Episode Summary

EDIT
9.4
out of 10
EPISODE RATING: Superb
407 votes
  • Your Rating: 10
    "Perfect"
  • Your Rating: 9.5
    "Superb"
  • Your Rating: 9
    "Superb"
  • Your Rating: 8.5
    "Great"
  • Your Rating: 8
    "Great"
  • Your Rating: 7.5
    "Good"
  • Your Rating: 7
    "Good"
  • Your Rating: 6.5
    "Fair"
  • Your Rating: 6
    "Fair"
  • Your Rating: 5.5
    "Mediocre"
  • Your Rating: 5
    "Mediocre"
  • Your Rating: 4.5
    "Poor"
  • Your Rating: 4
    "Poor"
  • Your Rating: 3.5
    "Bad"
  • Your Rating: 3
    "Bad"
  • Your Rating: 2.5
    "Terrible"
  • Your Rating: 2
    "Terrible"
  • Your Rating: 1.5
    "Abysmal"
  • Your Rating: 1
    "Abysmal"
Rate Now!
A rising young star is killed in a wreck and her determined stalker claims credit, but the team finds out there's more to this tragedy than meets the eye.
  • awwww man! >.< this review is not for Sarah fans that's for sure. here there be spoilers.

    9.0
    "Superb"
    Finally we got rid of Riley! the quintessential non character. Non interesting non engaging, just a space filler. And who shows up? Sidle *groans*

    i started watching csi when it premiered and was a loyal viewer until GSR fans got what they wanted in that hotel room. I stopped watching for a year, then i came back because i was told it wasn't being rubbed in our faces. but i didn't like the miniature killer story arc so i stopped watching again. this summer i started from episode one and watched all of the episodes until now. I jumped for joy when Sarah left, and was on the verge of tuning in for real (not on netflix), until now.

    This episode is filled with twists and turns and just plain excellent. I truly enjoyed the attack on the lab. This would have been a ten start episode except for one thing.

    Why did the first truly good, episode have to have her? i was enjoying the conflict and investigative techniques until she showed up. srlsy? i know i'm watching these late but i'm guessing all of last seasons good writers were working on this comeback episode so Sidle couldn't ruin it. Well at least Jorga Fox is a better actress. Let's hope this won't last and Ms. Fox gets a much better awesome job. Please let CSI stand on its own. She left, please let her go and continue the show in a way that makes more viewers happy. i would hate to turn CSI of for good this time. What are we going to see next? Warrick is actually in witness protection?moreless
  • Wow. This episode reminds me why I like this show. Grissom and Sara were very important characters. And after them, everything changed.

    10
    "Perfect"
    Spoiler alert! Opening scenes are quite different and awesome. In this one, the case is good but the really important thing is the dynamic between the CSI's. Sara is always one of my favorites. And with her existence, this episode is more interesting and meaningful to me. She and Catherine's talk is awesome and also so emotional. There's just one more thing I have to talk about. Greg and Sara. They have a great chemistry on-screen. Last year's episodes are not so good. I hope, this new season will be amusing, thrilling and effective as expected. I wish we'll see more episodes with Sara and hopefully Grissom. I absolutely love this season's premier. It feels like meeting a good old friend.moreless
  • Sara's back.....but still no Grissom

