Season 4 Episode 15


Aired Monday 10:00 PM Feb 13, 2012 on ABC

Episode Fan Reviews (5)

Write A Review
out of 10
239 votes
  • It was ok...

    I have to agree with one of the comments earlier that there are quite a few loopholes in the storyline. If the former CIA is one of their best, why only send one person to apprehend him? But I have to say that the storyline about the linchpin is interesting. Hm... just one weak link.. who may it be?

    Beckett is funny when she gets insecure about Castle's former short-term partner/girlfriend of one year!!! haha, that was hilarious when Beckett asked how short was short!
  • Pandora

    I like the abrupt ending with the car crash, that was smart as it leaves us counting the hours until Monday's show.

    This was a good first part, but it did not feel like the huge TV event ABC tried to pass it off as. It was good as I said, but a little over the top with the whole underground CIA thing. I liked it, I was on the edge of my seat, but let's keep things in perspective.
  • What remains inside Pandora's Box? Hope?

    With the paired metaphors of a linchpin, which holds a structure together and without which the structure will fail catastrophically, and of the myth of Pandora's Box, out of which all of earth's evils escaped when it was opened, leaving only hope, the writers have structured an uncomfortably possible cliff-hanger: if not prevented, an economic disaster the like of which the world has never seen will bring the US down.

    Humanizing both the evil machine aimed at destroying the US and the defenders who struggle to prevent catastrophe involves a series of juxtapositions: day and night as times for action; ground level and deep basement settings as backdrops; a gloomy garage and a sunny park as arenas for confrontations; the seriousness and freshness of Alexis and the jaundiced selfishness of Gage; the starkness of a believable doomsday scenario and the humor of jealous co-workers sniping and snapping out their irritation at one another. In places, the plot seems structured like the layers of a Russian matryoshka nesting doll: events within events within events; reasons within reasons within reasons; facts within facts within facts. One is reminded of Ezekiel's "wheel within a wheel" as every event changes meanings with the addition of newly-discovered or newly-admitted data.

    Castle, in "Pandora," interacts directly with five different women: his mother, his daughter, the Captain, his old CIA source, and Beckett; most of his interaction with Lanie is at a remove: she shares some comments with Beckett, who tells Alexis, who tells Martha. . . who accidentally tells Castle. For once, Castle savors having been forbidden to discuss a case; it gives him a chance to score against Captain Gates. Reminiscing and flirting with his old CIA source gives him a similar chance to ruffle Beckett's feathers, gently, as she reacts negatively to watching him "partner" someone else until he proves that ONLY Beckett is really his partner. As often before, one of the women in Castle's life suggests a different point of view for a problem puzzling him; this time it is Martha who opines that the chess moves may have nothing to do with the game of chess. Castle's interactions with ALL of the women in this episode reinforce one of his strongest attributes: his respect for women as people. Despite his frequent flirtations and rather bawdy history, Castle is actually a feminist and Alexis and Martha have definitely assisted in his growth.

    Although the murder of Dr. Blakely was predictable, the discovery that he is actually one of the "good guys" was not. We are left with questions about the CIA as an organization, about the veracity of its workers, about who is manipulating whom, about whom to believe and whom to trust. Although not excruciating, the suspense is pleasurable most of us will be tuning in next week.

  • Boring, Predictable and Stupid

    Wow, not only did everybody behave stupidly, this episode was predictable at every turn.

    It starts with a mistake:

    CIA sends ONE guy to apprehend their best man? How is that supposed to work? Luck?

    And ends with sheer stupidity:

    Why didn't Castle and Becket call it in when they had the guy everybody was after, the one guy who could tell them whats going on...
  • Pandora: Castle & Kate vs. the CIA (spoilers for those on the W. Coast)

    Rating: 9: A darn good setup for next week!

    I always enjoy a good case of the Green-Eyed Monster, whether it's Kate's or Rick's.

    I like that Alexis is interning with Lanie. As usual, Alexis' choice doesn't sit well with Dad.

    I loved it when "Sir,"Esposito and Ryan got their noses out of joint because K&C couldn't tell them what's going on.

    K&C sharing the trunk was a nice touch.

    The one negative for me was that Blakely's murder was no surprise at all. Throwing in a surprise twist would have made for a more effective cliffhanger. It's not as like we're going to skip watching next week.