Leo is in charge of deciding on a gift for the Cpt. Block's 25th wedding anniversary, and insists on getting a cheese knife. But when Toody and Muldoon have to deliver paperwork to the captain at his home, they find that their boss collects antiques. He shows them an outlandish chair, and tells them how he wishes that he had the other half of this one and only pair. Shortly thereafter, Toody finds a chair just like it at an auction, and plans on getting it for the captain without regard to cost.