Castle

Season 1 Episode 2

Nanny McDead

18
Aired Monday 10:00 PM Mar 16, 2009 on ABC
8.2
out of 10
User Rating
426 votes
9

EPISODE REVIEWS
By TV.com Users

Episode Summary

EDIT

Castle and Beckett work together to solve the murder of a nanny found dead spinning in the dryer of an upscale New York apartment building's laundry room.

Who was the Episode MVP ?

Today
6:00pm
MNT
12:00am
ABC
Monday
1:00am
ABC
3:00pm
TNT
4:00pm
TNT
5:00pm
TNT
6:00pm
TNT
7:00pm
TNT
8:00pm
TNT
9:00pm
TNT
10:00pm
TNT
Tuesday
8:00pm
TNT
10:00pm
TNT
11:00pm
TNT
SUBMIT REVIEW
  • Nanny McDead was another superb episode in this already great series.

    9.0
    This was an adventurous episode for new hit show Castle. Nathan Fillion continues to be excellent in his role as Richard Castle, and I continue to look forward to seeing new episodes of this show. Stana Katic is doing a great job as well, and she and Nathan Fillion have great chemistry together. Molly Quinn, the actress who plays Castle's daughter, is also great in her role. This episode had an interesting twist at the end which surprised me. I really want to learn more about Detective Beckett, and what happened to her in the past that convinced her to become a cop. Overall, I give this episode, Nanny McDead, a 9.0 out of 10.moreless
  • A much stronger episode than the pilot, not as predictable with a better story and nice twists.

    9.0
    I'm really not impressed with Beckett as a detective, she didn't even bother to ask about the nanny's belongings, like her bag. Possible contents: address book, apartment keys and oh yes, CELL PHONE! Not to mention the family don't want the dead girl's things in their apartment. As for the theory that this was a stranger-murder, it's ridiculous – how many 'break-in murderer's' stuff the dead body in a dryer?!



    Though Castle has a good knowledge of crime, he bases most of his theories on what makes 'a good story' and he's often right, because the 'good stories' are ones that are common to human nature. Even when he's guessing, he is still compelling because he talks as he writes, he has a hypnotic style which makes people listen, even if he's completely wrong. Obviously why he's a best selling author. His spiel about the neighbor killing the girl was very good. And his improv is excellent, ringing the cellphone.



    The writers have a real grasp on the emotional scenes, touching without being heavy – Beckett talking Chloe down, Castle with his daughter, Castle looking at the photo of him and his daughter. Nicely done.



    Best quotes:

    - "Your mother and I decided if someone was gonna screw you up, it was gonna be me."

    - "We could always make it strip poker." "I'm more into mystery than horror."



    Again, great soundtrack. Particularly enjoyed Pink's ringtone as they find the cellphone, given the lyrics 'nah nah…' plus Castle and Beckett's smirks, it's quite fitting.



    A very good episode, stronger than the pilot with some good twists, witty dialogue, great music and some nice touching moments.moreless
  • *** Spoiler-free *** Episodic character development but convincing acting, unauthentic dialogs, déjà vu but twisted enough story

    3.0
    The first impression is not always the most objective one but in this case I'm a bit disappointed by Beckett and Castle. In the pilot I found the mix between writing and investigation quite original but watching this episode was just entertaining and nothing more. The acting was good but the protagonists chemistry seemed forced and their dialogs weren't as spicy and funny as expected. In fact I worry that the upcoming episodes are just fillers. So I really hope the writers don't plan to use the same recipe but with a different story everytime. In Nanny McDead the events weren't predictable but not surprising. Even Castle's story telling his new partners wasn't intriguing. I just didn't believe him because what he said wasn't fascinating nor thought out of the box. Despite all these cons from time to time I enjoyed watching them investigate because of some good elements like the outfit design and charming performers. But in the end I'll quickly forget that old Nanny story and really disliked the episodic format. I'm surprised the writers didn't focus on further developing the arc covered in the pilot, about a serial killer using Castle's novels as guidelines.moreless
  • Not as good as the pilot episode

    7.5
    After the quite promising first episode, this one was kind of a let-down. What made "Flowers for your grave" so brilliant was Nathan Fillion's character and charm. In this episode, however, he was not given a chance to shine. Other people did not stand out either. It felt like everyone was standing still in terms of character development. The plot itself was not that interesting as well, although I enjoyed how Castle figured out the time delay. His knowledge, wit and perception should be made use of more in upcoming episodes. All in all, I think that this show should not try to be serious in the crime and drama department, but instead focus on the comedy.moreless
  • It's keeping me interested so far.

