Canadian Idol

The judges said it. But remember this is a singing competition. Did not fall off my chair just yet with those ladies. Many of them are out of key and pitchy. Some of them also remind me the existence of Kareoke. No matter how bad they can screw up a song, the have powerfull voice. Contender like Martha Joy and Scarlett Burke really rely on that: mouth not ears.



In this kind of competition usually girls gives more goosebumps than that. I find it cold. The energy is missing. I'm curious so I watch every episode of the show, but no contestant (and this goes for the boys too) really "affect me". I watch them do their stuff but, I'm never anxious to see them perform, because they don't. Judges comments are totally unfair. Again, they were totally rude with Annika, because she is the straight girl of the Bunch and they don't want that on their show. I think once again, her voice was very good and powerfull. But if you notice, the judges never talk about her voice. She really tried hard doing what they ask her to do and they are still unhappy. She don't have the casting they want for the show and because of that, they are maybe ruining that poor girl's dream. I hope she sees what's going on. I can believe they call her immature and love what Montana is doing. Yes, Montana was good once or twice, but if she's playing that Johnny Rotten things over and over, it's gonna become very cliche. The Pistols were there 30 years ago, she was not even born, we were. Been there, seen that, can we evolve to something new now. Judges compaints about song choice, but again what about Montana. Did her last night performance really show us her "beautiful Voice" (remember about the singing competition). I use to like her because she was different, but now she starts to look very ordinary and not evolving as she suppose to in that show. Carly Rae Jepsen is maybe the highlight on the female side. But again, if she's going in that Betty Bo cliche stuff, here we go again. She's got the indie thing going on in a totally not Indie Show; We 'll see where it brings her.



I have a lot of faith in Mila Miller and I hoppe she will not lie back and continue to perform as much as she can. She gives me the impression that she knows she's got it and because of that, won't make as much efforts as to others to move forward in this competition. I think Khalila is doing a fine job too, but maybe she is working harder. So, my Top 5 for the female goes as follow: Mila, Carly, Khalila, Tara and Annika.



2 must go, so let's say Scarlett and Naomi (she Performs but can't really sing) .