Buffy the Vampire Slayer

Season 1 Episode 3


Aired Tuesday 8:00 PM Mar 17, 1997 on The WB

Episode Fan Reviews (66)

Write A Review
out of 10
961 votes
  • intro to Witches hits buffy

    The shows starts introduce the first non-vampire supernatural creature. That's not worse but the witch start attacking people on the cheerleading team first, one girl, then Cordelia and finally Buffy. Not only do the witch hurt people on the cheerleading team, she switches bodies with her own daughter. If your into witches then this episode is for you
  • ooo, hey, juice! -- ooo, hey, witch!

    first episode without any vampire in it. I guess it's the first epi I have memory about since 1998. and it's really good. I mean, till certain moment I had no clue that Amy was actually Catherine -- her mother... full of funny moments again: "Macho Man" song, Xander and Willow saving Buffy... and full of cheerleading that I admire! it's easy watching and completely unforgettable. plus, shows us why people can still afford a house in Sunnydale: first vampires -- now witches :) actually, that is something that doesn't depend on living near the Hellmouth -- it's just about the human nature, at least I think so.

    FAVE SCENE: Buffy's morning "Macho Man" song.

    FAVE QUOTE: Xander: I laugh in the face of danger. Then I hide until it goes away.
  • The third Buffy lurches a little as the show shifts from master-plot mode to monster-of-the-week mode.

    Still, "Witch" is an entertaining hour with a semi-clever twistone that I saw coming before it was officially revealed, but was still surprising to me when I first realized what was going onand an exploration of mother-daughter relations that helps flesh out who Buffy is.

    The main point of comparison is between Buffy's mom Joyce, a busy gallery owner who cares about her daughter but can't dedicate the time to keep up with all of Buffy's school activities and personal dramas, and Catherine Madison, the meddling ex-cheerleader mother of another Sunnydale student, Amy. When the main rivals for Amy's position on the cheerleading squad suffer bizarre ailmentsfire-hand, no-mouth, perpetual intoxicationBuffy and the gang suspect witchery on Amy's part. It turns out they're half-right. It's actually Catherine who's the culprit, becauseand here's the twistshe's taken over Amy's body!

    As I said, the twist is semi-clever, and capped by a cool ending that has Catherine trapped inside of one of her old cheerleading trophies. And while there's nothing especially revelatory about the message that mothers who try to re-live their youths through their daughters are no damn good, I liked the way "Witch" gives more definition to Joyce Summers, by subtly asking whether too little involvement is as bad as too much.

    The introduction of Amy gives Xander and Willow a little less to do in this episode, though Willow puts her web-surfing skills to good use, and Xander declares his crush on Buffy by giving her a bracelet. This pays off later in the episode when a wacked-out Buffy, suffering from a spell cast by Catherine/Amy, reveals that she likes Xander as a friend, and that she appreciates the bracelet because it comes from a friend, and not a suitor. Ouch for Xander.

    The only problem with the "like you as a friend" scene is that it gets to an emotional place that the rest of "Witch" doesn't even come close to approaching, though there was ample opportunity to do so via Buffy's sudden whim to join the cheerleading squad. Buffy's still pining for normalcy, and when Giles warns her not to "enslave yourself to this cult," I got psyched for a cogent critique of conformity, and how the popular crowd can be a bad model for Instead, Buffy got spell-hammered and injured some teammates. End of cheerleading storyline. Oh well.
  • Bad Parenting

    This is actually one of my favorite episodes of season one, just because of the ridiculous scenario of having a mother take over her daughter's body so she can cheerlead. It stays well in tune with the series' humor and allows for the supernatural entities to move beyond vampires, setting that standard viewers can come to expect for the rest of the show. It's not always about vampires, and sometimes the non-vamps are the more interesting.
  • The Witch

    With the introduction of the show out of the way, "The Witch" is left with the job of giving the viewer a taste of what it will look like on a regular basis. If I was watching this for the first time now I'd be left moderately entertained but not very critically impressed. What we have here is what I'd describe as an 'amiable' yet also fairly forgettable 'monster of the week' episode. It has a single neat twist that utilizes the "high school is hell" theme to tell a decent little story, but sadly also has minimal lasting relevance to both the season and the characters.

