Charmed

Season 6 Episode 15

I Dream of Phoebe

1
Aired Sunday 8:00 PM Feb 15, 2004 on The WB
9.0
out of 10
User Rating
377 votes
19

EPISODE REVIEWS
By TV.com Users

Episode Summary

EDIT
When Phoebe frees a genie from a bottle, she soon finds that she must take the genie's place. Meanwhile, anxious to put Leo and Piper back together, Chris uses Phoebe to make his wish come true, but she takes his instructions too literally.

Who was the Episode MVP ?

Tuesday
No results found.
Wednesday
No results found.
Thursday
No results found.
SUBMIT REVIEW
  • An alright one, if not a rip off of multiple shows.

    7.0
    While it's kind of disturbing that Chris just wants two people want to have sex, Phoebe knows the truth and is holding it against Chris and could not care less that he's just going to disappear and cease to exist.



    He had perfect reasons for everything he was doing. And seriously "your brother picked on you", he's evil and taking over the entire world and craves more and more power. But Phoebe's little rant here was actually quite annoying.



    The wish for them to sleep together was kind of weird but funny. I just don't get why people think he's sick and wrong, it's completely understandable. It's called surviving! You're all talking about it being too hard on her so no. Um he will die, the man who's spent this long trying to save Wyatt will not exist.



    "I'm giving up a lot to be here" Um piper Greg is going to work.. you're not bloody giving up anything! Jesus I hate what they did with their priorities in the later seasons.



    1. Paige was ridiculous "not only do I have to worry about Richard but you too", so what because Chris uses magic now he's irresponsible and can't be trusted? Paige actually is kind of sexist.

    2. The whole rant about Chris being a creep, registered sex offender is bloody over the top. Why not just ask 'why'.

    3. He's not evil, he's never hurt anyone, you have no right to just show up and throw a potion at him. Him giving up his powers is ENTIRELY his choice.



    Yes he's being a bit crazed, I can agree with that, but Paige just leave him, stop acting like you have the right to control him. Let's face it, you'd strip his powers and then dump him anyway. And what the hell was with showing up and then asking about Chris. Priorities.



    I'm actually surprised nobody tried to wish them dead before - it's quite smart. But I'm sick of them throughout the show going "I can't heal the dead, I can't heal the dead" etc etc they were wished dead, dead dead, not 'ah sort of dead but they can be healed', it's stupid.



    "How can you have so much faith Paige" Actually she has absolutely none. She automatically assumes the worst so far in any male, especially males with powers. He finally chooses between her and magic, like she forced him into doing, so he chooses her and no magic and she leaves anyway. I get why, she doesn't want to tempt him but she forces him, keeps shoving lack of magic down his throat, only to know she would have to leave.



    I like Jinny, she was a cool evil dude.



    And god, Phoebe calling Chris dramatic. Coming from her who dramatises everything, especially the Cole situation. But Chris IS GOING TO DIE. Never ever exist! I think he's reacting perfectly normally. I'd be angrier if I was him because everyone that knows is treating him like crap and could not care less.



    I'd rate these higher if I could get over how they treated Chris.moreless
  • I Dream of Phoebe

    9.5
    I Dream of Phoebe was a superb episode of Charmed and I really enjoyed watching because there was a lot of character and plot development. It was very interesting to learn of Chris's true origins, to see the powers of a genie used again, and for Paige and Richard to deal with his problem. There was lots of action, drama and intrigue along with some humor, serious moments and of course magic. I certainly look forward to watching the next episode!!!!!!!!!moreless
  • I Dream Of A Better Series!

    4.0
    I Dream of Phoebe-When Phoebe frees a genie from a bottle, she soon finds that she must take the genie's place. Meanwhile, anxious to put Leo and Piper back together, Chris uses Phoebe to make his wish come true, but she takes his instructions too literally.

