Yeah, i would have killed off Prue. When i first watched Charmed i started form season 4, thus Paige has always been my favorite.
I never really cared for Prue. Sure, i sorta liked her, but i hate how it always seemed like she was the strongest. It wasn't the power of three, it was the power of Prue and Piper and Phoebe just tagging a long. I mean they practically proved that's what they thought in the episode where Grams first came in and that demon started reading the spells backwards and bring back all the demons, sorry, i forgot the episode name.
I liked Paige. I liked how she was special and half whitelighter. I liked how she was so sarcastic and funny.
I liked Piper. Sure, she was extremely annoying how she kept prattling off about how it was so unfair that she didn't have a normal life blah blaaah blah. But she's so caring and sweet and vital to the show!
Phoebe REALLY annoyed me how she was so obsessed with finding love and having a kid. But i love her!!
Prue. Can go...die.