CSI: NY

Season 1 Episode 23

What You See Is What You See

3
Aired Friday 9:00 PM May 18, 2005 on CBS
9.0
out of 10
User Rating
217 votes
9

EPISODE REVIEWS
By TV.com Users

Episode Summary

EDIT
While Mac dines at his local breakfast spot, a gunman opens fire, leaving a waitress critically injured and a man dead, and Mac having to choose whether to chase after the suspect or save the life of the young woman. Meanwhile, before the chaos, Mac was approached by a shy patron who awkwardly engaged him in conversation. After feeling that he saved her life during the shoot out, she asks him to join her for a drink and Mac must decide if he is ready to start dating after his wife's tragic death.moreless

Who was the Episode MVP ?

Saturday
No results found.
Sunday
No results found.
Monday
No results found.
SUBMIT REVIEW
  • An informant turned murderer, and Mac the witness to a crime. Great episode- great character development.

    9.6
    The Beginning:

    I loved seeing someone flirt with Mac. He has so much charisma and it seemed to be ignored for such a long time. And then there was the crazy shootout. I couldn’t help but think, you had to have stopped.



    The Case:

    The entire case was on counterfeit money! I couldn’t believe it. I mean, the shootout happened because of some stupid people. And one of said stupid people got his girlfriend almost killed. I felt so bad for the brother. It seemed so sure that it was him. I loved the scene when they slam into him. I loved that again, we had the entire team on a case. It was wonderful.



    Favorite Scene:

    Of course, it had to be the ending with Mac being on the date with the woman from the morning. It was adorable seeing him all afraid of being stood up. Great character development.



    Overall:

    This episode was a great episode. The case was intense, but mostly because there was a lot of back and forth that kept going on. We knew who the killer was, we just had to get to him. Then of course, they had to catch the person shooting at him. And we find him too. The only thing is that the most memorable part was Mac's date. Not necessarily a bad thing, as it is character development.moreless
  • Wonderful finale to the first season

    10
    What is it about CSI NY that makes it possible to enjoy watching the same episode again and again? I loved this episode back when I first watched it, and watching it again only confirms how good it is. Not only it feels great to see Mac opening up for the possibility of a new relationship, after seeing him suffering the loss of his wife in silence for the whole season. It's always interesting to see him interacting with people who don't work for him, like the waitress who knows him, the attractive woman who talks to him at the diner… Of course then he becomes Mac again, taking charge, helping the woman, trying to keep the guy from shooting, being the best eyewitness there's ever been. But Mac knows sometimes the whole picture is larger than the eyes can see, hence the title – what you see is only what you see, you can get a lot more when you dig after it. Hawkes appears distracted at the morgue, then we learn he's applying to become a CSI. By the way, in this first season, everything was so dark, sometimes it gave a feeling they were working in a basement – specially in the morgue scenes. Danny still had his glasses – how I miss them. Flack had sideburns and longer hair and looked like a kid, it seems it was 10 years ago or more, not just 4 seasons. Stella is wonderful, as usual, but also in her support of Mac and her clear desire to see him moving on.

    Aiden, now – I always loved her evident friendship with Danny, the way they'd joke and just be comfortable around each other. In this episode, we see her taking care of Danny, trying to help him, and it feels good for they are obviously not attracted to each other in a romantic way. It's friendship, pure and simple, and it sounds just right.moreless
  • I have never actually seen this show so I cannot comment on what its about

    1.0
    If I had to watch a TV show I would most likely to watch this. For one thing when I see their poster spattered all over a bus or in the subway, I think, wow, those people really look like they have a TV show. So I suppose if I should watch something, it should be this.
  • Nice finale.

    9.0
    I'm writing this at the same time I'm watching the chapter so it could end up being quite long!



    *I love the song 'It's a beautiful day'! The opening scene is great.



    *Mac in casual clothes looks great. Oatmeal person! Rose being all nervous talking with him and Mac's reaction was really cute.



    *Kinky JJ noticed that you can see Mac's underwar while he is applying pressure to the waitress wound.



    *OMG! Flack with long sideburns and a normal tie!!



