I was very impressed with the Season 12 premiere, which meant that episode 2 had a lot to beat. I was pleasantly surprised to find that my expectations were well exceeded with this episode!
What automatically makes Tell-Tale Hearts better is the case, a brutal quadruple homicide reminiscent of past episodes such as Gum Drops and Blood Drops, and ultimately provided a chilling and exciting story. The outcome is particularly unexpected, whilst it appears that all the suspects played their part, one of them it turns out was not directly responsible for the deaths.
Danson's character proves to be excellent once more, a clear contrast to Fishburne's overly-melancholy character whichemitteda sense of gloom into the show. The writing has noticeably improved since Season 11, ensuring that all characters get decent screentime and restoring some of the humour which has been lost the past couple of years.
The episode also gives Elisabeth Harnois' character a proper introduction, and she is immediately an interestingcharacter from the start, not only with her frustration with the SatNav but her interactions with Sara, Nick and Greg. She reminds me of Riley, but softer and more likeable.
The end of the episode provides some forewarning, including a sad moment which shows Catherine appearing to ponder about her job over her family and social life, her exit arc it appears has officially begun.
Overall, Tell-Tale Hearts is a superb episode, combining all the elements of a good CSI episode, an interesting case, good character interaction as well as some emotional moments throughout. If the episodes can remain up to this standard, Season 12 could well be CSI's best yet.