    "She said I was wasting my youth. So she took it," says an Amy stuck in her mom's body, a chilling statement no doubt; a statement that strikes at the core of what this episode is about. The supernatural is used as a springboard to say something about the human condition, in this case being parents who selfishly live through their children. One of the things that separate S1 from what the show eventually becomes is its focus on plot and ideas in abstract rather than character; rather than telling its story through characters we care about and have them learn alongside the viewers, the show is simply making its statement and then forgetting about it in the next episode. This is sadly true of most S1, and is ultimately one of the problems plaguing "The Witch."

    "The Witch" certainly earns some points for how it plays with its premise, but Amy happens to be one of the only recurring characters to get very little solid character development and psychological depth throughout the series, so what begins here doesn't end up being terribly relevant to her future beyond a basic level.

    With Amy's involvement being largely insignificant in the grand scheme of things, all that's left to remember the episode by is in its miniscule effect on the main characters. I do give it credit for at least taking a baby step towards a character-based approach. "Amy" tells Buffy that she trains hours with her mother for cheerleading, which causes Buffy to try to wedge open a connection with her own mother. I actually found Buffy's attempt sweet and Joyce's complete black-out of her daughter's desire for connection a little sad despite the eventual apology. Once Buffy finds out what Amy's mom did to her, though, she's not so quick to want her mom all gun-ho in her activities. Per usual, I think balance always wins the day. It'd be great for your parents to show some support in the things you love (provided they're not dangerous activities), but not so much that they put their own successes or failures from their own youth on your shoulders.

    Early in the episode Buffy tells Giles she wants to do something "safe," in regard to cheerleading. A good metaphorical lesson learned from "The Witch" is that sometimes "normal" isn't necessarily safe at all, and that the Hellmouth will make sure Buffy's life is always normal turned upside down.

    The only other relevant bits in "The Witch" include Xander's continued pining for Buffy despite her obvious lack of physical interest in him and his continued obliviousness to the fact that Willow totally digs him, which clearly makes him completely blind. How could you not find Willow here absolutely adorable and totally dateable? I mean, really.

    "The Witch" is a fairly enjoyable episode even though it's definitely plagued by S1's terrible production values, awful score, and psychological shallowness in relation to the characters. There's nothing specifically wrong with the episode's core; it just has so little lasting importance to the series from both a plot and a character perspective. It does have its moments, though, and sports a decent little self-contained plot. At the end of the day it's not very memorable but it does have just enough stuff to be a decent first stand-alone entry for the series.
  • No vampires this time, but that doesn't stop our slayer from kicking wicked butt.

    Here is our first episode of few in the series that contains absolutely no vampires. Is that a bad thing? No, actually. Buffy may be the Vampire Slayer, but she can still defeat any other evil being that gets in her way.

    So Buffy decides to become a cheerleader. She goes to try-outs where she meets Amy (who makes an important recurring role much later in the series). While one of the best of the girls try out, she suddenly sets on fire, luckily it was Buffy to the rescue. Later, many of the other cheerleaders begin getting into danger such as Cordelia's car crash due to sudden blindness, and the girl who, uh... Lost her mouth?

    Anyway, we soon find out it's because Amy is actually her evil, youth-stealing, wicked Mother in Amy's body (she's a witch, duh). Amy's mother switched bodies with her because she felt that Amy was wasting her youth, so she took it.

    I actually really love this episode, it's one (if not THE) favourite episode of mine from Season 1. Just like in previous episodes, Joss has been able to trick us with these awesome twists that we don't see coming. Actually, now that I think about it, pretty much every episode of Season 1 has some sort of twist to it. It's definitely not a bad thing though, it surely keeps us on our toes.