    9.5
    "Superb"
    In this episode of CSI, the following happens. We open this season with a time freeze. As we move throughout the lab and the building, we see everything frozen in time. And yes it was true what I heard, the 1st minute is beautiful, but also reminded me a little too much of the Matrix. We then jump back to 48 hour earlier to one big ass scary spider. We open knowing that Riley has now left CSI, and they are short handed. And Langston becomes a CSI 2. The team then head to a crime scene where we learn that the victim is a rising young star (Olivia Hamilton) who was killed in a car accident.
    While everyone on the team works the death of Olivia, Greg has to work the death of an old man. During the autopsy, we learn that Olivia was pregnant when she died. Ecklie tells Catherine that he is adding a new CSI to her shift, and one that has been around the block. When the team look through the drunk drivers belongings (who is still alive but in hospital) we learn that he was stalking the young actress. Ray gets a letter saying that the board has cleared him of the death that happened in the season finale (if you could call it a finale). Hodges lets slip about the actress's case and soon it is front page news. We soon learn that the drunk driver wasn't driving the car that killed the actress. Someone else was and then after the accident, he was placed in the driver's seat. As Ecklie and Catherine have words over how she runs the team, enter the new shift CSI Sara Sidle. We quickly learn that she and Grissom are now married. Grissom is in Paris giving a lecture and when Ecklie phoned to see if she could recommend anyone, she offered to help out. When Catherine does what Ecklie said and reads Riley's exit interview, she claims that Catherine basically can't run the team. Soon Hodges tells Catherine that he was the one who let slip about the killer, but it wasn't on purpose and it wasn't an agent and not a reporter. She tells him not to do it again. Catherine talks to Sara about what she read in Riley's exit interview and Sara tells her she knows how to manage her team, and the only thing Grissom had that she doesn't, is her. Then we see David going back into the morgue, and into utter chaos. Water is running, bodies are hanging out of slab trays. We then see some men in black leaving carrying one of the body's in a bag. David tries to stop them but he can't so he calls security. But I find it a little hard to believe that they could all walk through the lab and hardly anyone tries to stop them, especially when you can clearly see one of them carrying a dead body over his shoulder (and I hardly think this is the new fashion accessory of the season). As they leave in a van, Sara and Nick shot at them.
    We soon learn that they didn't take Olivia's body, but the John Doe Greg was working on. When DNA is run, we learn that he was Olivia's father. Soon the van used is found, and so is what's left of his body. They put his body through a wood chipper. We soon learn that the agent who killed Olivia also killed her father. Soon through x-rays taken of the body before it was taken, we learn that the father swallowed a cufflink and so he is arrested for the father's death, but not for Olivia's. Catherine calls Nick(y) in to her office and tells him that she could do this job without him (which I doubt). And so she gives him a promotion and now he is Assistant Supervisor for Grave. As the episode ends, we see Ray and Doc at an autopsy, and as they discover something the screen goes to black. Hopefully they will pick up at this point in the next episode, but knowing what CSI has been like for the past couple of months, probably not. Ok so it wasn't excellent, but it was ok. A huge improvement on what the season 9 finale was, but still not as good as CSI used to be.moreless
  • This episode reminds me that Grissom is missing.

    8.0
    "Great"
    I think Raymond's character should be develop into something more unique and not to give viewer the feeling like he is trying to imitate Grissom. As in the part where he was kneeling next to the SUV and said "Doesn't really matter what he has to say, everything we need to know is right here in front of us."

    It was fresh to see him in the previous season. He should have his own trademark, not take over Grissom role. We need something fresh in the show.

    Secondly why is Nick Stokes suddenly become obsessed with spiders? Another traits from Grissom?moreless
  • I had given up... but I'm back again!

    10
    "Perfect"
    I missed seasons 8 and 9 and I had no intention of watching season 10 but well, I gave it a try and I was pleasantly surprised. The way the episode began was brilliant and original. Even when Sara was my least favorite character, I was very happy and surprised to see her back. She looked more relaxed, more eager to help, I guess marriage becomes her. That conversation she had with Catherine was very good and important and she was right, Catherine needed a 'she' on the team so she can focus her attention on different stuff. I liked the whole case. But the cliffhanger was more exciting. Can't wait for next week.moreless
WRITE A REVIEW

Trivia, Notes, Quotes and Allusions

See All

FILTER BY TYPE

  • TRIVIA (5)

    ADD TRIVIA
  • QUOTES (17)

    ADD QUOTES
    • Nick: What's up? Catherine: Oh, somethin' that's long overdue. I don't tell 'ya enough, Nicky, but I couldn't do this job without you. Nick: Okay. Love you too, Catherine. Catherine (smiles): I am promoting you. You are now assistant supervisor on grave. Nick (smiles): Alright, thanks. Catherine: Please have these FI reviews on my desk by tomorrow night. (Nick's smile fades)

    • (After Nick's spider gets loose, he lures him back with a cricket) Greg: How'd you know he was gonna be hungry? Nick: It doesn't really matter. They'll go after crickets no matter what. I think the chirping annoys them. (puts the spider back in the cage) That's not my spider, dude. Greg: Seriously? Nick: Seriously. Greg: Is that... Little Stevie? Wow, he's been missin' for years. I'll have to let Sara know so she can tell her... Greg & Nick: Husband. (they smirk)

    • Sara: Funny thing is, the father's death was probably an accident. Ray (about O'Neill murdering Olivia): And Olivia's was premeditated. It irrtates me that we weren't able to get him for that. Sara: But you know what? We know what he did and so does he and he can spend the next 20 years of his life dreaming about his perfect crime. Think of it like busting Al Capone for tax evasion.

