Horrible execution and there was no design that I saw in either of the apartments completed, actually they were not complete at all! It would definately not provide that oasis that one needs to recharge and prepare for the next days work. You provided a few basics, one could get that from a hotel room!
I did not even care what their hosting ability showed, you must not only be able to talk the talk but walk the walk which no one was able to do. I love all three of the designers and you must be wondering how you are gpoing to decide on a winner overall.