    *Aren't Danny's eyes even more blue??? I want the glasses back...



    *I love Stella's face when Rose tells her that the guy she was trying to talk was Mac. She looks amused!!



    *I miss the old morgue. I think that Hawkes is filling the form too!



    *Can't Danny get in a room without making so much noise???



    *The bone thing Hawkes does it's kinda cool, and possible. Bones are flexible at least for a few hours after death and when you are alive too. *I loved Aiden being so concerned about Danny, and him being himself, 'I can't handle it'...



    *Flack's leather jacket is baaaack!!! *I love NY night shots, those images of times square were really beautiful!



    *Shooting scene outside the precinct: WOW... Mac and Stella were really near they could have received the bullet!! The shooter must be really good!



    *Flack without tie trying the bikes...*GASMS*



    *Flack needs a haircut... but the sideburns have to stay!!! PLEASE!!



    *Hawkes working as ME and taking pics of the vic at the scene! I love his purple gloves!!



    *Mac talking with the DA and then the wife arrives and Mac face changes completely. It seems to me that he misses Claire, of course, but that he misses having a relationship, someone to have dinner with after a long day at work...



    *Is Danny's accent even toughter to understand??? He looks great with those suits and shorter hair, and the glasses....



    *The thing they do with the bills is really cool!



    *The crystall investigator is such a dork!



    *The localitzation of the call was really cool too!!



    *The interrogation room is quite creepy!! Seems like an old basement...



    *Poor Danny... Mac is being a little wough with him but he kinda deserves it...



    * LOL at Mac checking out Stella!



    *MAc doubting Danny is kinda sad! And for a moment I think he thinks about letting Danny go and putting Hawkes in his place!



    *I love Stella's face when MAc says that it can wait until the next day!



    *Really good Smacked friendship moment!!



    *Mac being all nervous about dating is really cute!!



    *I really liked that the final shot is a New York view!



    Nice chapter! I really love it!!moreless
  • Everything is connected.

    9.5
    A shooting at Mac's favorite breakfast diner. The victims, the witness', the shooter, all connected. Man do I love this show. It turns out, there was supposed to be an undercover treasury operation going down at Mac breakfast diner. His favorite waitress gets shot and he's on a mission. Mac and the team become involved in taking down a counterfeit ring. With Mac as an eye witness, as Flack says can't get better eye witness information than that. I loved the links to the treasury, to the victims, from the technology to the informant working for the treasury. In the end the ring gets broken up and Mac gets a date. Works for me.moreless
Hill Harper

Hill Harper

Dr. Sheldon Hawkes

Melina Kanakaredes

Melina Kanakaredes

Detective Stella Bonasera

Eddie Cahill

Eddie Cahill

Detective Donald "Don" Flack, Jr.

Gary Sinise

Gary Sinise

Detective Mack "Mac" Taylor

Carmine Giovinazzo

Carmine Giovinazzo

Danny Messer

Vanessa Ferlito

Vanessa Ferlito

Aiden Burn

Garret Dillahunt

Garret Dillahunt

Steve Collins

Guest Star

Penelope Ann Miller

Penelope Ann Miller

Rose

Guest Star

Raphael Sbarge

Raphael Sbarge

Distric Attorney Latham

Guest Star

Grant Albrecht

Grant Albrecht

Dr. Leonard Giles

Recurring Role

Trivia, Notes, Quotes and Allusions

FILTER BY TYPE

  • TRIVIA (4)

  • QUOTES (12)

    • Danny: Mac. So I did the evaluation.
      Mac: I know.
      Danny: Felt like it was all good.
      Mac: Okay.
      Danny: About me and you... we good?
      Mac: We'll see.
      Danny: We'll see. All right. Good night.

    • Aiden: Hey, wait. Is there anything else you want to tell me?
      Danny: What?
      Aiden: Come on, Danny. Give.
      Danny: I didn't go yet, all right?
      Aiden: Well, you know there's a reason why they call it a mandatory
      psych eval, because it's "mandatory".
      Danny: What, are you my mother?
      Aiden: No, I'm not your mother, but a couple of weeks ago, you were in a shooting of your own.
      Danny: I am very aware of that.
      Aiden: I'm just saying it's not
      that bad. You go in, you say the right thing, and that's that. I'm just looking out for you.
      Danny: Don't worry about it. I can handle it.