    Phoebe in yet another silly costume!! You can always tell the quality in a Charmed episode by how little Phoebe has to wear or some tacky costume the writers have forced poor Alyssa Milano to wear. I mean come on, Alyssa, your a producer at this point, tell these people they are embarrassing you week by week on national television and it needs to stop! Besides, they writers already did a Genie episode, a relatively "good" Genie episode, so why is this "I Dream of Genie"knockoff forced down our throats!! Barbara Eden wouldn't be amused! The whole plot is your typical Charmed fluff, Phoebe gets a premonition (yeah, she actually still gets those!!) about a woman being attacked by a demon, leaving her and Chris to go to some where in Arabia or whatever and they find Jenny...The Genie.....*headdesk* I also find the Aladdin mythology silly on Charmed with the 40 theives being demons. Jenny turning out to be a demon all along was a decent twist I guess but things just go downhill once Phoebe gets turned into a Genie.

    If that wasn't bad enough, we have Chris on a sick and disturbing crusade to get Piper and Leo to sleep together so he cane be concieved in time. I don't know whether this was suppose to be intended as funny but if the was, the writers have a messed up sense of humor. Not only it it not funny, but it's extremely jarring considering we just found out who Chris really is. One week, he's barely in the sisters' lives and the nexr, he's forcing one of them to sleep with an Elder. Yeah, I know their his parents but still, give us time to explore this knew revelation, not make cheap jokes about wanting your parents to have sex. I still believe the writers pulled this development out their a$$ as we as an audience were given no hints as to who Chris really was. Sure, he and Wyatt had a past in the future, but still, it was pretty vague and this is a pretty big development for not even giving the fans a bit of clue to Chris' being Piper and Leo's son. It's also pathetic watching Chris trying to break up Piper's date with Greg! It's funny considering in "Prince Charmed" only a few episodes ago, Chris wanted Piper to dtae so she wouldn't give up on love. Phoebe during her agrument with Chris at the beginning is the only thing that made sense in this episode: Chris' plans were terrible! He's the one who forced his parents to split! He's the one who sent Leo to Vahalla! He's the one whose been keeping secrets to the point that have caused unforseen consequences! Now all of sudden he wants Piper and Leo to bone? *HEAD-FREAKIN'-DESK*

    If that wasn't bad enough we get Paige and Richard going at it about his powers. At this point, I couldn't careless about Richard or his supposed dangerous usage of magic. I glad the writers finally rapped up this relationship with Richard stripping himself of his powers and both deciding to break-up. It was long time coming and maybe with Richard gone Paige can become more independent and less of a ditzy, overportective girlfriend?.........NOPE! I did love the Piper and Leo moment toward the end. Even with all the suck around them, Holly and Brian always remind us that Piper and Leo's relationship is the only redeeming thing about the series. But besides that, 'I Dream of Phoebe" is as gimmicky and pathetic as Charmed can get!moreless
  • Interesting Episode!

    10
    Ginny tricked Phoebe to help the Genie to get free so Ginny can control the world! How comes Ginny want Phoebe? Because Phoebe is one of the Charmed Ones. Chris gets to be master of Genie Phoebe for while, very interesting! When Phoebe freed Ginny and Ginny became evil~! Weird! Ginny acted very nice as Genie, which not made sense! Chris want his parents to sleep together thought Piper's boyfriend caught her sleep with her ex-husband. Piper's boyfriend was never heard of it again and left Piper's life! I am happy for Chris! Phoebe became blonde in this episode so she got her chance to wear another hair color, thought it is wig! Great episode!moreless
  • A hot genie, a mad demon, and Leo's love to the rescue once again.

    9.0
    Season 6 reaches its pinnacle in this episode and the following one, before the terrific season finale. For one thing, we have a tremendously pretty genie who in a terrific twist becomes a hot demon bent on becoming all powerful. Stupid name or not, Jinny makes a fantastic bad guy. I am always for attractive female bads cast in opposition to the sisters. Secondly, we have the wrap up of Richard's storyline, which I think we were all glad to see end. And that means only 4 episodes after the idiotic split of the sisters, that moronic story arc mercifully ends and the sisters are all back at Halliwell manor. We also have Chris, Phoebe and then Paige all talking openly about who Chris is and the mission to reunite his parents. I hated that Piper was still dating Greg after recent events, but I loved how Chris pretty much ended their relationship by manipulating his parents together. And of course, it was a miracle that he did, since it ended up saving the Charmed Ones.



