Season 3 Episode 1

A Deadly Affair

Aired Monday 10:00 PM Sep 20, 2010 on ABC

Episode Fan Reviews (6)

Write A Review
out of 10
419 votes
  • An alright start.

    Maybe I'm the only one but I found Kate a bit annoying "he said he'd be back in the fall and it's fall so clearly he has better things to do" like I'm sorry Castle didn't HAVE to call you first.. it is your precint, maybe he was thinking that since you hadn't called it'd be rude for him to just show up? As far as he knows you're with Demming and he wanted to give you your space... like I'm sorry but to me Castle did nothing wrong in not calling. At least from what we know at the start.

    Sure he could've called, but it does go both ways. Same with Alexis' situation. Unless someone specifically says "I'll call you" and they don't, then it's just as much your responsibility to call as theirs. So I thought the hate on Castle was completely ridiculous. But I liked how they brought him back in. I've always liked that they had ways of making sure Castle comes back to the team in a good way and not just "oh he called the mayor - well fine".

    While Castle being at the scenes is yes suspicious she was also being a bit ridiculous and over the top in her behaviour and questioning. And jeez at Ryan firing the gun and how they're yelling at him. Ah well, not my favourite episode for the script/acting on the cops part. "oh so you're in a relationship" it's a phonecall! "no I bought "have you had sex" "well why were you there" well you'd know if you'd shut up and let him finish. Her anger is completely unjustified! So by their logic, Castle should be justified in shooting them and being angry because they didn't call him either!

    Sorry guys, the further through the episode I get the lower my rating goes ha. Like I said my reviews are purely nitpicks, you can see what the episode is about from someone else or you know, by watching it. I don't need to read a walk through in reviews I want people's thoughts.

    I'm a girl, who's had male friends go away.. and I didn't blame them for not calling. While I get Alexis being upset her dad was trying to justify, he should be on her side in her mind but Martha saying "that's the stupidest thing I've ever heard"? "Lock him up out of spite"

    You were all over some guy in front of him, knowing that he liked you, so he went away thinking it's what you wanted! And you should be able to figure that out Kate! It's not ridiculous to think that maybe she doesn't want you around anymore, and then you do see her and they're all dickheads to you, well why would he want to call you now.

    And when Castle finally said "you ever thought I was waiting for you to call" or whatever, she gives him this ridiculous look... yeah ok, you're all being over the top annoying this episode.
  • Average

    Though the part where they shoot each other was too predictable and unoriginal, they brought Castle without complications and that felt good. The second wife, though back with Castle had no appearance and was almost non-existent and completely irrelevant. Good case though
  • Happy Dance, Castle is BACK!

    So Castle is found over a dead body by the dynamic trio, almost getting shot by Ryan. :snicker: So he's in the box being interrogated by Beckett. I loved the interaction between the two here. She attacks him asking if he was sleeping with the victim to which he replies he's in a relationship and she knows with who. Beckett works in that she hasn't seen him in months so she doesn't know how many women he went through. Classic back and forth between the two, she gets in a zinger about his ex-wife keeping everything they do on a schedule and he tries to make a crack about Demming only to find out that they broke up which surprises him. This is all they mention about Demming which was disappointing, hopefully they will revisit this and eventually Castle will find out exactly when she broke up with him.

    They quickly clear him as a suspect and when he tries to join the investigation Beckett tells him to go back to his life and leave them alone. Soon after, Alexis is having issues of her own, a boy she met over the summer was suppose to call her when he got back from vacation and hasn't yet. She's really upset and Castle begins to realize that he may have really screwed up himself by not calling Beckett over the summer.

    So Castle does his own investigating and finds himself again standing over a dead body as the trio bust down a door. Again we get some great back and forth between Beckett and Castle, even resorting to the classic ear pull to get Castle to talk. Beckett finally gives it to him straight that he just can't come back and act like nothings happened and if he wanted to come back then he would have by then. This would have been a great place for him to actually apologize for giving them all the cold shoulder over the summer but he makes some comment about the universe and Beckett agrees to let him work this one case.

    Beckett really missed Castle and it's obvious that she enjoys having him back, the other two not so much. They keep giving him the cold shoulder much to Beckett's amusement. Beckett orchestras a bet between the two, whoever finds out the connection to the victims first, wins. Stakes are whether or not Castle is allowed to return to the team. It was awesome how Beckett fed him just enough information while theorizing for him to figure it out 'first' and watch her grin behind his back. Now she gets him back without losing any pride. Esposito of course knew what she was doing.

    Best part was the showdown at the end with Beckett and Castle both shooting a suspect that was behind the other. Looks on their faces where priceless. Oh and Castle saved Beckett's life again with a well timed tackle as shots where fired. Overall a great season opener. I did think that Beckett let him off the hook a little easily. Hopefully there will be residual feelings that they bring up over the next couple of episodes. And I gotta say that Stana Katic is a pro at letting her emotions play out through facial expressions, love to watch her act. And Nathan is always a joy to watch.

    On a side note I'm reading Naked Heat on ABC's website and I wonder how Gina feels about her boyfriend writing books that casts himself in a relationship with a woman that he works with on a daily basis. Hopefully they will bring that up as well. I mean if it were me I would not be thrilled with the idea. Sorry for the long post...I'm just so excited that it's finally back!
  • You've been informed of your rights, Mr. Castle?

    First off I would like to say I HATE it when shows to the really intense and intresting clip, and then just when your drooling a little from the intenseness of the moment "3 Days Later" appears on the screen.

    Other then that I thought this was a great season premiere. I thought the case was awesome, and very intresting. I felt bad for Kate that Castle didn't call (mainly because I have a huge crush on Stana Katic), but what I thought was the best part was, was how this didn't feel like a season premiere. Usually you have to go through 1 or 2 murderless and emotionaly draining episodes of finishing up last seasons unfinished buisness, before the show gets back into the swing of things, but this show just managed to jump right back in!

    I Love You Castle!
  • Castle hasn't kept in tough with the detectives all summer. However, they discover that he's back when he is found standing over a dead body holding a gun. After clearing his name, Castle joins in the investigation.

    This one was actually one of the rare mysteries. I didn't know who murdered the three people. Although, I should have. But, as always, it's the relationships that is the most intriguing. And, Ryan and Esposito were extremely entertaining, with the very deliberate snubbing of Castle.

    It always amazes me how much leeway Castle gets. Obviously, Beckett likes him and enjoys their partnership. I think it actually might be harder for Ryan and Esposito to forgive Castle than Beckett.

    So, strong season opener. But, that was a wicked teaser. But, the ending was sweet--very intense. Castle actually saved Beckett's life and she saved his! Awesome!

    I love this show!
  • Still URST-ing after all these months...

    The season is off to a good start with Castle charming his way out of a murder rap, and back into the good graces of the team.

    It continues with Esposito and Ryan channeling Mutt and Jeff, or Dumb and Dumber, while we all know they have more on the ball than they pretend.

    It ends with Beckett relenting and announcing the tie going to the rapscallion, Castle, just because she really wanted it that way...and because there would be no show without of course!

    It does appear Demming-with-the-perfect-teeth may be a thing of past seasons, but I doubt he or some replacement will be out of the picture for long. Lines of tension and upping the URST factor demand it but for now, all is right with these two characters who can deal with real life for everyone but themselves.

    Yep. Castle's back. And it was a long summer without...