    • Ray (about O'Neill): He's guilty, Catherine. Catherine: Okay, how are we gonna prove it? Ray: I don't know, but we will. (walks off) Sara (walks up): I like his attitude. Catherine: Reminds you of you? (Sara laughs)

    • Hodges (putting an apple on her desk): It has ten percent of the FDA's requirements for vitimen C. If you don't have your health, you don't have anything. Catherine: Hodges, who did you blab to? Hodges: Nobody in the media, but I did mention something to Tom O'Neill. But only in passing and implicitly in confidence. I would point out that I had not been explicitly forbidden from discussing the case with law enforcement community. Uh, memo from my supervisor to that effect would have been helpful, not that I'm blaming you. Catherine (throws the apple back at him): Don't ever do anything like that again. Hodges: Thanks.

    • Greg: Sara! (they hug) What are you doing here? You tired of being happy and married? Sara: No, Grissom is guest lecturing at the Sorbonne, while we're waiting to get our research grant to get founded, and Ecklie; called and said the team was down a man and he wondered if I could recommend anyone. And you know, as much as I love Paris and my French is actually pretty good right now, I realized I missed you guys. Greg: Well, we miss you, too. Sara: So, uh, how's the world been treating you? Greg: Oh, you know, still being treated as the lab tech with the crazy hair.

    • Ray (looking at photos of seatbelt bruises on Wilkes): Wilkes was in the passenger seat, he wasn't driving the car. The real driver crashes into Olivia Hamilton, killing her. I don't think the crash broke Wilkes neck, I think the killer moved a drugged out Wilkes into the passanger seat, the killer leaves the scene. The headline reads 'Stalker Kills Actress.' Catherine: Which suggests that the killer knew Wilkes was a stalker. Nick: Well, he certainly picked the right nut job. Even though Wilkes survived, he still confessed to the crime. Catherine: Can Wilkes corrobarate any of this? Ray: Oh, he won't. He's too happy being the new Mark David Chapman. Ecklie: I really hope you're referring to Richard Wilkes. (slaps a magazine down on the table) Ray: I wasn't. Catherine (looks at the front page that reads 'Vegas Crime lab confirmed: Stalker confessed'): Where'd they get this from? Ecklie; You tell me. Catherine: Well, I don't know. Ecklie: It's your job to know, Catherine. Nobody in this lab should be talking to the media about an open investigation, let alone one of this profile. Nick: Hey, take it easy, Ecklie. I'm sure she's not the leak. Catherine: I can defend myself. Ecklie: This is a discipline problem, Catherine. Just get a grip on your people. I'm beginning to think Riley was right about you. Catherine: What is that supposed to mean? Ecklie: You didn't read her exit interview. I put it on her desk. Just read it. (walks off, pissed) Sara (walks in): Uh... Hi, guys. This a bad time? (smiles)

    • Nick: Shooting review board? Ray: Yeah. (reads the letter) They cleared me. Nick: Good. Kill or be killed, Ray. It's a terrible situation to be in, man, don't let it bother 'ya. Ray: It hasn't been bothering me. And that's what's been bothering me.

    • Ecklie: Alright, look guys, I got a press conference in an hour and I'd rather not say something that I'll have to backtrack on later. Did Wilkes intentionally kill Olivia Hamilton? Nick (same time as Ray): I'd say so. Ray: I doubt it. Catherine: Maybe you should cancel the press conference.

    • Ray: According to the SMD's, Wilkes traveled 3.2 miles from the time of his last engine stop. Now, how do you travel that far, that wasted and still stay on the road? Nick: Individual tolerances vary, just ask Keith Richards.

    • Ecklie: I heard from some uniforms that you guys had a little dust up at the scene. Catherine: It was just a spirited debate amoung colleagues. My team's very passionate about their work. Ecklie: Yeah, they're also understaffed and have been for a while, which is why I'm adding another CSI to your shift. Catherine: Ugh, Conrad. I don't have time to train anybody new. Ecklie: Don't worry. This one's been around the block. You're gonna get along just fine.

    • Catherine (after Doc Robbins takes a picture of Olivia and adds it to his scrapbook): That's quite the ghoulish hobby you got there, Doc. Doc Robbins: I'm quite the ghoul.

