So it's settled, then! TVFan is the winner!!!
Next thread, folks.
The WB (ended 2006)
If Phoebe would still have her empath powerm she could have win because she could channel every power used against her (like she did with the fire balls thrown at her on season 6)
I think the order would be...
I think Pheobe would defintely lose to them all because the power of premonition isn't exactly a good battle weapon. Prue would probably come in 3rd because her telekinetic abilities give her an advantage towards reversing and dodging attacks, but since it is tied to her energy, she can't keep it up forever. It's easy to know that Piper would come in 2nd because due to her molecular combustion she can blow things up without being stopped due to telekenisis. The reason Paige would be in first is because if her molecules can separate and rejoin, due to her whitelighter half, she can escape Piper's molecular combustion and as we could see in the episode Charmed Again, Pt.2, Paige can orb someone's heart out of their body.
|The reason Paige would be in first is because if her molecules can separate and rejoin, due to her whitelighter half, she can escape Piper's molecular combustion and as we could see in the episode Charmed Again, Pt.2, Paige can orb someone's heart out of their body.|
Good points! Plus in Centennial Charmed she blew up Leo and Cole from the inside.
Actually, it might be Phoebe.
We've seen the sisters lose their powers when they use them against each other, so let's say that happens. Piper has had the least experience in hand-to-hand combat, so she'd go down 1st.
Prue did, but she's a little rusty. Paige beat up the arrogant cop when she wanted to enlist, so she knows a thing or two about fighting. But she's very used to using her powers defensively to reverse shots and orb out of the way. Without her powers she'd take alot more blows, so Prue would win out.
But Phoebe's been doing karate since the beginning, AND not having active powers for most of the show, she's relied on it even more and thus honed her skills.
So the winners would be in order:
I agree, It'd definetely be between Prue and Phoebe in hand-to-hand combat. But whoever wins would depend on what season they had a fight in. If it was S3 or earlier, Prue would win because she said in 'Ms Hellfire' that she'd be going to combat classes or something like that and she had more experience in fighting than Phoebe did. Although it would be pretty evenly matched, Prue would have the slight advantage. If they fought during S4 or after, Phoebe would win. This is because in 'Enter the demon', Cole taught Phoebe how to fight properly and over the years her fighting ability probably advanced.
BTW, Piper can't freeze good witches but she can blow them up. In Charmed and Dangerous, the source blew up Phoebe and Paige when he had Piper's power. And also, her sisters are also human which means the blasts could be fatal to them. The reason she's never blown any good witches up is because she doesn't want to kill good witches.
Hey has anyone noticed that its always Phoebe and Paige that sortta gets to die. Like in Witch in Time, or the premonition of the seer or Forever Charmed...