Season 4 Episode 5


Aired Unknown Mar 02, 1975 on NBC

Episode Fan Reviews (2)

Write A Review
out of 10
51 votes
  • A classic of the genre and the series

    This is a technically spectacular episode that is gripping from the beginning to the reveal, one of the most cleverly plotted and uncovered of the series. Many familiar Columbo keynotes: the Lt. does not appear until a long and elegantly executed murder; his unceasing questioning peeling back layers of the facade, his suspicion aroused whenever someone does something completely out of the ordinary on the day of the crime (writing down the number of the art gallery on the magazine); a masterfully conceived alibi for a suspect who steadfastly refuses to yield ground, and yet continues to suppose what might have happened to the victim; and Columbo seizing upon the solution in the rare moment he is enjoying some chili, here a burger.

    The set is classic mystery theater, with a wonderful wood paneled study and a control room that looks like Scotty's office on the Enterprise. Many well-staged scenes contribute to a fast-building finish. The watch adds nice effect with the constant attention to the exact minute each event allegedly took place. Memorable scenes include the opening, the art gallery, the "gotcha" moment with the clown in the chair, the comparison of the tapes, and the incredible conclusion with the invitation where Mrs. Van Wyck and Columbo share an unspoken moment as he shuts the tape. The crime is superbly planned and meticulously carried out. Oskar Werner is very convincing in the lead and he does an excellent job building the familiar interplay between the killer and the Lt. The end is very satisfying, as Columbo has done a brilliant job proving unequivocally what really happened.

    The 70's tech in the episode is also very cool. I had one of those slick gold watches with "the numbers all written out" that I bought off the street in NY for five bucks in maybe 1981.