    • Catherine: Busy morning. We got a possible 420 at a weekly on Boulder Highway. Greg, you take it. Greg: Are you serious? You're sending me on a trash run at a fleabag motel? Catherine: What's the problem? Greg: I mean, why me? There are people here with less seniority. Ray: Present an accounted for. Catherine: Ray, it's alright. Ray: I'd be happy to do it. Nick: No, no, that's not the point, Ray. When a supervisor assigns you a case, you take it; he knows that. Greg: Who asked you? Catherine: Nick I need you over here. Nick: You know better than that. Catherine: Nick! Greg, why don't you go over on the other side of the vehicle. Greg: Fine!

    • Nick: Looks like we have an eyewitness. That should add to the circus. Ray: Doen't really matter what he has to say, everything we need to know is right here in front of us.

    • Ecklie: What is this for? Ray: I am training myself on how to identify different knife wounds. Ecklie: Do you know how much ballistics gel costs? Ray: Don't worry, I'm going to melt it down and reuse it. Ecklie: Well, you've had quite the busy summer: 'Advanced Non-Invasive Tissue Imaging', 'Raman Microspectroscopy'. You're already two courses over your training allotment for the whole year. Ray: Yes, which is why, I paid for them myself, and took my vacation time to do them. Ecklie: I know. I like the attitude. You're now offically a CSI Level 2, congratulations.

    • Catherine (as Greg is carrying a container of goo): Mr. and Mrs. Decomp? Greg: 'Til death do they centrifuge.

    • Catherine: Sara, I know that you walked into some fireworks in the breakroom. Sara: What? Ecklie? Please. Catherine: No, I just read Riley's exit interview. She had some harsh things to say about my leadership, that the team's fractured, that it lacks cohesion because of me because of my managerial style. I don't know. I-I admit it, I admit that things are different since Grissom left. Sara: Well... it's like when a great baseball team loses its clean-up hitter; suddenly everybody's swinging for the fences and nobody's playin' small ball. Catherine (smirks): You're using a baseball analogy. Sara: Ah, apparently part of being married is attempting to share in your spouse's interests. Catherine (chuckles): Okay. That's a weird side of you. Sara (smiles): I know. ... Look, you still have a lot of great players and some new talent. Maybe you just need to reshuffle your lineup. Catherine: English, please? Sara: You are a great CSI Catherine, and you know how to manage your team. The only thing Grissom had that you don't... is you. (Catherine smiles)

  • NOTES (5)

    ADD NOTES
    • The opening shot is the most expensive and technology advanced shot, and the largest effect in the show's history. It took six weeks of planning, two months of adding digital effects, and three days of motion-control shooting. Every regular castmember was present in the second-unit directing (a first) and double or triple of the crew was involved for six weeks. It took six weeks to add effect shots. Finally, the episode was delivered two months after filming ended instead of the usual two weeks.

    • This is the first season premiere in which William Peterson (Gil Grissom) and Gary Dourdan (Warrick Brown) do not appear.

    • Garret Dillahunt (Tom O'Neill) previously guest starred as a different character in the Season 1 episode "Face Lift."

    • David Berman and Liz Vassey join the main cast with this episode.

    • Original International Air Dates: Australia: October 1, 2009 on Channel 9 Sweden: November 23, 2009 on Kanal 5 New Zealand: February 8, 2010 on TV3 Norway: February 9, 2010 on TVNorge Italy: March 4, 2010 FoxTV.it Spain: June 29, 2010 on AXN Finland: August 4, 2010 on MTV3 Slovakia: September 8, 2010 on JOJ Germany: September 16, 2010 on RTL Czech Republic: November 18, 2010 on TV Nova

  • ALLUSIONS (4)

    ADD ALLUSIONS
    • Ray: He's too happy being the new Mark David Chapman.

      Chapman murdered John Lennon on December 8, 1980, in New York City. Chapman shot at Lennon four times in the back, outside The Dakota apartment building, in the presence of Lennon's wife Yoko Ono and others. Chapman remained at the scene until arrested by police.

    • Nick: Individual tolerances vary, just ask Keith Richards. Keith Richards is a guitarist, songwriter, singer, record producer and a founding member of The Rolling Stones. He has been frank about his habits (cocaine, heroin) and earned notoriety for his decadent outlaw persona.

    • Catherine (after Doc Robbins takes a picture of Olivia for his scrapbook): That's quite the goulish hobby you got there, Doc. Doc Robbins collects photos of dead celebrities, we first found this out when he took a photo of Julian Harper in the season 6 episode Room Service.

    • Ecklie: Do you know how much ballistics gel costs? This is a running gag on the show, and reference to previous conversations in the episodes Who Shot Sherlock? from Season 5 and A La Cart from season 8.

More
Less