    Another thing that recurred in this episode is Joyce's worry of Buffy getting into trouble again like at her old school. It's good to know that Buffy's past has not totally been forgotten of. And let me just say that I love Joyce. She is my favourite parental figure on a TV show. She genuinely cares about her daughter, and she wants to trust her, even after the trouble Buffy has gotten into. She's not totally harsh on her, and is only when necessary. And although she's busy with her new job, she's still there when Buffy really needs her. She's just the perfect Mom.

    Something else to take notice in this episode is Willow's jealousy towards Xander's crush on Buffy. Buffy is clearly not very interested, but Xander is there giving Buffy jewelery and attempting to ask her out. I love how so early in the series we're seeing development in the characters. It makes them seem so much more alive and realistic. I watch other TV shows which aren't that bad at all, but in every episode, it's like the characters haven't changed at all. In "Buffy", the characters are somehow different in a way in every episode. Well, not really different, but they grow. They develop. Even though most of Season 1 are filler episodes, it doesn't stop the characters from growing.

    "First vampires, now witches. No wonder you can still afford a house in Sunnydale." - Xander Harris
  • Witch

    The Witch

    The good;

    Amy for the first time, yay! And even now she's still appearing in season 8. I always thought if Will died she'd have been a good replacement. Buffy looks sensational in her cheerleading gear, a shame we'll never see her in it again (and we won't see the costume again until Dawn digs it out in season 7). Willow gets more hands on with the axe and we have our first case of Wicca although it's a very dark variety. The African fertility statue gag is the first sign of the saucy humour Buffy and Angel will become famous for. Lovely scenes between Buffy and Joyce both at breakfast and in closing. I gotta say, I didn't see the twist at all.

    The bad;

    What happens to the poor girl whose mouth sealed up? Presumably all the aspects of Amy's mum's magic stop once she is defeated.

    Best lines;

    Willow; That girl's on fire!

    Cordy; Enough with the hyperbole

    Giles; Why would anyone want to hurt Cordelia?

    Willow; Maybe they met her?

    My favourite though;

    Xander; I laugh in the face of danger. Then I hide until it goes away

    Observations and questions; Presumably Amy mom dies properly when the school blows up and passes to the afterlife. Willow is already beginning to dress less nerdy. We see Giles' car for the first time, the Citreon whilst a design classic seems a weird choice for him, a classic Jag maybe more his style. Xander's Buffy obsession continues to grow. No Angel, you sometimes forget he's not in all the eps of season 1. At exactly what point do Amy and her mum swap bodies? Cordy hasn't passed her driving test yet but that changes by the end of the season


  • Buffy tries out Sunnydale High's cheerleading squad. It's a highly competitive try out, but when another competitor spontaneously combusts, and other eerie occurrences follow, Buffy and co. suspect a witch is at work. An excellent first regular episode...

    This review contains spoilers.

    When 'Buffy the Vampire Slayer' first aired on BBC Two here in the U.K. in 1999, I really enjoyed the Pilot ('Welcome to the Hellmouth' / 'The Harvest'), but was slightly weary that it would be one of those cases of a great Pilot that soon gets watered down and nosedives for the subsequent series. I needn't have worried – as 'Witch' perfectly demonstrates, 'Buffy' would always have plenty of engaging stories and lots of creative concepts to engross us.

    I know some don't like this one, and it was most definitely superseded as the series progressed, but for me, as a first regular hour-long instalment after the Pilot, it does superbly.

    As with the Pilot, Buffy herself here is likeable and funny (something that, I'll dare to say, I didn't find to be the case in some later episodes). Willow and Xander too are again very funny, adding just the right amount of humour to the proceedings.
    The script is sharp, with just the right balance of drama, comedy, mystery and mild horror, and is littered with the show's trademark pop culture references (I love "She's our Sabrina"), coming over as very amusing, not trying too hard to be cute or "cool" as was the case in late seasons.

