EDIT

Episode Summary

The body of a beheaded woman found in a fraternity house is a mystery to the CSIs. Now they must sort through twisted clues and crime scene after crime scene to find the killer that has them trapped in his own little game.
9.5
out of 10
EPISODE RATING: Superb
278 votes
  • Your Rating: 10
    "Perfect"
  • Your Rating: 9.5
    "Superb"
  • Your Rating: 9
    "Superb"
  • Your Rating: 8.5
    "Great"
  • Your Rating: 8
    "Great"
  • Your Rating: 7.5
    "Good"
  • Your Rating: 7
    "Good"
  • Your Rating: 6.5
    "Fair"
  • Your Rating: 6
    "Fair"
  • Your Rating: 5.5
    "Mediocre"
  • Your Rating: 5
    "Mediocre"
  • Your Rating: 4.5
    "Poor"
  • Your Rating: 4
    "Poor"
  • Your Rating: 3.5
    "Bad"
  • Your Rating: 3
    "Bad"
  • Your Rating: 2.5
    "Terrible"
  • Your Rating: 2
    "Terrible"
  • Your Rating: 1.5
    "Abysmal"
  • Your Rating: 1
    "Abysmal"
Rate It
  • Eye for an Eye

    9.0
    "Superb"
    Now, I have to say that this was one of the greatest serial killer in CSI history. Up there among the Living Doll Killer, The Taxi Driver Killer, Squweegl, and Nate Haskel.

    The only part of this episode that I didn't like was that it was such a good idea, it was smart and enertaining, and kept me on the edge of my seat, but it was only one episode, when I feel they could have done so much more with it! I would have loved for him to be a recurring killer. Thar was something I would have tuned into for several more weeks!moreless

    DO YOU AGREE?

    1 0
  • OMG!!! Suspect gets away, Hawkes is in danger, what will they come up with next?!?!?!

    10
    "Perfect"
    Holy crap, I was so not prepared for this episode! The t-shirt idea was incredibly original. When we found out who the killer was was a little obvious. And his motive was unoriginal, though, I think his brother's case should have been thrown out due to lack of evidence because that was a pretty medieval court case.

    I know some Greek mythology, but I don't think I've ever heard of Hera taking Zeus' eyes out and sewing them to her favorite bird. It was definitely a good idea. When Stella and Mac find out who the cornor was that did the autopsy in Shane's brother's case, I first thought Hammerback. But when it was Hawkes, I was all like, "WOW!! For once it's not a CSI in trouble!"

    When Danny and Flack were chasing Shane down the fire escape that ws truely an old New York moment. A personal classic. I winced and "oooooooooo!!" when Flack tackled Shane to the ground and they slid a couple feet. Then I laughed when Danny joined in. Dog pile!! lol, this was definitely a good episode.moreless

    DO YOU AGREE?

    3 0
  • 3x04

    10
    "Perfect"
    OMG!!!, this episode was really great, since I stared watching I couldn stop.

    Definitively, when CSI NY try to be the best, they do it and this episode proves that, I dont have any doubt about why this is a top ten episode, It was brilliant.

    I think CSI NY touched the sky with this one, Shane Casey is one of the most exellent assesins not only in Csi NY but also in the entire franchise.

    also, Im a graphic designer and I was very glad with one episode with a plot related with teachers designs and things like that, I really loved that. P.D: Im from venezuela, Im not an expert writing in english, please forgive my mistakesmoreless

    DO YOU AGREE?

    2 0
  • This was an excellent episode. It was absolutely pristine. Shane Casey, his acting was impeccable. So far, best of the season! Spoilers throughout.

    10
    "Perfect"
    THE BEGINNING:
    I love the shock factor of this beginning. I mean really. It starts off with a frat party, a bikini one, and then what do we get? A girl hanging with her head decapitate off from a ceiling, her shirt bloody. And how do we find it? Kids making out of course. They don't notice because the lights are off. But then she feels something dripping. And up she turns on the lights and they look up.

    THE CASE:
    Since this is an intense case, I'm going to do it by victims. Hahah. Well kind of by them:

    What's great of the case is the originality of it. I actually saw this guy selling these shirts, by the way. The real guy that is. I have to say I loved this case from the beginning, with the chick who had her head decapitated. I also loved the killer's logic. And who doesn't like Greek mythology? Hee hee. I have to say, how much, I love these shirts. I love the concept. Well okay, not Shane Casey's, but the actual ones. Love the concept. Though I do have to say when the voices spoke during the words on the shirts that freaked me out. So much.

