A Breaking Bad Community
AMC (ended 2013)
Landing the “role of a lifetime” is every actor’s dream, and for good reason. When the lines between character and actor fade so completely that the two are synonymous, this is when fame and recognition set in. Audiences love to meet a character whose appearance, demeanor, mannerisms, and dialogue speaks to them — it only makes sense that the person who takes the writer’s creation and delivers it to the masses becomes fused with the character. Unfortunately, that same person’s identity can also disappear. Typecasting has always taken a toll.

There’s no need to paint a typecast actor’s life as one of immense suffering and existential angst — at the end of the day, Michael Cera is still wildly successful and rich. What’s interesting to examine, however, is whether actors that become typecast can ever break free from the spell. History and conventional wisdom say no, not entirely. Rather, there seems to be a spectrum along which typecast actors fall. On the left you’ve got actors who will forever be one character, and on the right, you’ve got actors who early on were wildly famous for one role, yet later demonstrated a great range that wiped away any aspects of pigeonholing.

It doesn’t require completion of Econ 1A to smartly guess which direction the spectrum skews toward. Landing the role of a lifetime is hard enough. Continuing to act in strong, diversified roles for a meaningful time afterward is nearly impossible—especially on TV. Take Kiefer Sutherland for example. At age 34, he landed the iconic role of Jack Bauer, the badass, death defying (even when his heart stopped beating) Counter Terrorist Unit field agent. 24 went on to be one of the most successful shows Fox has ever produced, lasting eight full seasons and securing an Emmy for Bauer — I mean Sutherland — in 2006.



Sutherland is now 46 years old, and hasn’t had a durable role since 24 went off the air in 2010. He did star in Touch, a thriller that centered on a former reporter and his emotionally disturbed/brilliant son’s fascination with numbers and ability to predict tragic events. But that was short-lived. Perhaps not coincidentally, the show’s cancellation was followed up by another instance of the TV industry’s recent nostalgia spell with a renewal of 24 for 12 episodes in 2014. If Sutherland wants to branch his career out, so far he hasn’t showed he can.

Similarly, Jon Hamm is an actor defined by one iconic role that he landed relatively late in his career. It’s hard to imagine he’ll ever shake Don Draper from the minds of viewers when he steps in front of any camera after Mad Men ends in 2015, but give the man some credit for A) taking on numerous comedy roles in between MM seasons, and B) sporting incredible good looks. He’ll be just fine.

One of the most talented actors on TV today, and in Hollywood as a whole, makes for the most intriguing typecast story in recent memory. That would be Bryan Cranston, fresh off his masterful performance as Breaking Bad’s ultimate anti-hero, Walter White. Until 2008, Cranston was super-glued to the goofy, gaffe-prone Hal, father of Frankie Muniz and four others in Malcolm in the Middle. When BB creator Vince Gilligan pushed for Cranston as the lead in his dark drama (he had worked with Cranston on an episode of the X-files and knew he could play serious), AMC execs couldn’t get the image of Hal shaving his body out of their heads. Little did they know the man in the whitey tighties had range.



Save for a few Walter White witness protection jokes about him becoming Hal in Malcolm in the Middle, Cranston had completely eradicated his former typecast role by the end of Breaking Bad. This begs the question: do other famously typecast actors have hope? Let’s have a vote on who has the best chance to break free, shall we?

poll

Shame on you if you cast a vote for Kelsey Grammer. Including him was pure novelty. The guy played literally the same character on two long-running shows, and also appeared as Frasier periodically on various shows like The Simpsons. In all seriousness, typecasting is a curious phenomenon. Many actors even admit to it just being a part of the job, while others can’t stand it. It appears only the cream of the crop can ever escape it.

