CSI: NY

Favorite
4426
CBS (ended 2013)

USER EDITOR

boom-moo

User Score: 8350

SUBMIT REVIEW

CSI: NY Fan Reviews (290)

8.7
out of 10
Average
9,762 votes
  • Not really a suprise.

    1.0
    To my mind from the moment Melina Kanakaredes left between s6/7 it was always when CSI:NY would end not if, lets face it s9 only materialized because it was cheaper than Miami. I never understood why Christine was introduced in the first place she certainly wasn't needed and I don't recall anybody actually asking for her exactly the opposite. Fortunately at least we don't have to endure seeing Mac actually having to marry her remember some of us have been waiting an incredibly gruelling nine years to see him work off into the sunset with Stella (the woman who consoled him after Claire died, taught him how to loosen up, for whom he went to Greece for and whom he had to hear it from her when he was becoming to involved with the McBride girl ) it's just a pity that TPTB didn't have enough grace within themselves to let us have her back even for a brief cameo.
  • Veteran Police Detective Mac Taylor leads a team of Crime Scene Investigators who solve crimes in America's greatest city.

    8.5
    I always looked forward to the next episode of "CSI: NY" as much as I did for episodes of its two companion series. As with the other "CSI" shows I was a fan from the beginning and stayed a fan for the show's entire nine year run. One thing all three "CSI" shows have in common is terrific casts. In this case Gary Sinise was perfectly cast as Mac Taylor. He was a great leader to a great group of law enforcement agents. Also just as terrific was Carmine Giovanazzo as tough street smart Detective Danny Messer (Boom!). The show benefited from its well written scripts and very entertaining episodes. "CSI: NY" is the only one of the three series not to reach 200 episodes before it ended. It would have been nice if it managed to acheive that milestone, but regrdless, it was still a terrific show.
  • dont take it away

    10
    I love this show, bring it back

  • Goodbye good friend...

    7.0
    It was the best of the 3. But lets face it, it was time to say goodbye. At least, it will not overstay its welcome like the original CSI. For the past 2 years, they did excellent goodbye last scenes, never sure to be back the next season. This year was no different. That last scene was awesome, perfect! Goodbye! Thank you!



    Lets hope we wll see Sela Ward in something else as soon as possible. She was an excellent addition to the cast. One of my favorite actress.
  • Please don't end this

    9.0
    I hope this show stays. I really love it.
  • NCIS: RED will proabably kill CSI: NY

    9.0
    If you watched the last two episodes of NCIS: LA you could see they've introduced new characters just how they introduced the LA team just a few episodes until the season finale, they wouldn't invest in an entire new team unless they are pitching for a new reboot.

    Because NCIS Red is just a traveling show of two trucks would be cheaper to produce.
  • love csi ny

    10
    i hope csi ny comes back on also.

    this past season the show"unspoken" where lindsey gets hurt at a rally was really incredible, i imagine its hard for actors to express everything thru theyre actions and facial expressions, they all did a great job with this show, getting everything across without saying hardly any words, i know that actors can do this, but this team was great at it. ny is a fav of mine along with ncis and poi, so i really hope that cbs does not make a mistake and cancell this yet, at least i would like to see mac married and lindsy with another kid. marge
  • Please bring CSI: NY back for another season!!!

    10
    I would love to see Danny and Lindsay's new baby and to see Mac finally live happily ever after with Christine, along with more interesting crimes.
  • When is Csi ny next episode coming??

    10
    I Love the Serie.. :DD
  • Kanakeredes not on the show anymore

    6.0
    I noticed that the her name should not be in the Cast information anymore as she is not in the show anymore, thank you.
  • Mac/Christine realtionship

    1.0
    I like the crime drama aspect of csi, as i do ncis, but the relationship thing it throws it off balance, its just like ncis, gibbs wife dies and he goes from woman to woman, leave the love stuff out of it, its a crime show not a soap opera and christine made it seem more like a soap than a crime drama
  • If I wanted a concert

    8.0
    The episode tonight was absolutely miserable. Entire songs were played that had no effect on the show, in fact deterred greatly. i am very disappointed in the direction. It appears as if the songs are fillers for the lack of a script. If you can't generate enough of a script, then pull the show. very weak. my last episode.
  • Too much music..

