Defiance

Season 1 Episode 2

Down in the Ground Where the Dead Men Go

36
Aired Thursday 8:00 PM Apr 22, 2013 on Syfy
SUBMIT REVIEW

Episode Fan Reviews (5)

8.0
out of 10
Average
141 votes
  • Defiance is being too clever?

    8.5
    Firstly I must make it clear I really want Defiance to become a success! However this second episode left me wanting at best; Indifferent at worst. I appreciated the background setups for starting to understand the alien histories and cultures, but is it too clever too early? None Scifi viewers might struggle with these story lines being developed too quickly. The basic story line with Ben I struggled with. It just seemed weak. Perhaps a different line rather than Ben being resurrected would have worked better for me. The one thing the story did do well is leave open as to what Mayor Nicky agenda really is. The visuals seemed much better this week. The characters, the sets ticked the boxes. Particularly the white room scene.



    Miles to go...
  • Down in the Ground Where the Dead Men Go

    10
    Down in the Ground Where the Dead Men Go was a superb episode of Defiance and I really enjoyed watching because the story was awesome and full of character growth and plot development on many levels. The visual effects were stunning. The white wash room scene with Datak and Stahma was exquisite and very beautiful. It was interesting to see a clash of cultures and how it was handled. I kike how the series is unfolding so far. I look forward to the next episode!!!!!!!!!



  • While not as good as the premiere episode, I still really enjoyed it.

    8.5
    This one was slightly less interesting than the first episode but overall it did develop a few storylines well and the show is definitely getting quite interesting.



    A couple of characters we saw in the pilot were missing, which was slightly disappointing - mainly the mayor's sister. I hope she reappears.



    I enjoy the dynamics between the Tarrs and the MacAuleys. It is quite good.



    Overall, I'm enjoying it and I look forward to the next one!
  • It can go either way with the show, but I'm positive so far

    9.0
    I was "cautiously enthusiastic" after the pilot. I thought there came finally a sci-fi show that returned to the roots of the genre: super spacecraft, superguns, superaliens. While there's definitely a great room for development, I must say I start liking the show.



    We had very few Irisa moments in the second episode, but it was clearly the case of less being actually more. At least there's food for speculations about her past.



    When I was a child reading Tolkien's Valaquenta and Silmarillion for the first time, after Beren and Luthien's story I loved the mythology part most. It seems like our pale-faced new citizens, who, by the way, very much resemble Elves, do have their own mythology, their own pantheon and written and unwritten laws. This gives a very good potential for a few spicy scenes of culture clash, just like the ones we've already seen. They kept my attention for the whole duration of the episode.



    Some reviewer mentioned Spartacus flashbacks after the Jaime Murray spa scene. It may very well be the case, and it may be already obvious, just into the second episode, who's wearing the pants in the Tarr mansion. A scheming bitch with a smooth tongue, Stahma is the proverbial woman who stands behind the successful man, and she got plenty of screen time to prove it already.



    Overall, there's a feeble status quo in Defiance, and that's what gives the creators plenty of chance for development and creativity. I hope they won't mess up this show, it would be a shame. We've seen fantastic shows die an untimely death and I wouldn't like this one end up the same way.



    Pluses:

    - Stahma

    - Irisa

    - Nina's secret agenda

    - potential in alien characters

    - few sharp one-liners, especially in the pilot



    Minuses:

    - bad CGI

    - Nolan's character

    - some really horrible dialogues



    Let's see what Ep3 brings, shall we?
  • Defiance.

    9.5
    As we found out, the former Mayor Nicky is the one behind all of what is going on in Defiance, but what is her end game. Now that Ben is dead, whats Nicky's back up plan. One character i do love in this show is Irisa Nyira, so there is going to be a wedding after all between Christie & Alak. At the end what did McCawley find in Luke's draw, what was the map & that mysterious gold piece. Still getting to know the characters names in this show, Fantastic Episode, Cant wait for next weeks episode, looks interestinging.
Friday
No results found.
Saturday
No results found.
Sunday
No results found.
More
Less