Victor Beigelman is a writer for Thelma, an online pop culture manifesto. Follow him on Twitter @vbeigelman. If you have thoughts about other typecast actors not included, say so in the comments below!
38 Comments
Comments (38)
Submit
Sort: Latest | Popular
You must not have seen Boss. Kelsey Grammar got my vote.
And like somebody below mentioned, Michael C. Hall, from David Fisher to Dexter Morgan to...
Reply
Flag
How about David Duchovny? He played Fox Mulder on The X Files for almost 10 years, but was able to lose that typecast and role right into a completely different one, Hank Moody, and has been doing that for 6 years now.
2
Reply
Flag
Staff
Kristen Bell as Veronica Mars
Reply
Flag
I think Michael C. Hall did a great job being Dexter after being the totally different David Fisher.
As for typecasting, I'm afraid most of the Star Trek-actors will always be their Star Trek-character....
3
Reply
Flag
Staff
Sarah Michelle Gellar will forever be Buffy Summers. And she seems to be embracing that legacy more now that she did when the series had just ended. Maybe it's the fact she hasn't had the greatest career post-Buffy (I'm not hating, because I love SMG), but it's nice to see that.
8
Reply
Flag
The question now is will Cranston be typecast all over again? I think if he can find the right role, people will accept him in it. His next project is playing Lyndon Johnson on Broadway. If he nails that, and I think he will, it'll prove to anyone who sees it that he has the necessary range if they don't already believe it.
4
Reply
Flag
I feel like Jennifer Aniston is always playing some version of Rachel, albeit in movies now.
7
Reply
Flag
For a while after the X-Files ended it looked as if David Duchovny and Gillian Anderson would struggle to break away from their Mulder and Scully. But its twenty years later and now David has carved another niche - albeit a smaller one - for himself on Californication and it looks like Gillian is breaking through again with wonderful roles on various shows - Hannibal, The Fall (though admittedly as various iterations of the Strong Female Cop/Figure of Authority).

That said, none of those roles would ever be as iconic as Mulder & Scully, a fact acknowledged by them both and the rabid X-Files following that still show up at various comic-cons and anniversary celebrations.
3
Reply
Flag
How can the cast of Game of Thrones be typecasted? They don't last long enough to be typecast.
7
Reply
Flag
Well, maybe Lommy's Eros Vlahos has been typecasted as an apprentice after Da Vinci's Demons but, to be fair, he's just not old enough to be a maester.
Reply
Flag
Really great point. Red Wedding tears, man.
2
Reply
Flag
The Boss. Kelsey Grammer carried that show and showed no hint of Frasier.
3
Reply
Flag
True, not to mention his Broadway stuff.
Reply
Flag
The Game of Thrones gang, if anything they are already breaking types in the detective genre (Natalie Dormer's Moriarty, Elementary), Sci-fi movies (Nikolaj Coster-Waldau, Oblivion), classic horror (Michelle Fairley, The Others) and so on without breaking a sweat.
1
Reply
Flag
Yeah... most of the the actors there already have some kind of a tv/ movie resume pre-GoT and they'll slip right back into that post-GoT. I can't watch Game of Thrones without thinking Oh Hey Its That Guy from some rom-com/ horror flick/ etc.
1
Reply
Flag
"Tyrion" is going to be in the upcoming X-Men movie, "Robb Stark" in both Klondike (a period drama) and Cinderella (a romantic movie), "Orell" is starring on Being Human, etc.

Not to mention, "Cersei" on Sarah Connor Chronicles, "Lord Baelish" on Batman, "Ygritte" & "Ser Jorah" on Downton Abby, etc.
Reply
Flag
Poor "Tyrion", always typecast as a little person...
Reply
Flag
So Tyrion is playing a giant? Good for him, might take a fair bit of CGI though...
Flag
Bolivar Task was a giant, en evil one but a giant nonetheless (and so were his robots)
Flag
Kelsey Grammer was magnificent in Boss, totally devious. It's a pity the show didn't last.
1
Reply
Flag
Totally agreed – I really would've liked to see more of that :-/
1
Reply
Flag
Staff
I was tempted to vote for Frasier just because ;)
Reply
Flag
I love this topic.

Some favorites that never escaped their characters.

From Seinfeld:




Reply
Flag
And do you think Jerry Seinfeld can be anything but a stand-up comic?
Reply
Flag
Well, I'm not sure he's really ever set out to be an actor who can tackle new roles.

Jason Alexander had a half dozen attempts at starring roles post-Seinfeld and The Michael Richards Show lasted 7 episodes in total. Very different cases.
1
Reply
Flag
Pretty sure Rainn Wilson will always be Dwight.


1
Reply
Flag
And Danny Pudi will always be Abed.


1
Reply
Flag
Staff
Aaron Paul will forever be Jesse Pinkman

4
Reply
Flag
Staff
I'm not sure I'm really upset about that one.
2
Reply
Flag
Staff
I'll be interested to see if Aaron Paul can break that one!
7
Reply
Flag
Follow this Show
Members
7,880