    5.5
    My wife and I have been big fans of CSI and CSI New York for years how ever recently we've found way too much music being run during some of the scenes which in our opinion does nothing to enhance the enjoyment or telling of the story. Almost turned off CSI New York tonight. Can the music!!!

    PS, bumped into Ted Danson last year in LA. If I see him again this year, I'll complain to him to!

  • Ms Willie Mae

    10
    I think CSI-NY is in the top 5 CBS shows! Ted Danson does not fit into CSI at all! Need someone with caliber of Lawrence Fishburn!
  • CSI NY

    9.0
    Is there any legit place to get the transcripts. Gary had some awesome quotable line about choices! BTW...Love NY...Miami Blows all that fake tan blonde bimbette stuff and what is up with David Caruso...just un watchable! and Ted Danson on CSI is hysterically perfectly mindblowing!...and Elisabeth Shue (Happy Bday 2 her today!) is Amazing...Love her! CBS Rocks (CSI + NY, NCIS +LA are the only reason I keep CBS active!)
  • BOTOX CITY NY

    2.0
    Please, age with grace & dignity; would be much more enjoyable AND believable to watch if SELA had expression in her face & not a plastic forehead, and Gary too! What is up with 40-50+actors? If you want the ratings to increase, JUST BE REAL- hardly recognized Sela Ward between botox & her most recent noticable face lift- it made me almost vomit- UCK, a real deal breaker- had to change the channel, permanently. BE REAL PEOPLE, ON TV OR IN REAL LIFE.
  • bleed out

    6.5
    CBS let the show bleed out. Now the third year bubbleshow, which destroyed the show. CBS is to blame for it ... The rating goes down lately ... in fact catastrophic down ... in the final 1.1 Demo (where was you all)...and the show is allways the same... I would very surprised if if we have a full season.... i dont know if i want to see the season 9 .... for me its gone and i am very sad for it
  • Hate the change

    8.0
    I like Sela Ward in movies but, not on CSI New York. I watch for Gary Sinise. I don't watch CSI anymore. I don't care for Ted Danson. To much weird stuff going on.
  • CSI'NY

    10
    Hey everybody watch CSI'NY on CBS so we can get the ratings up and maybe save this awesome show!!!
  • CSI:NY Long May It Continue...

    10
    I used to like CSI but then CSI:Miami came along and then CSI:NY which is hands down my favorite of the three. It has everything, excellent cast, (except Lindsay, I don't like her character, after 8 seasons she really hasn't developed much, if at all and she just plain irritates.) There are some amazing stories and Sela Ward was a great choice for the show, she's so easy to warm to and just fits right in.
  • wubbywubby

    9.5
    I love CSI New and can't find it anywhere, where is it????

    I don't watch Undercover Boss and turn the channel when it comes on.

    SO what is going on with CSI New York??

    Know any place I can post a objection about it not being on TV Friday nights??

    Thanks



    SO NOW IT'S ON THE BUBBLE ARE YOU KIDDING ME?????

    What is wrong with these networks?????

    This is a great show, DON'T take it off the air !!
  • The Best Of All CSIs !!

    10
    There is no doubt that CSI: NY is the best CSI of the franchise! The plots of this CSI are the best I have seen (The incredible 2nd season,The amazing 3rd season,The golden 4th season, The pure gold 5th season, the amazing 7th season). Compared to the CSI and CSI: Mimai, this is the most action-filled edition of CSI! I love this show (even got T-shirts)! Well, I hope that there will be many more seasons! Sela Ward is way better than Melina Kanakaredes.
  • Sooooo Disappointed in all CSI's Now!