    In a rather shocking turn of events, Richard ends up killing the sisters at Jinny's wish. Great acting by the much-maligned Drew Fuller during this scene. Fortunately, Leo had an arm around Piper, and she called to him as her soul floated away. Leo even while asleep healed her, saving all of them. The sisters learning their lesson from past ghosts and using that against the demon was also very smartly done. And of course that all led to the final scene where we saw Piper and Leo edging closer to being together again, what most of us have been waiting for.moreless
J. Michael Flynn

J. Michael Flynn

Benjamin Montana

Guest Star

Jason Shaw

Jason Shaw

Greg

Guest Star

Joey Naber

Joey Naber

Head Thief

Guest Star

Amanda Sickler

Amanda Sickler

Sophie

Recurring Role

Balthazar Getty

Balthazar Getty

Richard Montana

Recurring Role

Trivia, Notes, Quotes and Allusions

FILTER BY TYPE

  • TRIVIA (22)

    • When Chris holds out his hand for the bottle while on the floor, the book is open next to him and it's a blank page, then when the camera switches to the bottle flying off and they show Chris again a second later, the book is now open on Bosk's entry.

    • The Arabic inscription on the Genie bottle can be translated like this:
      From right to left: "20- DON'T" (Upside-down) …"BE SAD GOD IS WITH YOU." It doesn't have anything to do with what Leo said. Also, those few words can't possibly measure up with the two sentences "read" by Leo.

    • In this episode it is said that the only way a genie can be freed is for the master to wish it free and then they become the genie. Yet in the season 2 episode Prue wishes the Genie free and does not have to switch places. Which could be possibly be explained by Jinny's curse however in this episode when Phoebe became the Genie she had to listen to Chris when he ordered her into the bottle. But in the season 2 episode The Genie would not listen to Phoebe when she tried to make him leave her alone. In fact once released he pretty much did whatever and went wherever he wanted. Side Note: Jinny the Genie was a demon who was cursed by someone. That is why whoever freed her would change places with her, not because she was a Genie.

    • TRIVIA: This is the second of two times the sisters come across a genie. The first time was the season 2 episode Be Careful What You Witch For.

    • TRIVIA: In this episode Paige is given jewelery (earrings and a necklace) by Richard, via magic. This is the same exact jewelery that alternate Pheobe is wearing in the season 5 episode "Centennial Charmed".

    • When Chris and Phoebe enter the cave in the desert to look for Jinny, Chris is wearing a brown jacket. But when he bends down to look at a pile of half buried bones, you can see he's wearing a black leather jacket- the same one he's seen wearing later through the show. Then when he straightens back up, it's the brown one again.

    • TRIVIA: This episode features the final appearance of Balthazar Getty (Richard Montana).

    • TRIVIA: This is one of four episodes with "Phoebe" in the title. However, there is only one episode with "Paige" in the title, one with "Prue" and two with "Piper".

    • TRIVIA: Paige finds out about Chris' true identity in this episode.

    • Leo reads the inscription on the genie bottle, which is in Arabic, from left to right. But the Arabic language reads from right to left, unlike English.

    • In this episode Leo takes Piper to pick Wyatt up but in the next one, he tells her she is not allowed up there. Was Wyatt "up there" - Leo didn't say where he took Wyatt.

    • If Leo wasn't a elder in Chris' past, why does Chris in this episode say he got letters from his father when he was a kid? Why did Leo write him letters instead of talking to him - where was Leo that he couldn't orb to Chris?

    • When Paige is wearing her green top you can clearly see that it switches positions between shots.

    • When someone dies on the show, their spirit leaves their body, but as it has been seen/explained previously until their soul "moves on" Leo can still heal them. Once the spirit moves on they cannot be healed (example in episode 6.9, the beast only changes to human again when he dies, but they are able to heal him after this as they move quickly before his spirit moves on). In the episode Saving Private Leo Piper dies and then begins to move on, but Leo is able to heal her in time and she returns to her body.

    • If a genie can be used to kill others, even the powerful Charmed Ones, and demons have posessed the genie, wouldn't they have wished to either become the Source of all Evil or kill him or kill a lot of witches?

