This is not "my Bones" anymore. It's still funny, still quirky but different, it lost what made me interested in it and it's slowly turning into another CSI clone. There are dozens of shows like that on TV but there was only one Bones. Not anymore.
6.5
I'll start at the very end. When they'd gotten rid of Zack (in such a cruel, cruel way), after my initial anger passed, my first thought was: "at least they didn't break Angela and Hodges up." Well, wasn't that just tempting the faith! Birimbau's arrival was unexpected but not unwelcome; in my mind, especially after he himself admitted that the universe wants Angela to be with Hodges, he appeared on the show just to put a huge, flashy full-stop after the sentence we've been repeating since day one – that they are perfect for each other.
The fact that neither Angela nor Hodges fought for the relationship that for over one season was portrayed as almost perfect, is nothing more than a sloppy, lazy writing. With Zack the writers have an excuse (that after hearing some of the justifications of why they've turned Zack into a serial killer is nothing more than just that – an excuse) – the strike, here, you just feel that they had no idea of how to break them up, they just wanted it to happen, so they made it happen. Angela and Hodges gave up on their relationship in 6 sentences. They didn't look sad, angry or desperate – they looked just bored; there was no tension, no drama, no nothing just a resignation so very unlike this passionate, lovable couple. It's so hard to believe they would give up on each other like that, that it simply is unbelievable. The whole previous characterization of them and their relationship went down the drain and is now heading towards the North Sea. No points for that.
Now Sweets. I liked him, now every time he appears I want to punch him. His character is too annoying to be a regular! He works well as an occasional quirky comic relief but to have him all the time is just unbearable, especially since you know that there's more to come. Why couldn't they make him the killer? Just imagine the scene when he is discovered and his expression changes from his usual half-goofy/half-clueless, into an angry, hardened,evil mask. It would have been glorious.
Then there's Clark. When Clark substituted for Zack at the beginning of series 3, I wanted to hate him but couldn't. Quite surprisingly, I accepted him straight away and was a bit disappointed when he disappeared after this episode, hence my gratefulness when I saw him again in series 3, especially since it was established that he had found himself a new job. Seeing him, without any explanation, as Zack's replacement again, made my blood boil but just for a second. Of course they would choose Clark, who else could have they chosen? I was a bit jarred when it seemed that Clark's previously established personality, was being changed into something that looks like Zack's – I hate when one character is being replaced by another that has exactly the same characteristic traits, particularly if it happens because of some rapid, unexplained personality transplant. However he seemed more like himself in the episode two, so he got my interest and support again ... only to quit. Good choice, boy! Run while you can!
I liked how Zack was mentioned at the beginning but then nothing, not a single word, glance or gesture from any other character that would establish they remember and miss him. Look, let's face it, Zack had absolutely NO character development in the whole series, not a single episode featured him even close to the spotlight. Even after he came back from Iraq, when it seemed obvious they would now play the "poor traumatised boi" card, there was NOTHING! NOTHING at all! They picked it up and the dropped it like it's hot. Ugh!
There were good points – like Booth's rant on the motorway – but the whole thing just didn't work. Bones does not cut it as a serious drama because it worked hard for 3 seasons to distinguish itself from all the other criminal shows on TV by not doing personal drama at all. Yes, there was an arc with Bones' dad but it worked because it was a vital part of who Bones is – it was what made Tempe Tempe and it did not change her character in any way, it cemented it, while making her a bit more human. It was a positive development.
"Bones" is a different show now - still funny, still quirky but different, it lost what made me interested in it and it's slowly turning into another CSI clone. There are dozens of shows like that on TV but there was only one Bones. Not anymore.