    This episode also serves to show that – particularly in this first season – it's not just vampires that Buffy will be battling, but a much wider array of supernatural beings. There are no vampires at all in this one – which I don't mind, as it gives more variety – and that includes no Angel (which, as my reviews for the Pilot reflect, I can live with personally!). There is no reference to the Master or any of his minions; the overall season "big bad" story arc is much less prominent than it would be pretty much from the second season onwards.
    I disagree with a couple of other reviewers who class 'Witch' as a "filler episode" – the non-vampire, non-"big bad" thing was a common trait in season one, and far from being thrown in to bump up the episode count (as is the case with most fillers), I felt this one built on the premise set-up in the Pilot perfectly. And while I enjoy the on-going unfolding plots of later seasons, I also really like the many "stand alone" stories we get here in the first season or so.

    I found this to be a really engaging and well-executed story, and, on first viewing all those years ago, really didn't see the revelation of the Amy-and-her-mother body swap coming (though, on subsequent viewings, all the hints are there). Elizabeth Anne Allen puts in a great performance as young Amy – or rather, her mother in Amy's body; Amy will feature in a number of later stories (Allen, by the way, auditioned for the role of Buffy).
    I also personally enjoyed seeing Robin Riker; I'm a huge 1980s action-adventure TV fan, and Riker did many guest parts in those various shows, so it was good to see her again here, playing Amy-in-her-mother's-body (y'all following this?!).

    As I go through the DVDs, watching the episodes in original broadcast order, I am reviewing them "as I find them", and not rating them down simply because even better episodes came later (as I feel some other reviewers might subconsciously do sometimes). When I first watched this episode back in 1999, I really enjoyed it, and it really pulled me into the series; Viewing it tonight on DVD, I still seriously like it. Yes it would certainly be superseded by later episodes, but on its own merits, I like 'Witch' enough to give it a solid 10.
  • This episode is very exciting and interesting, one that is very fun to watch, and despite being a filler episode, is very good.

    This is the first episode to show us Buffy doesn't just battle vampires, but mystical forces of darkness as well. This week, Buffy and her friends are trying to stop a witch from messing with the cheerleading squad.

    This episode sees Buffy trying to fit in at Sunnydale High, as well as her attempting to be a cheerleader. We are introduced to Amy, who is suspected of being a witch, and who will play a role in future episodes. Highlights include Xander giving Buffy a braclet, suggesting that he likes Buffy as more than just a friend. Also, I love the scenes when Buffy goes and visit Amy's "mother", because that was just such brillantly done. Episode lowlights included them testing Amy to see if she was the witch, and most of the bits in the library - I do love the library, but not in this episode.

    A great episode which shows us Buffy not only saves the world from vampires, but from various forms of evil. An enjoyable episode to watch, very light and fun, and if you're not in a serious mood, the perfect episode to watch.
  • What is it with fully grown witches wanting the same things that teenage girls want, A pair of shoes, and to be a cheerleader.

    This episode shows that they won't only be dusting vamps but also facing witches, and also shows how evil humans can be, and how being on a Hellmouth can really bring that out in a person. The only thing about this episode is that it makes you think that all witches are bad, even though Willow will become one in about two years, though *SPOILER ALERT* If you watch season Seven and read season Eight, you will find that Amy will grow to be an evil witch herself. This is also the first episode not to include vampires, which is a rarity of Buffy the Vampire Slayer.All-In-All a pretty good episode!
  • Not a very good episode

    This episode wasn't really a good episode.. i believe it was just thrown in to fill the series... lol.
    Even though we got to see that Buffy would be fighting more than just vampires... i just think that it was a poor episode... and could have had alot done to it to make it a better one.
  • The Witch

    The Witch was another exciting episode of Buffy the Vampire Slayer. In this episode Buffy wanted to try out for cheerleading at Sunnydale High to have some thing normal to do like all the other teens. This news is welcome by her mother, but Mr. Giles has some reservations. It is fun to see how Buffy and Mr. Giles's Relationship is growing, and how they respond to each other. Girls start suffering from supernatural attacks, and the gang discover a Witch is behind it. Turns out Amy's mom was a cheerleading champion back in the day, and she wants to relive those moments, literally through her daughter Amy. At the end when she is about to use a spell on Buffy she reflects the spell using a mirror in the Lab. The Dark Place now has Amy's Mothers Soul, and it was quite an ironic place that it trapped her. The Dark Place must have a Dark sense of Humor. Another Classic Episode!!!
  • New day a new villian

    Thus one wasn't too bad.