    • Richard's current level of powers and his means of "materializing" bear a striking resemblance to Cole's power level and "bright shimmering" of the fifth season. In addition, coincidently the name of the actor who portrays Richard Montana is Balthazar Getty, which is almost the name of Cole's demon half from seasons 3-5 - Belthazar.

    • Why didn't Paige orb the bottle to her the many times she tried to get it back?

    • Why didn't Bosk just wish for the location of Zanbar.

    • How did Phoebe know those thieves were demons. She took quite a risk.

    • Jinny must be more powerful than the Source,since she is able to fool the BoS and break out of the crystal cage, which he never could.

    • When Phoebe and Chris are in Phoebe's office talking, her scarf tails keep changing from front to back. When we see her back and Chris' face, the scarf is flipped to the back, but when we see Phoebe's face, the scarf tails are in the front.

    • Leo already healed Piper at least once after her body died. In the episode "Awakened", after Piper's heart stopped beating and the doctors gave up, Leo healed Piper in the astral plane. The only differences in this episode are the fact that Leo healed Piper while he was asleep, and that her death was not a result of any physical injury. As learnt in this episode, the wishes can be taken quite literally, so Richard could have used the book he had about genies to fulfill the wish for the sisters' death in such a way that will leave a chance for them to be saved.

  • QUOTES (27)

    • Leo (trying to write an apology letter to Chris while under the influence of the genie's spell): But after everything I've put you through, I feel like I owe it to you.
      Chris (with bitterness): Honestly, a letter's not going to mean a hell of a lot to me. I got plenty of them growing up.
      Leo: Sorry?
      Chris: Uh, from my father. He wasn't around much.

    • Chris (exasperated): Look, I'm running out of time here, so what do you say we get to use that genie to make mom and dad... you know...
      Phoebe: That's vile, and against the rules. I would think that you wouldn't wanna be conceived that way.
      Chris: Well, it beats not being conceived at all.

    • Ghost Phoebe: Hey, Chris. We're not moving on.
      Ghost Paige: Why aren't we moving on?
      Chris: Who cares? You're still here.
      Ghost Paige: Got any unfinished business?
      Ghost Phoebe: No, you?
      Ghost Paige: Yeah, now that you mention it, it would've been nice to find out I had another NEPHEW…before I died!

    • Richard: I've got a book of wishes around here somewhere.
      Genie Phoebe: Wishes?
      Richard (as he searches the drawers): Yep. Gotta get the wording right.
      Genie Phoebe: Yeah, maybe you should just wish for sleep, because I'm really good at that wish!

    • Genie Phoebe: I do believe the element of surprise is very important here.
      Chris: You sure? Because we could always take our time with this plan, you know, keep Piper around just a little bit longer?
      Genie Phoebe: Yes, master.
      Chris: Good. I'm glad you agree.
      Genie Phoebe: A-actually I d-I don't agree, but I ca-I can't… (frustrated) How am I supposed to take charge and take commands all at the same time?!

    • (Phoebe became a Genie in the bottle)
      Piper (looks into the bottle): Will you come out of there, please?
      Phoebe: I can't! I don't know how. Try commanding me.
      Piper: Uh, okay. Get the hell outta there!

    • Piper: What is this big emergency? Can't it wait an hour or two?
      Chris: No, it can't. There's a demon on the loose, a genie running amok, and it took me two wishes to get here.
      Piper: You can't make wishes with genies.
      Chris: See, we need you. Come on.

    • Greg: Is there a problem here?
      Chris: Yeah, many problems, many levels. Piper has to come home now.
      Greg: Excuse me? Who are you again?
      Chris: I'm a friend of her husband's.
      Piper: Ex-husband. And he's not really a great friend.

    • (Chris has just told Paige that he wished for Piper and Leo to sleep together)
      Paige: You! Oh my god, you are sick! What is wrong with you? You're disgusting!
      Chris: No!
      Paige: You are some creepy registered sex offender from the future!
      Chris: No, no, no...
      Paige: Oh my god, you are so gross!
      Chris: I'm Piper and Leo's son.
      Paige: What?!

