Vern's magical skills have advanced to the point that he is going to create his own "familiar", so Cally and Lance try to use clues from the book to locate it before it hatches. Meanwhile, Dizzy is falling in love with Cally's friend Rebecca.
Cally, and even Dizzy, become worried about Lance, who has been spending hours and hours playing a new online game. But by using the comic, the others realize that Lance has been playing with his comic alter-ego, Blaze.
Lance is surprised by how odd Sage has been acting lately, and then she devastates him by hooking up with Vern! What he doesn't know is that a spell has caused an evil version of Sage to take over the real Sage.
Cally is horrified when she sees in the comic that her new crush, Emmett, will have an accident in his brand new sports car. So on the day of the fall dance, Cally and Dizzy must do everything they can think of to stop Emmett from using his car.
When Dizzy unwittingly gets involved with a bizarre initiation at Vern's new fraternity, he learns that Lance is not the only one who has to confront the horrifying events predicted in the latest issue of the comic book.