My friend and I have this ongoing debate where she thinks that Supernatural is better but I think Buffy is better. This may be biased since I'm posting this thread on the Buffy forum, but I'm sure many of you have seen SPN since both of the shows are quite similar. So do you think Buffy is better?
I personally think Buffy is better because it's definitely better writing, and it's not so serious. I mean, it has lots of drama and stuff, but sometimes when it gets too serious, it's like the characters know it is and they lighten the mood up. It's really realistic in that sense. Plus, it's more original with their demons and "monsters of the weeks". I also read somewhere that the creator of SPN is a big fan of Buffy so it doesn't surprise me that SPN is very similar.