The investigation into a body found in a chimney leads the CSIs to re-open an investigation of an unsolved homicide of a female teenager named Caroline Fitzgibbons.
Incredible. This is one very, very, very good episode. First, the fire fighter found a body in the chimney and the CSI is called in. Catherine finds out that the house is actually her suspect's house (in a cold case). So, Catherine takes the chances to re-open the old case, although it is not allowed. Incrediblely good. I have to admit this is one very good episode. Although some viewers claimed this episode lacked of Grissom and Greg, but I don't think it has anything to do to this episode. The story is still good, and after 6 years of production, it is very unbelieveable that CSI is still good and getting better.moreless
This episode included everything that makes me love this show. I'm referring to a revolving storyline, a great mystery, extensive investigate work and of course, nabbing the bad guy and closing a case. After a charred body is discovered in a chimney, the CSI's are hard at work. The interesting thing is that Warrick & Catherine had previously tried to search the residence in regards to a missing persons case. Now that the home is a crime scene they get that chance. Although unrelated to the body in the chimney, they discover other evidence in the home to suggest foul play in the missing persons case. The episode turns into a case of mistaken identity regarding the body in the chimney as the CSI's victim appears days later purchasing gas. The intricate plot brings Scott William Winters into the scene as a heartbroken father desperate to find out the truth about his daughter's disappearance. I liked this actor from his days on OZ as the mentally slow Cyril O'Reilly. Great Episode!!!moreless
I\'ve always thought that CSI was more of a stroyline based show than a character based show. I always thought that it was the well crafted script which made this show so successful rather than the individuality of the characters. Well this episode proved me wrong. This episode was nothing but a filler. It felt like it too. Without the presence of Grissom, it made the case seem unimportant. I guess if there was any upside to this episode, it hopefully would have made viewers and producers alike, aware of just how important William Petersen is to this show. This is definately more than just one of those series where you can tune in any time, on an irregular basis, and thoroughly enjoy it. The characters tie each episode together, and if one were to leave, it would leave a massive hole in the show, none more so than Gil Grissom.moreless
I only watched this episode a week ago yet I cannot remember a single thing that happened. All I remember that the guy who they thought was killed was still alive and the dead body wasn't even murdered and it was all a ruse to get the CSIs to investigate the house and find the missing daughter of a guy who knew who killed her. There was nothing witty about the episode. In order for an episode to catch my attention it needs to have some witty comment from one of the characters. The episode didn't have a single funny moment. Oh well I continue to hope for a less boring episode to rescue us from the boringness that has plagued CSI of late. moreless
The show is usually good but this episode just wasn't That good at all. Like one reviewer says, it was Boring despite a great ending but that is our opinion And our opinion alone. There was lack of both Greg and Of course, the star and glue to the show, Grissom. Only In a few scenes since he is the star but liked Cathering and Warrick which made up the show a bit!
Goof: When they find the second body, Sara says, "This isn't the Tell Tale Heart it's the Cask of Amontillado. She was sealed into a wall and left to die." However, instead of saying "the Tell Tale Heart" she said "the Tale Tell Heart" by mistake.
Edit
Sofia: Where have you been for the past few weeks?
Tad Sidley: Tijuana, L.A., quick stop in Santa Barbara. Just got back this morning.
Sofia: Any idea how your gym membership got into a dead man's pocket?
Tad Sidley(chuckles): No. I'm sorry, I didn't even know it was missing. I'm-I'm not exactly big on the weights, you know? Look, uh ... I'm late for a movie. You mind if I get out of here?
Sofia: Sure. I'd just like to get your cell phone number.
Tad Sidley: Gonna ask me out?
Sofia: It's just in case I have any further questions.
Edit
Larry Smite: Yeah, that's it. That's him. That's your dude.
Grissom: That's Tad Sidley.
Larry Smite: That was the name on the credit card.
Grissom: Is this video from today?
Nick: Yeah, I downloaded it myself.
Grissom: Well, if that's Tad Sidley, who's in the morgue?
Edit
Hodges: Roof trace analysis. Afraid it's not going to be very helpful.
Sara: Why?
Hodges: Polyethylene plastic.
Sara: Compounds used in about a million different products.
Hodges: I hope that's not all you got.
Edit
Doc Robbins: Caroline did not go gently.
Do not go gentle into that good night is a villanelle composed by Welsh poet Dylan Thomas.
Edit
Sara: This isn't the Tell Tale Heart it's the Cask of Amontillado. She was sealed into a wall and left to die.
"The Cask of Amontillado" is a horror short story by Edgar Allan Poe.
Edit
Catherine: Kinda like Tell Tale Heart... Guy commits a murder and buries the body under the floorboards of his house.
"The Tell-Tale Heart" is a short story by Edgar Allan Poe.
Edit