor should it ever try to purposely be funny. When the humour is subtle, and within the context of a humorous/mad character (ala Baltar), it's fine. But here, the ''funny'' moments gravitate around emotional heavy-weights, Roslin, Tigh, Lee and Adama. Watching Tigh chuckle like a little school kid was bizarre, sure, but there's only so much mileage you can get from two relatively old people acting like teens.


    The ending is also purposely vague. We never find out if Ellen is a cylon or not. For another time, I suppose.


    Spoilerish Title Sequence: 7 mins and 19 secs into the episode.


    Frak-O-Meter: 3 fraks. Ellen and Bill both warn each other with ''Don't frak with me''.


    Cylon Sex: Gaius lets off some steam with a fairly racy sequence that doesn't show any activity whatsoever, but the implications are more than enough, especially the way Six was leaning once Starbuck interrupted his little romp.

    Spot the six: Head-Six shows up, as well as Cap-Six. The former suspects something is amiss with both Starbuck and Ellen. She's been right about pretty much everything else so far. The latter fights back a few tears of jealousy over Boomer's budding romance with Helo.


    Death/Injuries: Everyone gets to keep their limbs.

    Boomer or Sharon?: Sharon wins here, for no reason other than Boomer doesn't feature.


    Ships Lost: A raider almost crashes into Galactica. Almost.


    Battlestar Bleakness: We briefly deal with more suicide bombers. And it was kinda icky listening to Ellen mourn the loss of Zack while simultaneously groping Lee.

    The hour slows the entire season down a notch or two. It's mostly forgettable stuff.

Tuesday
No results found.
Wednesday
No results found.
Thursday
No results found.
More
Less