    8.0
    The First episode got my attention because Castle's character, as I'm guessing a lot of people thought, reminds me of Mal from Firefly, also played by Nathan Fillion. From here on out I was hoping the show would be able to give me something more to keep my interest.



    This episode had a few memorable scenes for me, including the well written speech by Castle, as if straight from a page of his new book, along with a pretty interesting murder mystery with a few twists thrown in for good measure. Nothing new or overly impressive was brought to the table, but I think I'll still be interested in giving episode three a go and hopefully others feel the same way.moreless
Ama'ri

Ama'ri

Nanny Kid

Guest Star

Jayne Brook

Jayne Brook

Claudia Peterson

Guest Star

Claudia Choi

Claudia Choi

Video Tech

Guest Star

Trivia, Notes, Quotes and Allusions

FILTER BY TYPE

  • TRIVIA (2)

    • When Castle and Beckett are on their way to meet the victim's friend Chloe in the playground, campaign posters for City Counselor Jeff Horn can be seen on pillars and walls. In a later episode, Hell Hath No Fury, Jeff Horn is murdered and Beckett and Castle look for his killer.

    • Goof: At the end of the episode, Castle is typing on his laptop. He then closes it and puts it on his desk. Seconds later, when he's looking at the photograph, you can see the laptop open again on the desk in the background. When the camera is panning out, it appears to be closed again.

  • QUOTES (13)

    • Beckett: Exactly how much longer do I have to expect you to be shadowing me on my cases like this?
      Castle: Hard to say, when I'm writing a new character there's no saying when inspiration might strike.
      Beckett: I thought I was your inspiration.
      Castle: Oh you are Detective, in so many ways
      Beckett: Yeah well your inspiration might strike you sooner than you might think.

    • Castle: Thought you ditched me back at the precinct, didn't you? Come on, Nanny McDead is found in the spin dry and you don't think the Captain's going to let me in on that story?

    • Police Representative: Mr. Castle, be advised: if you get injured following Detective Beckett to research your next novel, you cannot sue the city. If you get shot, you cannot sue the city. If you get killed...
      Castle: My lifeless remains cannot sue the city?

    • (Mr. Peterson has been accused of having an affair with the victim)
      Mr. Peterson: I am having an affair, just not with Sarah. But it's not what you think.
      Castle: (sarcastically) When is it ever?

    • Castle: (surprised after Beckett tells a suspect not to leave town) Don't leave town? Don't you need probable cause for something like that?
      Beckett: Yeah, well, he doesn't know that, does he?
      Castle: You can lie like that? That is so cool! (scribbles in his notepad)

    • Castle: So. Looks like I managed to make it through the case without getting injured, shot or killed.
      Beckett
      : Yeah, well, maybe tomorrow.

    • Kate: Okay, Castle, but it's accompany and observe, not participate and annoy. Got it?
      Castle: Participate and annoy is a lot more fun, but alright.

    • Castle: We could always make it strip poker.
      Kate: Sorry, but I prefer mystery to horror.

    • Castle: (to Kate about marriage) You'd be good at it. You're both controlling and disapproving. You should really try it.

    • Alexis: How come we never had a nanny?
      Castle: Well, your mother and I decided if someone was going to screw you up, we wanted it to be me. Only, you managed to turn out fine somehow anyway.

    • Castle: Three men huddled around a computer. There'd better not be porn, and if there is, I want in.

    • Esposito: I'm sorry. If someone started rooting around my underwear without an invitation, I'm taking that as a serious breach of hygiene.
      Kate: I thought you went commando, Esposito.

    • Ryan: So, she opens up the drier, takes the other person's clothes out, finds Miss Fluff and Fold here instead.
      Esposito: If that's not a cautionary tale about poking around with someone else's laundry, I don't know what is.

  • NOTES (3)

  • ALLUSIONS (2)

More
Less