    We got to see Buffy in a cheerleader outfit and few other other hot girls wondering around. The idea was ok too. a Mother wanting to relive her glory days as a cheerleader and turns to witch craft. She got revenge on the cheerleaders by casting spooky spells to get them out.

    One of victims is the nasty girl Cordilia and the spell made her flunk her driving test and make her eyes go white. Pretty scary. Plus she seems to have a pretty short term memory and doesn't seem to remember anything from the last episode.

    Plus Xander seems to be coping pretty well after stabbing his friend with a stake.
  • Season 1, Episode 3.

    Not a bad episode at all. Buffy wants to be a cheerleader, but there are a bunch of combustions and mysterious occurrences.
    Willow: She's on fire!
    Cordelia: Enough with the hyperbole!
    LMAO. Cordelia is awesome. She is just way too conceited, though. I liked Cordelia's little driving session. The plot for this episode was a little weird, though. I liked it though. It was still very entertaining to watch, thanks to Sarah Michelle Gellar and the awesome writing. It was extremely creepy when Cordelia couldn't see. Buffy singing Macho Man is a classic part of the series, in my opinion. I ALWAYS remember it when I think of Buffy. Good episode, and I liked the ending. :)
  • OK episode with more good dialog

    This episode was pretty decent. It also marks the introduction of recurring character Amy the witch. There were a couple surprises here and there and it continued to have some great dialog that is emblematic of the series. The scene where the UPS driver doesn't slow down when Cordelia is in the middle of the street could have been done better. It is kind of ridiculous to think he would just keep driving. They should have had Cordelia stumble out in front of the truck at the last moment. However, all in all it was a good, but not great episode.
  • When Buffy tries to make the cheerleading team, she soon finds herself investigating some strange and bizzarre things which happen to the other cheerleaders...

    The Witch remains to this day one of my favourite stand-alone Buffy episodes; their are so many neat one-liners, dramatic and creepy scenes (Buffy saving Cordelia from being road-kill being for instance. The mystery that surrounds this episode is never died down and the revelation that Amy's mother, Catherine Madison has switched bodies with her daughter to relive her dream is both surprising and makes for a very entertaining conclusion and battle scene at the end of the episode

    I also want to congratulate the spectacular guest stars: Elizabeth Anne Allen and Robin Riker (who play both Amy and her mothe respectably) as well as Kristine Sutherland who has some great one-liners and really conveys Joyce's concern for her daughter Buffy's wellfare spectacularly
  • Buffy tries out for Sunnydale High's Cheerleading squad, but one of the girls spontaneously combusts. Odd things begin happening to the cheering members and Giles suspects that a witch is to blame, mainly a girl named Amy Madison...

    I Love this episode! This was the first episode I ever watched, so it got me into Buffy the Vampire Slayer, my favorite television show of all time. The reason I love this episode is because I love the twist in it, the daughter and mother have switched bodies! I didn't see that coming AT ALL. I loved that character of Amy, she was a minor character, but an interesting and fun character. That's a main reason why I love this show. Joss Whedon can make even the minor character so complete and understandable. This is an instant classic for me. I can not praise this episode enough, it is that good. That is why this is my favorite episode of the entire series.
  • What do you get when you cross a witch, a cheerleader, and the plot for Freaky Friday?

    This is the first Buffy episode I've ever seen in its entirety (I just started watching Buffy from the start), so I thought I'd give it a try and watch this show since I already watch Charmed. As many other reviews mentioned what I like about this episode is that it briefly takes the focus away from vampires to other supernatural creatures (I had the misconception the show would be just about her kicking and stabbing random vampires every night).

