Charmed Season 5 Episode 18

When Phoebe is telling Paige about Piper's previous relationships, she says that before between Jeremy and Dan there was two bankers, a rock climber and a ghost. However, that is incorrect. Aside from the fact that "the rock climber" was a college Professor, Piper only dated one banker (in the episode Witch Trial). While we had seen her go out on dates in the episodes Dream Sorcerer and From Fear to Eternity with Jack and Lucus, they were both businessmen not bankers.

TRIVIA: In this episode, during the "flashbacks" that the girls visit, Prue's face is never shown - which may be because they had to re-shoot alot of the screens but likely has to do with the fact that Shannen "owns" her image.

When the Warlock catches Kit and kills her, she turns to her human form. However, when Leo and Katarina are explaining everything it is said that becoming human was a reward for her excellent service as a familiar. So wouldn't that mean that since she was killed before her work was recognized, that she had not been made human? Therefore, if never made human her form should have remained as a cat when killed.

During the return to the episode The Fourth Sister, Phoebe and Paige witness Leo searching for Kit in the chimney, then hide in a corner while Phoebe and Piper's past selves discuss Phoebe's preference for dangerous boys. In the original episode, after searching for Kit, Leo leaves the Manor, and this scene is immediately followed by Leo hanging flyers in the street, the dialogue about dangerous boys not being part of the original episode.

How come Phoebe figures out only now that Kit was their familiar? Kit came to the Charmed Ones' house the day they became witches, she had a medallion with the triquetra (the Charmed Ones' symbol, no less!) on her neck even before she came to them, she hissed at evil beings in Deja Vu All Over Again (Piper was aware of her hissing at the evil in They're Everywhere), in Pre-witched the dead witch refers to her former cat as "my familiar, a feline called Shadow" and Phoebe herself compares Kit to Shadow saying she would never undress in front of Kit again. There were enough clues, and Phoebe realizes only now Kit is their familiar, when Paige refers to Kit as "a familiar cat".

One of the flashes that is shown is when Leo and Piper kiss for the first time. When the flash ends we see Piper and Leo with the doctor smiling and looking at each other. Why should Leo be smiling and looking at Piper that way? If you remember the original scene the "truth" spell had been cast and even at the end of the episode Leo goes to Quake to talk with Piper because he doesn't remember anything. So how is it possible that both of them remember the moment if Leo had forgotten the moment because of the spell?

GOOF: During the "Look Who's Barking" flashback, when Piper says "I wish everyone would stop telling me to relax." She looks back towards where Leo just left from. In the actual episode, she looks at DogPrue.

TRIVIA: This is the only episode ever to feature all four of the Charmed Ones (although Prue's face is never shown) and their family. The family included Patty, Victor, Penny, Leo, Wyatt, and Kit, the Charmed Ones' cat. One could also count Cole as family, seeing how he was married to Phoebe at one point. The only family members not featured are Chris, Coop, and Henry, none of which had been introduced yet.

During the scene of the flashback where Piper is dancing on the bar, the song is different than in the original episode Coyote Piper - EMF's Unbelievable. This scene also does not really apply either since Piper was possessed and Leo was not even there.

In the scene where Leo is about to propose to Piper, Phoebe and Paige orb into the back door in the bathroom with just a toilet. In the season 2 episode "Chick Flick" Bloody Mary comes out the same door and you can clearly see a hallway not a extra part of the bathroom.

Why would Piper and Leo remember the episode "Look Who's Barking"? He was afraid of Prue only, that is not a memorable time for them as a couple.

When in the flashback of the episode "Love Hurts" Phoebe and Paige are kneeling on the floor, with Paige on the left, and Phoebe on the right, but when they flash into the flashback of the episode "Once Upon a Time" Phoebe is on the left, and Paige is on the right.

If the memory of when Piper and Leo first met was set inside, then why were Paige, Phoebe, and the warlock brought outside the house?

During "the wedding scene" everyone was looking at Prue leave which was right next to Paige and Phoebe (who were looking out to see what was going on) so why did no one see them looking out?

In the flashback when Phoebe and Paige are in the attic from a scene in "Bride and Gloom" they see that while Past Phoebe and Past Piper are torturing Danatalian, a dark priestess, Leo orbs in. However, in the flashback, he says "Piper, we need to talk" when orbing in, when in the original, he said "I just couldn't leave like that, Piper".