    Of course a case this gruesome needed everyone. I love how the first we see of Shane Casey is with Danny, and how he, the killer, REMAINED there the entire time after the murderer. And he got interviewed by Danny first and said "who would do such a thing?" Man Shane Casey, though absolutely insane, was brilliant. OOOO though he was creepy. I love the first shirt we find and how these shirts are the clues to solving the crime. I bet Shane doesn't think they'd be smart enough to figure him out. Though I'm sure he wants to get caught so people know he's on a vengeance crusade. And of course, being me, I felt bad for their first suspect who couldn't remember a thing because he was so drunk. He is a genuinely sweet guy and seemed so distraught of the thought he might have killed the girl when he was drunk, after all there is evidence from their night together ON her. But poor guy is saved from another call. They found the head! And of course- another twist- date rape drug well the stuff from the drug was produced naturally in her system, as sometimes it can happen. Weee. And I love the second time Danny interviews him about the shirt. Stupid idiot wore a similar shirt to the crime scene. Dummy. And then he was all o the guy makes these shirts, but this isn't from his batch. He was definitely leading them on a chase. I bet he probably hoped they'd catch him, just not so soon. I mean, he basically showed them how to work the other website, basically saying, this is how you work mine too. And Stella and Hawkes work it. Indeed they do.
    Danny is just such a good detective. When he and Stella found out where he was from, I kept squeeing. I was like yay there goes my boy finding out where the pictures on the website are from! And when they get there? They find stuff for the shirts. And two more shirts, ready made for two more victims. Who we find out, are a lawyer, and Hawkes! OH NO!
    And then as it ends, Lindsay rushes in, "Shane escaped." Sent shivers down my spine, it did. Absolutely brilliant- YAY we're going to have a serial for this series! I mean Pratt kinda counted as one, but his cases weren't high profile, though they were realllllly bad.

    I have to say I loved Stella's work in this case as well. She did an amazing job with figuring out the crime and what his message was by lining up all the information on that giant window board they use. It was so great watching her piece the giant puzzle. And Melina is such a great actress because she portrayed Stella's joy in piecing out the puzzle so well. I also loved how Danny figured out Hypnos, and I also loved how Mac was slowly figuring things out as he was going around and around. And then the hair left at the scene was great for them, and also, they got the information that YAY it was a court case. Good job Mac. And I love how they figured out how great they were at figuring the next victims by comparing them to the mythological figures. Ooo and when they closed out and they had the face from the shirt glowing on his face, sooo creepy.

    Victim 1- Hydra
    I mean she had .26 BAC, and she was so unconscious, and had a date rape case, and basically so she wouldn't scream while he TORCHED her HEAD OFF. Nice. I mean can we get any more gruesome than that? Yes people have said CSI is very bloody and gruesome. But guess what. It's a show. About. Murders. You really think murder is all that clean? No. It wouldn't be truthful if they downplayed the gore. And as humans, no matter how much we want to deny it or be holier than though, we are attracted to the gruesome and the morbid. Why do you think when there is an accident or something, people slow down as the go past? Anyways, she was killed because she was in the jury. And I guess easier to get to? What a jerk.

    Victim 2- Argus the watchdog
    But really, what is up with this guy. EYES in the kid's POCKETS? Poor guy. I loved the story with that one though. So this guy was killed because he was the bouncer. Shane believed he gave a false eye witness report of his brother's crime. And of course when they lifted up his shirt, his chest is all covered with eyes, just like Hera's watchdog. NICE!

    FAVORITE SCENES:
    First was Flack saying how if anyone would call him bro, he would give em one. Man I love it when he interviews people. He is brilliant :D
    Also loved the scene in Shane Casey's room with all the laundry everywhere, and one of the shirts in a pizza box! Hilarious.
    I also loved when they interviewed the guy who made the shirts, and he was all you belong in Barney's. And then, HAHAHA when Danny asks how much they are and gets the quote of 29 bucks, Danny shakes his head and says, "Think I'll stick to Barney's."
    Another Sid scene when Sid was saying how the guy was not pecked to death with a peacock. Actually all of Sid's scenes with the victims. Wonderful bits of insight into Sid himself. Lastly, chase scene with Flack, Danny, and Shane. Brilliant stuff. SO GREAT! And then finally the scene with all three of them in the cop car. I love Danny for being so great with him

    OVERALL:
    This was an excellent episode. It was absolutely pristine. I loved the connections with the shirt, and Shane Casey, his acting was impeccable. I loved the connections with mythology, and the entire way everything was plotted out. It was so sad at the end with Shane looking out and everything with his brother playing out in his head. And the looks of my boys, Flack and Danny, as Shane is being led away in cuffs. Oh, it was just such a great episode. It fills a person with so much shock and kept me on the edge of my seat. There was also everything with the passion of Shane and you felt for him, you did. Because the way it seemed, it did seem as if his brother may have been innocent. Superb. Really. So far, best of the season!moreless

    DO YOU AGREE?

    1 0
  • Serial killers out of revenge, Greek mythology and Numerology. Excellent combination!