    4.0
    Sela Ward sucks....thinks she is so cool. Hate the show now, but hate Miami worse. Wish Grissom was still on the first CSI. Hated Ray! Kinda like Ted Danson., but now they brought in Elizabeth and it's like, what about seniority? The main characters go to the back burners! Please never change NCIS!!!!!!
  • The best of the CSIs

    9.6
    Whilst I love all three shows, some of the changes in CSI (Las Vegas) have been a little hard to take, and Miami was always the slightly weaker entrant. I was so looking forward to the new season (7), but the sudden disappearance of Stella (even though she was not my favourite character) and the replacement Jo was a bit difficult to swallow. Unfortunately, so far, even though the storylines have been great, Jo has not (in my opinion) been a success. I feel as though she is a bit too arrogant for my taste, and some of her actions are a little too conveniently "brilliant" to be realistic.
  • Stella

    10
    Stella was ok but remember the show has had changes before and it's just gotten better. Best show on TV and I'm sure they'll handle this change as well. Going along with more real world atmospher is better. They all work well together and each character and actor has grown and improved over the years. Look at Montana; now a very important part of the team. Don't tell me you weren't impressed with the ex - from the FBI even. I'm not sure the show would hold up if Mac left and, of course loosing favorites is hard but after all, like in real life Stella got a promotion and left.


    Still the best show on TV; only thing close is NCIS.
  • not the same without stella

    8.0
    Hey Guys,





    I have been a fan of the CSI range for over five years now and I love CSI NY season five and six were my aboslute fav. I am not as keen on season seven at the moment as most of you have said that the show has gotten better that is true it has gotten better.





    But Stella was one of my fav CSI's and I can't believe that she is gone, I love the fact that they casted Sela Ward to replace Melina Kanakaredes I think Sela has a more up beat personality.





    Oh how I miss Melina Kanakaredes.
  • A fine addition to the CSI franchise.

    9.5
    Every bit as good as it's parent show CSI, CSI NY is a real treat for fans of Gary Sinise. A fine actor, and perfectly cast as the lead character in this show. A very well written crime drama that is just as facinating to interested layman as it is to highly advanced techno-geek fans alike. This is quality entertainment for long time hard boiled crime drama freaks such as myself. Great acting, great writing and high production values make this a fine addition to the CSI franchise, and a weekly never miss event for yours truly. Long live CSI NY!
  • The best show ever!

    10
    This is the most awesomest show ever, and it is the best CSI in all of the 3. This show has everything, awesome cast, awesome stories, and awesome songs( backround songs). I absolutley LOVE this show!!! CSI:NY should never be cancelled, it should never end! The speciality of this show is that it has the hottest cast, the stories are very gritty and they potray it really well. The shots of New York City are taken beautifully, really makes you think they are in New York. And the guest stars are great too, like Nelly, Nelly Furtado, Kevin Rahm, etc. And the crossovers with other shows are great too. So, final word is: CSI:NY is the best show!!
  • CSI NY is Gr8 but I can not believe stella is gone, that's a bummer.

    10
    This episode was 1 of the best yet ever...The storyline was very intense and just when I thought it could not get any better.... BOOM!!!!!!! The suspense get's even more intense. The way every piece of evidence is collected, every little detail no matter how little is precise and on point... I just finished watching 10/22/10 episode and I just always love the way the story ends I just can not believe that she threw that diamond, emerald & gold ring in that wishing well, it is a ending that leave's you content and mesmerized as well as leaving you with the question, "What would you do? What would your conscious say?"
  • Amazing Show!!!!!:)

    9.5
    CSI: New York is by far the best show on television right now. The episodes always keep you on the edge of your seat. The characters really bring the show together. Gary Sinise(Mac) creates a perfect main character that has a hard side but really genuinely cares about his team. Melina Kanakaredes(Stella)plays a great second in command who compliments Mac's character amazingly. The other main characters create a great group of people that would be the perfect work companions. CSI:NY is a show that is very addictive and makes you wait in anticipation every week for the next episode to come on. The best show on tv right now

See All Reviews

< 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Friday
No results found.
Saturday
No results found.
Sunday
No results found.