CSI: Crime Scene Investigation

Season 9 Episode 8

Young Man With A Horn

1
Aired Sunday 10:00 PM Dec 04, 2008 on CBS
8.9
out of 10
User Rating
284 votes
8

EPISODE REVIEWS
By TV.com Users

Episode Summary

EDIT
The CSIs discover a link between the death of a popular young singer and a murder that happened over 50 years ago.

Who was the Episode MVP ?

Today
8:00pm
CLOO
9:00pm
CLOO
10:00pm
CLOO
12:00am
CLOO
Friday
1:00am
CLOO
8:00am
USA
9:00am
USA
10:00am
USA
11:00am
USA
12:00pm
USA
1:00pm
USA
2:00pm
USA
3:00pm
USA
Saturday
2:00am
USA
3:00am
USA
SUBMIT REVIEW
  • A murder takes place at an old casino, Le Chateau Rogue.

    9.0
    - Tippi Hedren...

    ... did a great job in the role of Karen Rosenthal. Hedren is a very experienced actress, and I have to say - it shows!

    Rosenthal is a loveable old woman who had an affair with one of the sax men at the casino. Great quote:

    Karen Rosenthal: You see, a white woman could get away with murder. But she couldn't love a black man.



    ... which leads me to my next part of the review:

    - The writing

    Now, we all know how super important the writing is to a show (duh), and the terrific writing on CSI is one of the reasons I love it.



    - The good ol' days

    I loved the flashbacks... and the music... with the saxophone. God, 50s music is the best!

    Think they did a great job directing the flashbacks. It seemed very authentic. Also, I'm loving the poker playing.



    To sum up, a warmly recommended episode!

    Exactly why I watch this series.moreless
  • The death of a contestant on a popular talent competition takes Grissom and the team to a Vegas hotel which was the scene of a homicide shortly before the hotel was closed in 1958.moreless

    6.0
    After this episode was over I was very surprised. Surprised that one of the best crime dramas of all-time could produce such a boring and badly written episode. There were a lot of things that went wrong here. The competition "Overnight Sensation" is one of them. Gee, I wonder what the model for that show is. From the moronic producer, to Kip's idiot father to Jasmine's breakdown on stage it just didn't work. The plot about the death of the casino owner and the story surrounding it recycled tired old plot devices. This episode is no doubt a total misfire.moreless
  • Quite avarage

    7.0
    So, nothing too amazing out of it - a story what looks much more promising than it was, some hidden secrets and it all coming out..



    So.. I really most say the case had nothing too exciting - they had intriguing start when it all happened and looked promising and I cannot say I did not liked where it went - the direction of that old club and the "ghosts" still hunting there - the woman in car and the old musician and how then it all was connected and I liked the irony - the woman did confess the murder long ago and got away.. and then she said what was impossible to her.. great twist.moreless
  • An old crime is solved

    10
    In this episode of CSI the following happens. When a contestant on a TV show is found dead, the CSI team are called in to investigate. When the autopsy is performed it is learnt that Layla, the victim, was 8 weeks pregnant. They soon learn that she was dating another contestant on the show and the team believe that he is the baby's father. But DNA tests confirm that is not the case, he is not the baby's father.

    The team head to an old casino which closed down over 50 years before. They believe that it was where Layla was murdered. When they go in there, it's like a time capsule. Nothing has been touched in over 50 years, apart from the murder of course. Her boyfriend soon confession that both he and Layla broke into the old casino, and Layla went on stage, all dressed up to sing. The homeless man living there came out when he heard a noise, and his gun went off and the next thing the boyfriend a gone and Layla was dead. So the man undressed her and moved her body. The murder which was committed in the casino over 50 years ago was that of the owner of the casino. Grissom soon learns that the man put behind bars for that murder was in fact framed. The old man soon confesses to the murder of Layla, but the evidence does not support it. We soon learn from the wife of the casino owner, that she was the one who murdered her husband after he found her with another woman. The team learn through the evidence, that Layla's death was an accident. We see at the end of the episode that Layla's boyfriend, Kip won the competition.moreless
  • I Love CSI, but not this episode!!!

    1.5
    After 8 and a half great seasons with little to complain about i have finally found an episode of the show i don't like, (well the second episode). This episode was so dull and it was such a shame as it is Grissoms penultimate case, i was expecting something more. First of all none of the characters seemed to really do anything, each of them walked into the story and then out of it. Why was this a single story episode? there was no need for all the CSI's to be working such an old case. And after a promising start the new girl seems to have already faded into the background, she looked to be a burst of new energy in her first episodes but it seems as though she has lost all of her personality and has become a part of the background action. I really hope this is the last negative review i write about this show!!! Hopefully things will pick up!!moreless
Tippi Hedren

Tippi Hedren

Karen Rosenthal

Guest Star

Robert Guillame

Robert Guillame

Sonny Bridges

Guest Star

Tiffany Hines

Tiffany Hines

Layla Wells

Guest Star

David Berman

David Berman

David Phillips

Recurring Role

Liz Vassey

Liz Vassey

Wendy Simms

Recurring Role

Archie Kao

Archie Kao

Archie Johnson

Recurring Role

Trivia, Notes, Quotes and Allusions

FILTER BY TYPE

  • TRIVIA (0)

  • QUOTES (16)

    • Grissom: Why did you move the body? Why didn't you call for help?
      Harry: Because I didn't want anybody comin' into my space. Wanted to spend my time in the last place that I was ever happy. We were like a family back there, beautiful moment in time.