    • Mac: This wasn't just a
      nickel-and-dime robbery. There's more to it.
      Flack: How do you mean?
      Mac: Two guys with no apparent connection, both carrying, end up in a shootout in a coffee shop? Something was going on in there.
      Stella: Maybe someone else
      can fill in the blanks.

    • Flack: Well, I'm never gonna get a better eyewitness account than this. What did you see?
      Mac: Three shots were fired. The first shot ricocheted off a metal chair, went through a pastry tray, landed in the wall. Second shot hit the waitress. Third shot killed the male vic, entering his thigh. I left my prints on the cell phone when I dialed 911. The killer was sitting alone. Left behind a possible DNA sample.

    • Mac: I think it can wait till tomorrow. Right now, there's someplace I gotta be.
      Stella: I'm impressed.
      Mac: I think it's time.
      Stella: Let me fix your tie. (She removes his tie) You need to loosen up, Mac. Have a good time.

    • Steve Collins: (in jail) They're gonna get me out. Just like last time.
      Mac: Last time they needed you. You're useless now.

    • Mac: I can't get a straight answer about who's handling Steve Collins. That means it's federal.

    • Mac: (to Steve Collins) I don't care what kind of information you have to offer. At the end of the day, you're mine.

    • Flack: So what you're telling me is you need some extensive road testing, say I take each one up to Taconic and back.
      Aiden: No I need tire impressions from a 180 spin out in order to match the bikes you need to match the tires.
      Flack: What about just the Harley, maybe I take that for the weekend?
      Aiden: It's all about the tires Flack, not the bikes.
      Flack: Speak for yourself.

    • (We find out Steve Collins was a confidential informant and that's why he was let out)
      Steve: You can't touch me!
      Mac: Sure I can. (Mac pokes him hard)
      Steve Collins: OW!

    • Mac: Make any headway with the D.A., finding out who's handling our C.I.?
      Flack: Textbook example of a departmental turf battle - Steve Collins might as well be handled by E.T. as far as I can find out.

    • Flack: (to Mac) Well, I'm never going to get a better eyewitness account than this - what did you see?

  • NOTES (3)

    • Tim Sitarz, who plays Adam Baxter, also appears in the CSI: Miami episodes Going Under and Hog Heaven.

      Garret Dillahunt, who plays Steve Collins, also appears in the C.S.I. episodes Precious Metal and Family Affair.

      Raphael Sbarge, who plays Distric Attorney Latham, also appears in the C.S.I. episodes Sin City Blue and Ch-Ch-Changes and in the CSI: Miami one Backstabbers.

    • German episode title: Falscher Schein, meaning Wrong Appearance.
      Brazilian episode title: Diante dos seus olhos, meaning Right Before your Eyes.
      French episode title : Expert et témoin, meaning CSI and Witness.

    • Music Featured:
      Beautiful Day by U2.
      Frozen Spotlight by Hardfloor.
      One Thought At a Time by Massive Attack.
      Behind Blue Eyes by Tooga featuring Pit Bailay.
      Is That Alright With You by Johnny Rodes Outlaw Band.
      Los Parranderos Dance by Daniel Indart featuring Mike Jimenez Jr..
      Right Here in Your Arms by Tammy Wynette.
      Right Here in Your Arms by Terry Frank & Rick Holmes/Kenny Arnold.
      Senseless by Kenny Inglis.
      What You See Is What You See by Daniel Quaranta.

  • ALLUSIONS (2)

    • Aiden pressures Danny to go see the departmental shrink. This is an allusion to 1x21 On the job where he was involved in a shooting that resulted in the death of an undercover police officer.

    • Flack: Textbook example of an departmental turf battle - Steve Collins might as well be handled by E.T. as far as I can find out.

      E.T. (the Extra-Terrestrial) is a 1982 science fiction film co-produced and directed by Steven Spielberg.

More
Less