See this is where it's also annoying Paige is always "demon this, demon Cole that" like you have NO REASON to believe he's a demon. This is why I like Piper's anti-Cole. At least hers is mostly rational, and she's not condemning a man just because.
BUT In their sort of defense, Phoebe was being a bit blind. I mean most of the 'fact's' Paige claims to have, are pretty ridiculous, but once they add up it is something you can at least question and not blindly ignore. But in her defense Cole is like the perfect husband to her, so why be suspicious of a man like that. Especially when there's more facts to attest to Cole being a good man than a bad one so.
Paige acting like it's Phoebe's fault she's not there "rolls eyes - urgh hormones" .. um no that is NOT what happened at all. It's not like you said "hi Phoebe' and she said "oh eff you Paige get away from me" which is how you're trying to make it seem.
I liked the wizard, he was good. Especially the loop he played and how long it took Piper to realise.