I certainly have no problem with her being emotional about losing Riley, but she's never really this cartoonish/corny about it. I mean, really, the "Their love...will last...forever" thing was just a bit tooooo over the top for me.
But I certainly appreciate hearing different opinions--and being able to debate our perspectives in a very respectful, intelligent manner. That's what I've always loved about BtVS and its fans. I mean, if you say one bad thing about a single episode over on the Lost forums, you're automatically pegged as a hater or a troll. Good to know people over here aren't nutjobs like them.
And I of course think Buffy > Lost. Just thought I'd mention that in a place where many people will hopefully agree.