    Although Charmed has been my favorite show, Buffy has a way of making the supernatural seem a bit more realistic and the stories more interesting since she has to rely more on her own resources than on powers.

    The plot twist in this episode was interesting and so was the fight sequence in the lab (some good telekinetic and vanquish/banish action).

    I didn't understand the end, but I will certainly keep watching this show and see what happens!
  • first encounter w/ the witch kind.

    buffy tries out for the cheerleading squad. amy seemed to be so damn serious about getting in & she's using some kind of spell to her advantage to make sure she'll get in. she wants to be just like her mom who was the cheerleading queen during her time. buffy found out that amy & her mom switched bodies & it's amy's mom who's really putting the show. w/ the help of the gang, they tried to reverse the spell & cast off amy's mom. then at the end, buffy & amy were talking at the school looking at the cheerleading trophy unaware that amy's mom was trapped inside.
  • Buffy must fight a witch.

    Something that Buffy the Vampire Slayer can capture is a feeling of both suspense and comedy. The characters really start to become interesting in this one, and the main plot is great for a third episode. There's this whole mystery about who the witch is, and there are a few twists and turns along the way. Though the special effects aren't the greatest, the episode recovers with its strong plot. Although this is a "normal" episode, it manages to be special in its own right. It is another improvement over the first two, so I look forward to where this Buffy world will take the plot next.
  • A witch who wants nothing more than to be a cheerleader ... again.

    This episode starts with Giles giving Buffy a lecture about wanting to join a "cult", being the cheerleading squad. Scene changes to a cauldron of green ooze. Then to the gym where heaps of girls are warming up for tryouts. Willow recognizes and old friend, Amy. Some great gymnast, Amber, tries out with Buffy, Willow and AMy watching, when she spontaneously combusts. Buffy quickly runs and puts out the fire. Giles and the scoobies try to figure out why and how Amber caught on fire. The following day the tryouts continue. In group routine Amy knock Cordelia over. Later in the hall, Buffy finds out that Amy's mother was a cheerleading champion when she was back in high school. Amy starts freaking that she's not as talented as her mother. Scene cuts to Amy in the locker room being confronted by Cordelia. She intimidates Amy about her screw-up in the tryouts. The cheerleading list gets posted. Cordelia makes the squad. Buffy gets first alternate. Amy gets third. Scene cuts again to the cauldron where someone is putting a spell on Cordelia. The next day, Cordelia walks around all zombie like. She goes for a driving lesson, still in her zombie state. She totally loses control of the cars. When she gets out she is almost hit by a truck, but Buffy saves her just in time. Cordelia's eyes go completely white and she can't see anything. Giles figures out that it's witchcraft. Buffy figures out that it's Amy because she desperately wants to be a cheerleader, so she's eliminating the competition. Giles finds a spell to make sure the witch is Amy. When they make the potion and spill it on Amy, it turns blue, proving she's the witch. But just after Buffy spills the potion on Amy, another student in their class starts making a fuss and when you can see her face, you see she has no mouth. You see Amy at home talking with her mother and she reveals that she has Buffy's bracelet. The nest day, Buffy starts her day in a particularly goofy mood. At cheer practice she is really un-co and goofy and she accidentally throws a girl across the room. Xander and Willow carry Buffy out. All of a sudden Buffy starts feeling really ill. Buffy and Giles go to Amy's house to try and get her spell book. Her mother answers the door and Giles starts grilling her about Amy. Buffy realizes that Amy is actually in her mothers body. Her mother had cast a spell so she could relive her glory days. Giles goes up to the attic to find all the evidence of all the spells cast. He collects all the dolls and the spell book. He, Buffy and Amy head back to the school, to the science lab where Giles starts to perform a reversal spell. Both Amy and her mother start to feel the reversal. Amy's mother takes off from cheerleading to find Giles and Amy. Willow and Xander try to stop her but she attacks them. Amy's mother breaks down the door to the science lab that Giles, Buffy and Amy are in just as Giles completes the spell. When Amy's mother tries to attack Amy, Buffy steps in to fight instead. Amy's mother tries to cast a spell on Buffy but Buffy knock down a mirror and the spell reflects back onto herself. Amy gets to live with her dad. Cordelia is back on the squad, attitude completely back to normal. Amy and Buffy stop by the trophy case where Amy's mum's display is and it looks totally normal, but just as they are walking away the eyes of the trophy move around frantically, so you know Amy's mum is safely locked up, for now. This episode was a nice change from vampires, I mean I know it's call Buffy the VAMPIRE Slayer, But the series never would have lasted as long if it were just constant vampires. It was a good start of the involvement of witchcraft, which comes onto the show more frequently later on. Best episode of the series so far.
  • The Chronicles of Cheerleading: The Loser, The Witch and the Whinning

