Which Prue Is It Anyway?

Season 1, Episode 16, Aired
EDIT

Episode Recap

The episode begins with a sparring match in a boxing ring. One man knocks the other out, and we see an older man look on. You see the winning boxer in the locker room as the older man meets him and tells him he saw him fight in a boxing match where the other man died. He stops the boxer from trying to leave, and tells the man he wants his killer instinct. He stabs the man to death and leaves.
Back at the manor, Pru and Piper argue about Gram's statue in the living room. Piper explains that storage has gotten too expensive, and Pru wants it moved because it is ugly. She tries to use her powers to move it and can't. They hear Phoebe making noises and see her practicing kickboxing moves on a practice dummy, which she explains she purchased to practice fighting demons since she does not have an active power. The girls horse around, and Phoebe touches Pru and has a premonition of her being stabbed. "I saw you die," she tells Pru.
(Credits and Intro)
Phoebe is in the kitchen researching her premonition and trying to draw pictures of the sword she saw stab Pru. Piper enters and Phoebe tells her she hasn't found anything. The girls don't want Pru to go to work, but she says she has to go for a big account her boss wants to put her in charge of. They make her promise to come straight home. At Buckland's, her boss introduces Pru to Helena Statler, who explains she has a massive collection to offer at the Warehouse Flats. They demand Pru does an appraisal today, and she agrees.
At Quake, Piper is doing inventory when Phoebe runs in and says she found out Pru left for a meeting. She goes on to explain that she found out the sword belongs to the Lords of War, a group of warlords that move from period to period starting wars. Their swords make them invulnerable, and the warlord is trying to steal the powers of a firstborn witch. They leave the restaurant to find and warn Pru.
Pru arrives at warehouse flats and meets Helena Statler. She rejects a phone call from her sisters and turns off her phone. She begins to appraise the collection and puts her arms into a pillory, which locks into place, trapping her. The man from the boxing ring comes up behind her and explains he is there to steal her power. Pru unlocks the bolts at throws the woman across the room, and puts an axe into the man's chest. She makes a run for it, and the man removes the axe and throws it back at her. Pru escapes, and the evil brother and sister will try to find her at her house.
Back at the manor, the girls are getting a history on the warlords and the bad man, named Gabriel. Phoebe has found a spell to magnify Pru's powers, which she reads. Magic happens, and Pru is split into three seperate Pru's.
The next morning, the Pru's have taken over all the bathrooms, and Piper complains "This is like 'The Parent Trap' with a B-cup." Phoebe gives each Pru a different colored sweater so they know them apart. The real Pru gets a black sweater, and the clones get pink and blue. The clones explain that once Gabriel is vanquished, they will disappear. Pru has placed a call to her assistant to start tracking the Statlers through their antiquities. The doorbell rings at the same time the phone does, so "Pink" Pru runs to open the door as "Blue" Pru gets the phone. Andy is at the door and has tickets to a concert that he purchased months ago and gives them to Pru. He leaves, and Blue Pru tells them that Pru needs to get to the office right away.
Black and Pink Pru head into the office. Pink Pru talks to the assistant about the information on the Statlers, which she has, then sends her on a "busy work" mission to keep her busy. Pink and Black Pru head into her office, and Pru's boss yells at her about losing the Statler account. She tells her that she will go to their estate personally and apologize. Black Pru leaves with her boss, and Pink Pru calls to tell Piper to meet them at the manor. In the parking garage, Pink Pru is attacked and killed by Gabriel, and the real Pru feels it. Gabriel is upset when he does not receive Pru's powers.
At the morgue, Andy sees the concert tickets he gave to Pru that morning, and sees Pink Pru's body. At the manor, Phoebe answers to door to a distraught Andy, telling her Pru is dead. She asks what color Pru's sweater was, and he tells her pink, and she is relieved. Andy is freaked out that she calm, and she says that they always fought anyway. Just then, Piper walks in with Blue Pru, and Black Pru enters the front door. Piper tries to tell Andy that everyone has a twin, and Blue Pru tries to console him, and he asks if she decided what to do about the concert, which Blue Pru knows nothing about. Andy leaves, and we see Helena watching the manor. The girls continue to formulate a plan, and Pru decides to grab Helena to lure Gabriel away from his sword. Piper and Phoebe hate the plan, but Pru leaves them no choice.
At the Statler manor, Helena is telling Gabriel what she saw, and she tells him to attack while the witches are sleeping.
Back at Halliwell house, the sisters argue about the plan, and the real Pru thinks it is their only option. Blue Pru listens in on their conversation, and when Black Pru agrees they need a new plan, Blue Pru leaves to carry out the original plan herself.
At the Statler estate, Helena is tied up, and Gabriel enters and draws his sword at Blue Pru, who asks for his sword in exchange for his sister. Gabriel stabs Helena, then Blue Pru. The real Pru feels the last clone die. Phoebe thinks they need to find a way to kill Gabirle with his own sword, and she has a premonition that Gabriel is on his way.
At the morgue, the doctor explains to Andy that he matched Pru's fingerprints to the dead body, and they are exact. Andy leaves to confront the sisters.
At the manor, Gabrield breaks in and chases Pru through the house. Piper freezes him, Phoebe kicks him, and then Pru stabs him with his own sword. He vanishes. The doorbell rings, and an angry and confused Andy collects Pru and takes her to the morgue to see her own body. When they arrive, the drawer is empty except for a pink sweater and black dress. Andy is angry about all the weird coincidences, and Pru tells him to take her home.
At Quake, Piper is closing out inventory, and Phoebe is reading the newspaper story about the Statler murder. All that was found next to Helena's body was a blue sweater. Pru notes that Andy is suspicious and they need to be "extra careful".
At the police station, Andy is putting together a file on Pru and her sisters and the weird occurrences they are involved in...