Harvey has been seeing a fortune teller named Rosalind for quite some time. Almost everything she has told him has come true. Therefore, Eddie and Shauni pay Rosalind a visit. Rosalind predicts that Eddie will meet his first true love. She assures him that it´s not Shauni. Eddie doesn't believe this at first until one day when he spots a woman on a sailing-boat drawing just like the woman he had a relationship with back in 1985. Her name is Lorna Cosgrove. Eddie tracks down the sailing boat but when he meets Lorna, she denies knowing him and tells him that her name is Caitlin. Her boyfriend Roger is also on the boat.
Eddie leaves but the next day, he receives a painting from a boy. This was the painting Lorna drew that year on Nantucket Island. He sees her on the jetty and goes to talk to her. She tells him that she couldn´t reveal her true self while Roger was on board. Apparently, he doesn´t know everything about her past. However, Lorna is in trouble and she asks Eddie to remember everything that happened when they were last together.
When Rosalind sees death in Eddie´s future, Shauni goes to Garner. Garner finds out that Lorna is wanted for the murder of her husband Phillip Scott. She has been on the run ever since. When Eddie finds out about this, he confronts Lorna about it.
Suddenly, Eddie remembers that Roger entered the apartment the same night and that he is the murderer. Roger tries to escape in a speed boat but Eddie chases him. When Roger falls over board, Eddie is there to knock him out. It turns out that Roger murdered Phillip because he was jealous. Roger wanted to live Phillip´s life.