    9.5
    "Superb"
    Shane Casey is the best villain in CSINY. I give thumbs up for whoever it is that come up with the idea of putting the Greek mythology into the clues to solve the case. The writing in the t-shirts and the design are smart. Creepy, but smart. Shane appearance on the episode is also pretty deceiving. He helps the CSIs, and appears to be the only sensible one whatsoever on the party, and his overall attitude screams 'alright, i'll help, just because'.

    We see very little Lindsay in here, and that's probably due to Anna's first pregnancy. However, i think this is also one of the rare epi when we see her decent, in terms of her reaction towards the cruelty of the murders, and the contribution to the case-solving.

    I'm glad that Stella wasn't presented as the one who knows all the mythology. Yes, she's Greek, but Greek mythology is one of the most complex mythology existed in the world, and there is no way anyone, who's not focusing on that area as her/his expertise can know everything. Like she said 'Even us Greek have to brush up on our Mythology once in awhile'. However, it was quite strange that she doesn't know what happen to Hydra's immortal head. Hawkes is again a walking wikipedia in the episode. And, boy, is he not a Maths geek. Sid was brilliant. And creepy.

    Mac. Always the guy with all the answer. Why it has to be him that discover the different arrangement of the kodeTcone? It's like he's the master of this kind of game. He did the same with 'coward' in 4.10. Flack. Again, always funny! The Kevin-Britney comment, and when he talks to the perp, and all. The scene when he and Danny pursue Shane is also awesome. We kinda lacking that kind of action, lately.

    Then, there's Danny. I always know that Danny is the most interesting character in the show, but i just kinda realize how interesting he is. In this epi, he appears to be the most 'real' of all the characters. Knowing Hypnose, not because he is a walking wikipedia like Hawkes, but because he remembers someone told him that in one of his earlier cases; the whole conversation with Casey at the end, shows how he understandingly relate to the whole tragedy of the brothers, but still didn't justify Casey for what he did; the way he act when pursuing Casey, and the things he said when they finally have him are very spontaneous, and i don't know why, but it just make him more humane. Too bad, this Danny is kinda disappearing for now.

    This is a creepy episode, but a very good one. I almost can't sleep because Amy's head was kinda floating in my mind.

    Bottom line, one of the best episodes of CSINY.moreless

    DO YOU AGREE?

    2 0

Trivia, Notes, Quotes and Allusions

See All
  • Trivia

    ADD TRIVIA
    • When the CSI's are researching Ian Casey's arrest and trial, the words 'Found hanged in cell' pop-up on the screen when they first access the information. However, it is not completely mentioned until 3 or 4 points later, towards the end. Edit
    • Apparently, Shane Casey is supposedly gonna be brought back later in the season or a further season. Edit
    • So far, it's been made clear that no one is safe: Stella, Danny, Aiden, Flack, Mac... now it seems that Hawkes' connection to this case might bring him the damage he has been escaping. Mac's fear for him is nicely depicted despite Hawkes' attempt of contemptment. Edit
  • Notes

    ADD NOTES
    • Spanish episode title: La venganza se Tiende Fría, meaning Revenge hangs out Cold to Dry. Edit
    • Although this episode already screened in New Zealand last year, it will screen again on October 7, 2008 on TV3. Edit
    • International Airdates: Turkey: Monday, March 19, 2007 on CNBC-e. Norway: Wednesday, July 18, 2007 on TVNorge. Germany: Monday, Oktober 1, 2007 on VOX (Blutige Botschaft). Finland: Sunday, November 18, 2007 on MTV3. Greece: Wednesday, April 2, 2008 on SKAI. Edit
  • Quotes

    ADD QUOTES
    • Danny: (To Mac, after identifying the god of sleep) Didn't think I knew my Greek mythology, did you? Edit
    • Danny: Trump Tower? You got a thing for the Donald or what? Stella: It's the hair. Edit
    • (Flack questions a fraternity guy with alcohol bottles taped to his hands) Fraternity Guy: It's called Edward 40 hands, you know like Edward Scissor Hands, but with 40s. Flack: Get out of here. Fraternity Guy: No serious, that's what they call it. Flack: No I mean get out of my face, I never want to see you again, go! Fraternity Guy: Whatever bro. Edit
  • Allusions

    ADD ALLUSIONS
    • Danny: Trump Tower? You got a thing for the Donald or what? This is a reference to real estate developer billionaire Donald Trump who is the owner of Trump Tower. He is also famous for his unusual style of his air. Edit
    • Shane: The truth will set you free. Shane misquotes The Bible John 8:31-32 "and you will know the truth, and the truth will make you free." The truth came too late for his brother who due to his death in custody could never be set free. Edit
    • Sid: Off with her head! This exclamation is frequently made by the Queen of Hearts in Alice's Adventures in Wonderland, by Lewis Carroll. Edit
More
Less