    The Witch-It's time for cheerleader tryouts, and Buffy can't resist! However, when the girls start getting knocked out of the competition by spontaneous combustion, sudden blindness, and other freak accidents, Buffy and the gang begin to suspect that someone may be behind these not so normal occurrences. Could someone be using dark magicks in order to make the squad?

    Being the first non-vampire storyline of the series, "The Witch" is does well by introducing another new character, having some cool disturbing moments and mother/daughter issues. Amy makes for nice new face (who will have a much more recurring role in future seasons). You do feel bad for here as she just wants to leave up to her mother's expectations by becoming a cheerleader. Also, I liked the whole take on cheerleading in this episode. I loved how the teaser plays out so dramatic yet it's only Giles commenting on how ridiculous cheerleading is for a slayer. Also, we have Cordelia being very mean and petty to anyone who will stop her in her way to becoming a cheerleader. The creepy scenes had some pretty decent special effects for second episode of a series. The cheerleader combustion, eye-blinding, mouth disappearing, and spell casting scenes were cool. I especially loved the last spell Amy's mother casts on Buffy and how Buffy deflects it with a large mirror in the science lab.

    Also, there are some great sceneslike watching Xander commenting on Willow being "my guy friend who knows about girl stuff" only for Buffy to comment on Xander being "one of the girls", lol. It's also here we find Xander has a crush on Buffy which was a hopeless sub-plot from the start as you know they would never get together...ever! I also liked how Buffy and her mother had their little touching moments in this episode. All and All, a good-follow up to the premire.
  • Buffy deals with a pesky witch, who would have gotten away with it . . .

    Witch, was the very first episode of Buffy I ever saw and it is the reason that I watched the show; I loved it. I had seen Buffy the movie years before and really liked it, so when I turned on this episode and saw Buffy cheering I had a connection with her and the show immediately. I feel in love with Buffy when she and Giles went to Amy's house and Buffy realized that they switched bodies -- I knew that Buffy had evolved from the movie and the show was going to be something very special. And if I needed any more reason to like the show, it came during the fight with Catherine, when Buffy gets back up off the ground, tells Catherine that she "feels much better," and then knocks her across the room. I was hooked, and I couldn't wait to watch more. This episode aired over 10 years ago and I still want more Buffy :)
  • A very unique episode.

    For the third (or the second one) episode, I am surprised as to how original the plot of this episode is. Cheerleaders catching fire - the perfect way to break off from the intro. Joss couldn't have made a better way to continue smoothly from the two episodes of 'housekeeping'. In my eyes, this was the first 'fun' episode of the season (and the series). It didn't have much to do with the seasons plot and it showed us a lighter side to some of the characters. Everyone in this episode was hilarious and I'd be lying if I said I didn't enjoy this. Although, I didn't like this as much as the first two episodes, this stands out as a great episode.
  • This was the first fun episode.Introducing Amy the witch, get use to her because she will pop in and out throughout the series. She's fun. This episode gets us into the whole witchcraft/wiccan thing, which plays a bigger part in the series later on.