    • Sheriff Montgomery: Wilson signed a confession.
      Grissom: Yeah, but they say some of you guys used to drive suspects out in to the desert, show 'em a hole in the ground and give 'em a choice of either signing a confession or getting in the hole.
      Sheriff Montgomery: We got a good clean print.
      Grissom: The file says that you lifted the print from Rosethal's alligator wallet, now I examined it, alligator skin would've left voids.
      Sheriff Montgomery: Y'know, in the old days, criminals used to be afraid of us. Now it's the other way around.
      Grissom (takes out a photo): Does he look familiar to you? He's been squatting at the Chateau Rouge. Now, I ran his prints against the unidentified from the scene in '58, this man was all over the place.
      Sheriff Montgomery: All the crime that's goin' on in Vegas these days, you got time to poke around in my old cases? ... Good to see you, son. Thanks for the drink. (walks away)

    • Sheriff Montgomery: Well, I'll be damned. You're two years late, George deal 'em in.
      Grissom: No, I can't, Sheriff, I'm workin'.
      Sheriff Montgomery: Well, then what are you doing here?
      Grissom: I was hopin' to talk to you, actually. About the Chateau Rouge.
      Sheriff Montgomery: One hand. You win, I'll talk.

    • Sheriff Montgomery (while playing poker with Grissom): You haven't raised once. Either the county's still not paying you enough or you're bluffing.

    • Catherine (to Grissom, who is looking at the murder file of Jules Rosethal): Huh. You actually found a file this old that rodents haven't nested in.

    • Nick (upon entering the Le Chateau Rogue): Wow, it's like somebody yelled 'fire' 50 years ago, and nobody ever came back.
      Greg: Yeah, you can still feel it in the air. Legands walked here. Louis Armstrong, Nat King Cole, Diana Washington, first integrated casino in town. This place was smokin' so hot every night, they added a 2:30am show. Sinatra, the Rat Pack, all the white headliners and tourists, came down from the strip, this place was singin' until dawn. Then six months after it opened, the joint closed over night.
      Nick: How come?
      Greg: Well, rumor has it the Kansas City mob didn't like the East Coast Boys, poachin' their pigeons. Back then there were only eight or nine casinos on the strip, 700 or 800 people were here instead of there... Well, you do the math.

    • Nick (looking at an old map of Vegas): So this was The Strip 50 years ago.
      Catherine: The Vegas my dad came to. Now, any one of the big hotels have more rooms than all these put together.

    • Hodges: What I don't get is why anybody would wanna watch that show-- I mean, I don't. It's a talent contest, it's more like a humiliation ritual.
      Archie: Well, you'd know all about that.

    • Catherine: There's the people who come to Vegas wanting to become rich or famous, and then there's the people that are from here. And we know that the odds are always in favor of the house. It's what built this town. You didn't come here to become famous, did you?
      Grissom: I came to play cards.
      Catherine: No, for real.
      Grissom: I did - I came to play cards. I needed the money. I thought I was in love with this girl, in college, but I kept getting' into debt buying cadavers and fetal pigs. There was no money left for the girl. Science took the pot.
      Catherine: Well, maybe it just wasn't the right girl.
      Grissom: Plus, poker allowed me to be a loner and still make money.
      Catherine: You're right, so when's the last time that you played?
      Grissom: I can't remember. You know, to most people risk is a bad thing. But in Vegas, it's a good thing.
      Catherine: See? You paid for your pigs, you got roots, you got friends, a family... Well, a work family anyway.
      Grissom: Yeah... I think it's time to up the ante.

    • Greg (upon seeing a costume at Le Chateau Rogue, to Catherine): Wow. You know I have a glitter fetish, don't you? (Catherine smiles)

