It was a powerful episode. However, I do not think it was the best episode ever. Actually, I have my three medals and nothing will change it. But I want to make a stand why I think this episode was good and why it was bad.
9.0
Well, first thing - I think it was first time when Booth actually called Brennan by her name. It was cleverly used to later show a contrast between her "real" name (although I do not fully agree with the theory that you are what your name is - I mean, one is who he/she are and there is nothing to define him/her). I may be wrong though, but it was nicely done. The plot is very good, but a little too deep if you ask me. And her father calling at the end? I have a feeling it soon will become a case of some highly respected people turned into bunch of burglars by force or something like that, and that would be bad. I mean, they made they bank robbers, let's stick with it. No one is perfect, so were/are (?) her parents. The big fight with her brother or the fact that her brother is actually shown and referred to is amazing. It's like combining those little pieces of puzzle to have the real truth about Brennan emerge. Their relationship was greatly shown, up to the moment when after 15 years of anger and denial, they suddenly hug as if nothing happened. If I was in his shoes (if I was in hers I would go and talk to him as well), I'd answer, after she asked him to stay for a couple of days, I'd answer "I will visit you next week" or something like that. Only to show that trusting people again takes time.
Great Booth action. Especially after Brennan was talking to Angela about Marco Polo game and that she likes when someone cares about here, if she's okay and where she is, and right in this moment Booth calling her name and making sure she is there. It was sweet. It was like he's always there for her, but they both do not realize that they actually exist that close to each other.
Some stand-in Brennan moments were great - like that one in the shed, when she burst into tears after being called by her "real" name several times. It proved to me that Brennan actually is very weak as a person. She only poses as this tough-ass chick that knows martial arts and can handle an attacker all by herself. It was shown before in the episode "Two Bodies in the Lab" when she was almost killed - she showed some tears and actual fear in that episode, and it was great. Here it is proven again. She is weak and fragile (probably shaped into her current image by the very case of her parents disappearance), lonely inside, despite having friends and, as an addition, private knight in shining FBI standard-issue body armor. She is just like most people, and - more importantly - she is like me. Maybe that is why I dig that show so much, even if I don't have my private FBI Booth to protect me... Again - she is weak, fragile, lonely, freaked out about life and only creates the image of herself for people to stop them from asking questions. But occasionally, someone asks a question, usually Booth or Angela. And Brennan is confused. In this episode, she revealed herself, revealed that is indeed not as strong as she makes herself to seem.
About friends - the team, working on the case to help solve the mystery, was genuine and very cheerful thing to include. I must say I have same bad experience with both people you work with and people you call "friends" for quite some time until they screw you upside-down without even warning you. It was both comforting and encouraging to see them bonded up together for one case. And I'm sure she would do the same for them. I pray for episodes like that. Mostly, probably, so Brennan could help Booth at some point.
The book plot was very clever and entertaining. And the ending was quite brilliant. Not to mention some facts: 1) Booth smile, 2) Brennan not wanting to show it to Booth because of the dedication, 3) David teasing Booth about the book. But, most of all, the fact the she dedicated the book to him. For me, it meant more that giving it to review to David. Extremely smart to use it in the last episode of the season.
But, aside of those good points of the episode, I spotted some mistakes or just malfunctions of it. The changes in parents' story were too quick and sort of jumped into conclusions. I mean, Russ says "No way mom cheated on dad" and suddenly we got ourselves another story. It was not very believable for me. I also can't buy that Russ-abandoned-me story, then the twist change and their sudden reconciliation. It was too quick, and - for that sort of anger that firstly burst - too easy and quiet. I must say I was happier with the story that Russ actually abandoned her because it was that hard on him. I mean, people do have different ways of coping with problems. I admit I've never been in a situation like this so I can't possibly imagine how it is like to have your parents disappear. But I was ready to believe that leaving his life behind, even if that meant abandoning his sister, was Russ's way. That actually made him human. And Brennan had every right to be angry with him, but I think it was great material for some of other storylines. But, most of all, I expected something more emotional, more romantic between Booth and Brennan to happen. Don't get me wrong, I didn't expect them to hit the sack together, no - it would be false and, just, not good at all. But some more of hugging or touching would be nice. Last time they reached the stage when she touched him in consolation. Here, with such a case, I expected more.
And, at the end, I hated the end! I mean, not the actual end, but the cliffhanger. I didn't expect it, so I got me crazy!
I hope there is someone willing to read what I've just typed, because I am really proud of my review. So, feel free to comment on it and polemize. I'm open for discussion. No dirty images here.