    • Chris: I wish for Piper and Leo to sleep together tonight.
      Phoebe: I'm not...
      She nods her head while clapping her hands together. They then hear a thud and walk towards it, to see Piper and Leo asleep together
      Chris: They're sleeping together! (to Phoebe) You tricked me.
      Phoebe: No. You wished for them to sleep together, and they're sleeping together.

    • Chris: If mom and dad don't screw, I'm screwed!

    • Leo (to Chris): Hey buddy, do you wanna sit down and talk about it?

    • Phoebe: Oh, I feel soooo bad.
      Chris: Well, as you should.

    • Phoebe: You're unbelievable. I mean, most kids who are the cause of their parents' divorce actually feel guilty. And you're sitting here like it's part of your master plan.
      Chris: I'm sensing some real issues here.
      Phoebe: Oh you're damn right there are issues. You can't just pop in from the future and play with peoples lives because your big brother picked on you.
      Chris: He picked on the world Phoebe!
      Phoebe: I'm not finished. Your parents were happy until you split them up. And now you want my help because you didn't think this all the way through?
      Chris: Feel better?
      Phoebe: Yes
      Chris: Will you help me?
      Phoebe: No.... oh I don't know.

    • Phoebe walks in her office door and gasps when she finds Chris waiting for her.
      Chris: Phoebe, I need your help.
      Phoebe: I've been calling for you all week! Didn't you hear me?
      Chris: The first couple of days, yeah, then I put you on mute.
      Phoebe: You can put me on mute?
      Chris: Yeah.

    • Phoebe: Okay, I'm just trying to get used to you being my nephew... uh I never hit on you did I? Chris: What? No. Phoebe: Oh, thank God. Chris: Can we focus here, please? Mom and Dad need to have sex. Now who's going to tell them? You or me?

    • Phoebe: I still want to know why we didn't die?
      (Chris glares at Phoebe)
      Phoebe: What? I'm curious.
      Chris: Oh, sure, you don't mind them knowing they almost died but not that I... never mind.

    • Chris: They're not waking up. How come they're not waking up?
      Phoebe: Would you relax?
      Chris: Relax? I'm sorry, did you say relax? Because I'm about to disappear, vanish forever, cease to exist.
      Phoebe: Oh my God. You are so dramatic!

    • Phoebe: We're gonna do this my way mister!
      Chris: Master.

    • Chris (to Phoebe): If we don't do something soon, I could end up half-fireman instead of half-whitelighter!

    • Paige sees Phoebe and laughs.
      Phoebe: You're laughing at me? I'm trying to be sympathetic and you're laughing at me!?

    • Piper: Do I need to call Chris to shut you up?
      Phoebe: You wouldn't!
      Piper: Try me.

    • Jinny: When I form my empire the first thing I'm gonna do is rid the world of witches.
      Paige: Oh yeah? Well when you're back in your bottle the first thing I'm gonna do is put you in the microwave. Hahha!

    • Phoebe (in her genie costume, to Chris): Hello master.

    • Phoebe: I thought she was an innocent. How was I to know that I was going to unleash a demon?
      Leo (pointing to the bottle): It says so right here.
      Phoebe: Oh right, right there...in Arabic!

    • Paige: Don't you need to go help Major Nelson?
      Piper laughs and Phoebe gives her a look.
      Piper: What? It's kinda funny!

    • Piper: You look ridiculous.
      Phoebe: I feel ridiculous.

  • NOTES (2)

    • International Episode Titles: Czech Republic: Sním o Phoebe (I Dream About Phoebe) France: Mauvais génie (Bad Genie) Italy: Quel genio di Phoebe (That Geni(us) of Phoebe) Germany: Bezaubernde Phoebe (Charming Phoebe)

    • This episode aired on February 13, 2004 in Canada.

  • ALLUSIONS (4)

More
Less
  • 8:00 pm
    America's Got Talent Semi-Final 1
    NEW
    NBC
  •  
    Are You Smarter Than a 5th Grader? Adolfo/Ashley
    NEW
    FOX
  • 9:00 pm
    Zoo Emotional Contagion
    NEW
    CBS
  • 10:00 pm
    Hollywood Game Night Everything's Coming Up Jonas
    NEW
    NBC
  •  
    Extreme Weight Loss Kim
    NEW
    ABC