    • Grissom: Hi, I'm Gil Grissom. I'm with the crime lab.
      Karen Rosenthal: Well, I hope your people are taking care of my property.
      Grissom: I understand that it has quite a history.
      Karen Rosenthal: You're too young to remember.
      Grissom: I've heard stories. Wasn't there a night when Sammy Davis sang, and the only way they'd let him off the stage was if he took the whole crowd to breakfast?
      Karen Rosenthal: More than once. Come on in, have a drink.
      Grissom: Thank you, but I'm working.
      Karen Rosenthal: Well, then you can watch me drink. (Grissom gets in the car with her) In Rome, they illuminate the ruins every night. The Italians see beauty in what ... what used to be. (gazes at the lights of the Le Chateu Rouge) It's been 50 years since I've seen lights on the Rouge.
      Grissom: She walks in beauty, like the night.
      Karen Rosenthal: My husband, Jules Rosenthal built this. Do you know that it was the first casino where blacks weren't turned away at the door?
      Grissom: Your husband was a brave man.
      Karen Rosenthal: No, he liked making money. He gave it the best of everything. The decor, the food, the music, it was exciting, magical really... As long as it lasted, but it died with him. I haven't been inside since-- since he was murdered there.
      Grissom: Why didn't you sell the property?
      Karen Rosenthal: There's no such thing as sentiment in Las Vegas. They would've torn it down and I- I couldn't bear that.
      Grissom: Would you like to go in now?
      Karen Rosenthal (shakes her head): Mm. You can only wake up once from a dream.

    • Brass: Hey, check it out. I've got you and Kip returning to the hotel after the time of the murder. You're like a team, right? You're in it together, 50-50. You know, the contest, the career, future earnings. It's a lot of money. And that's what this is about, right? The money?
      Mr. Westerman: Thirty million people tune in to hear my kid sing every week. How many people want to watch you?
      Brass: So you're on the road four months? How'd you work that out with your job?
      Mr. Westerman: I took a leave of absence.
      Brass: Come on, sailor, you abandoned ship. You quit your job, got a second mortgage on your house. If Kip screws up, you're wiped out. So I can understand how you'd cover up for him, and maybe you're even desperate enough to kill her yourself.

    • Brass: We know you left the Palermo around midnight. About 20 minutes later, your credit card was used at the Blue Madonna Motel.
      Rich: I wasn't with Layla.
      Brass: Her body was found three blocks from there. You beat rape charges once. Maybe you thought you wouldn't be so lucky a second time?
      Rich: This is ridiculous. Look … I was with a hooker. All right?
      Brass: Layla was pregnant with your child. That's statutory rape.
      Rich: Age of consent in Nevada is 16.
      Brass: No, have your lawyer look at the statute again. There's an exception when a person is in a position of authority with a teenager - like "executive producer". Come on, let's go.

    • Hodges: That type of ceiling material hasn't been used in 20 or 30 years. You know, it's as if your victim found a hole in the time-space continuum and was murdered decades ago.
      Grissom: Brilliant theory, Dave. Thanks.

    • Grissom: Mrs. Rosenthal. That is Harry Bastille.
      Karen Rosenthal: Well, you knew. So why did you want me to go look at him?
      Grissom: We think that he may be the man that murdered your husband.
      Karen Rosenthal: He didn't shoot Jules. ... I know because I was there. Do you know Sheriff Montgomery?
      Grissom: Very well.
      Karen Rosenthal: Well, I promise you that there is no evidence incriminating Harry.
      Grissom: You seem to me to be a woman that doesn't change her tastes very often. I noticed last night that you had a fine bottle of pink champagne in your car. It's the same rare champagne that was found in the room where your husband was murdered. Now, champagne usually suggests a celebration, or maybe in this case, a romance.
      Karen Rosenthal (looks at Harry through the window): We had no where to be together. So, we took a chance after the last show... Harry wanted to say that he did it. And I … I couldn't let that happen. I took the cash out of Jules' wallet and gave it to him and told him to run … and never come back.
      Grissom: And then, you and Sheriff Montgomery framed Melchior Wilson.
      Karen Rosenthal: No. I confessed. The town was very different then. And the men who ran it forced the sheriff to arrest Melchior. You see … a white woman could get away with murder … but she couldn't love a black man.

    • (viewing a dead body in the lab)
      Catherine (sighs): They make it to Vegas for the finals. Every kid watching wants to be them. It just … it shouldn't end like this.
      Grissom: Glamorous makeup. Fancy lingerie. Sex fetish that went too far? Perverted idol worship?
      Catherine: Wholesome all-American girl. Did you do an SAE kit?
      Doc Robbins: Not yet.
      Grissom: She may have gotten what she wished for - she's an overnight sensation now.

  • NOTES (4)

  • ALLUSIONS (3)

    • The character "Ajaya, with the fluffy hair", as Hodges called him, might be a subtle reference to "American Idol" singer Sanjaya Malakar who was a contestant on the musical reality show. He, too, was famous for his particular hairstyle which was dubbed a "ponyhawk" [a mix of a ponytail and a mohawk].

    • Grissom: She walks in beauty, like the night.

      Grissom is quoting the famous Lord Byron poem She Walks In Beauty.

    • Episode Title: Young Man With A Horn

      The title of this episode is a reference to the 1950 film "Young Man With A Horn" about a jazz musician which was based on a 1938 novel with the same title.

More
Less
  • 5:30 pm
    Thursday Night Football
    CBS
  • 8:00 pm
    The Biggest Loser The Knockout
    NEW
    NBC
  • 9:00 pm
    OK! TV
    NEW
    CBS