When Phoebe and Paige flash back to the memory of Piper's wedding, the original episode "Just Harried" was aired with Phoebe accidently stepping on Piper's dress when she attempts to walk away after saying that the wedding is off. However, in "Cat House" the flashback did not show Phoebe standing on Piper's dress.

When Phoebe and Paige flash back to Piper's wedding and get there in time to see Prue's astral self ride out on a motorcycle with TJ, a fling, and pulling most of the decorations with them (caught in the wheels), Piper leaves as she did in the original episode "Just Harried". However, in the original episode, Leo does not say to Phoebe "What just happened?" after Piper says the wedding is off, and Phoebe never answers with "Oh, come here sweetie".

In the flashback where Piper heals Leo, Leo then orbs himself & Piper out, but in the original episode ("Love Hurts"), hadn't they switched powers? Also, in the episode, it cut to them coming down the stairs.

When Paige wants to stay and listen to Leo propose to Piper, Phoebe says that she already knows how it ends. This indicates that Piper says yes. However, the first time Leo proposed Piper shot him down, and it was at least another few months before their engagement was official.

Although Phoebe meant that Paige knows that Piper and Leo are married in the present.

In the flashback to the wedding, when the cake falls the figures land a bit away from it, but in the season 3 episode "Just Harried" when the cake fell, the figures landed underneath the cake.

When Paige and Phoebe go back to when Piper and Phoebe were evil, because of a spell in the season 3 episode "Bride and Groom", Paige is surprised that Phoebe was a blonde, but her hair was that same color when they first met, so why was she surprised?

TRIVIA: Katrina's house looks exactly like the house of David Silver's on Beverly Hills, 90210, which was not only another Aaron Spelling production but starred Shannen Doherty.

TRIVIA: The characters in the series today were put into scenes from previous seasons almost seamlessly as they watched or listened to the action, similar to the "Star Trek: Deep Space Nine" episode "Trials and Tribble-ations" where characters were inserted into footage from an original "Star Trek" episode "The Trouble with Tribbles".

TRIVIA: Foreshadowing? At the end of this episode, the plastic bride and groom from Piper and Leo's wedding cake which was crushed by the warlock, is still gone even though everything else the spell affected was fixed.

TRIVIA: We learn that Kit was the Charmed Ones' familiar, and ran away after Paige became one of the Charmed Ones, and that Kit, the cat is now Katrina, a human.

Phoebe tells Paige that Piper was engaged but Piper was never engaged to Jeremy. She told Phoebe in the pilot episode that she thought Jeremy might be "the one" but she was never engaged to him.

Wouldn't Piper or Leo want to tell the memory of when Wyatt was born?

When Phoebe goes into the shower, she accidently catches Piper and Leo there. Yet while looking at Piper and Leo, it's fairly obvious that they are present-day Piper and Leo.

In the flashback of Piper and Leo's shower scene, why was the door partially open? When the original episode aired, the door was completely closed. Who takes a shower with their spouse and leaves the door open, yet doesn't want to be interrupted?

When Phoebe and Paige pop into the attic just before Dantalian shows up they are talking pretty loud. When Dantalian comes past Piper and Phoebe come from around the corner of the attic. Don't they hear Phoebe and Paige talking?

When Kit runs into the bathroom while Piper and Leo are showering, Phoebe runs after her to bring her out, but not only does she come out without her, but she also closes the door of the bathroom, trapping Kit inside.

In the beginning, when the warlock slashes Katrina, the gash that appears from the slash appears about an inch above where the knife touched her neck. In other words, the warlock cut Katrina, but she was hurt in a different place (about an inch above on the neck).

When Paige is talking to Katrina, the necklace that she was wearing was not around her neck, but when she orbs in to help Phoebe in the fight, her necklace is back but her jacket is not (she left it behind).

This is the first time that the cabinet filled with the couple's wedding memorabalia has been shown. Would they really leave it out like that? Since the many times stuff downstairs gets destroyed by powers gone awry, the demon-attack-of-the-week, etc.?

Piper says she "shattered" Leo, but as we see in the flashback immediately preceding her statement, it was Phoebe who did so - Piper just froze him. At best she was just an accomplice to him being shattered.