    I do enjoy watching this episode...I remember when it initially aired on tv, I thought, "wow, they have really changed directions with this show.", but that's not it at all. This episode lets the viewers know that its not just about vampires or The Master...It's about all the kooky creatures that go bump in the night. Fun show, loves it.
  • I laugh in the face of danger. Then I hide until it goes away.

    - You’re the slayer, and we’re like the slayerettes. –

    Witch is the first Buffy episode to do the thing no show does as well as Buffy: It takes an old idea (the body swap) and turns it into something fresh, fun and original. The best thing about Witch is the fact that it is so unpredictable. Whenever you have things figured out, there’s a twist and you’re back to zero. I’m not a huge fan of stand-alone, monster-of the-week episodes, but Witch really works for me, and as one of the first episodes of the series, it works as a way to set the tone of the series. It does establish the fact that Buffy fights so much more than vampires, it introduces the whacky fun of magic, and it further develops the relationships of the scoobies.

    I love the main plot, about the cheerleading, and the mad mom-witch. I also loved the fact that Cordy’s total bitca-ness is used to its fullest. Cordy was given many moments to shine, and had many great lines. I also liked Xander’s crush on Buffy, and his awkwardness and panic attacks gave many funny moments. The guest stars of the episode were also very good. Particularly Elizabeth Anne Allen and Robin Riker (Amy and her mom) gave outstanding performances, both as evil skank and good-hearted girl.

    The episode also developed the character of Joyce, who up until now hasn’t had a lot of do on the show. The relationship between Buffy and her mom has always been one filled with chemistry, and Witch is no exception.

    All in all, Witch is a fun and original episode, with many funny moments (Buffy singing Macho Man, anyone) and many twists and turns. A solid monster-of-the-week episode.
  • Buffy the Cheerleader

    Buffy, a cheerleader? That so doesn't seem like who she is, at least not anymore. But the episode does prove to be very humorous, after a witch casts a spell of several of the sunnydale cheerleaders including Buffy herself. For such an early episode in the series the bond between Buffy and Giles is cemented quite early, which is ofcouse part of the appeal of Buffy (the bonds between the characters, especially in the earlier seasons). As it turns out Willow's friend Amy is responsible, or is she? Another reason why this episode is unique is because it is the first introduction of witch craft into the series, which becomes a key theme for the series and the character of Willow later in the series.
  • Witches, I'm not surprised in the slightest. I mean, who wants to watch a whole season about just vampire slaying?

    When I first read the episode summary for Witch, I figured it was one of the original girls of the team who didn’t want to be replaced or something like that. That first chick who tried out for the cheerleading squad was a pretty remarkable dancer. Then her hands catch fire! Thankfully, Buffy was there to save the day.

    You know, I almost felt bad for Cordelia when she was robbed of her eyesight. Almost. When Amy tested positive for being a witch I figured she was innocent and that it was someone else doing all the witch craft. But, the next scene certainly proved that wrong. I was totally surprised when it turned out that Amy’s mom had switched bodies with her daughter to get a second chance at being a start cheerleader. Well, in the end she got her wish. She was trapped in the cheerleading trophy she won back when she went to school. This episode was totally wicked.
  • It wasn't as great as the pilot, but still it was fun.

    The first season consisted mostly of stand-alone episodes like this and I like that, Buffy had a lot of those episodes and they're often the best of the season (like Hush, Restless, the body, although in season three I thought the whole Faith-mayor story was great too) It was the first time that it showed Buffy wasn't going to be all about vampires but about all the intriguing creatures of the night and I thought it shows an original look on most. The introduction of the recurring caracter Amy was also fun and it was great seeing Buffy as the cheerleader she once was in LA.
  • When strange things start to happen to Sunnydale High cheerleaders, Buffy and friends suspect a witch may be behing them.

    This episode marks the first time Buffy faces a foe that is not of vampiric nature. The episode is well written, like every episode in the show's run, and is one of my favorites from the first season. This episode iintroduces us to Amy Madison (played by Elizabeth Anne Allen), who will become a reoccuring character in the seasons to come.
< 1 2 3