See while the girls may have brushed paige off too soon knowing what they've been through, they have known what Paige hasn't been through so it is fair enough on some level, and she did say she had the hots for the owner. But Paige tells them to continue their conversation and then keeps interrupting them to try and talk? Like you wait til they're finished...
I don't get how Phoebe is a college grad in one year? I mean I don't live in America, but College is the equivalent of University here and the shortest Uni course is 3 years... But I think she goes back and does Psychology later and even if the last course she did was just a short thing, that should be minimum 3 years so, can't remember, but hopefully it goes over 3 seasons.
At Phoebe's job interview she could've just said "well my sister died recently and my other sister isn't handling it so I may have to leave to be with her" opposed to acting all weird.
I kind of don't like how Paige is all "my whitelighter side is for demons" like in the opening she heals Cole and now she's 'sensing' evil in a house that looks haunted.. But I got supporting her to give her confidence in her abilities even if she may be wrong.
I actually didn't mind the demon in this one.
But I did find Paige become annoying once she realised she was right. Which will continue to be her annoying flaw. While it's good to try and take initiative and give ideas but she was stupid to take the man that may have kidnapped Phoebe to her place and completely ignoring Piper's advice/warnings about the house. And the lure didn't actually work. He took Paige out not because she lured him but because he felt guilty about the current victims.
There are people without bellybuttons though, so saying "he hasn't got one because he was never born" is pretty crap. If Finn was truly evil, what he's saying is smart to make himself seem innocent.
I really didn't like Paige cheating at heads or tails though. I mean she not only ignores Piper at every turn but instead of at least being fair like Leo wanted she goes and cheats to get her way. Another annoying flaw she'll always have. Sort of proves if they went with Piper's plan to just go straight to the house they'd be fine and have been able to rescue Phoebe.
But it's still a good episode. I like ones like this where it's not entirely any character-centric.