This week in "Popping Cherry" we get further along in understanding Dexter, Deb, Angel, Lt. LaGuerta, Doakes and the Ice Truck Killer. We also learn the details surrounding Dexter's first kill and that there are some things Harry didn't teach h
9.2
"Superb"
This show continues to impress, with its truly well fleshed out characters. One fault of many shows these days is the tendency to have a “rough” idea of who and what a character is, and then to develop that as the show goes along. Dexter (in this and so many ways) is truly different. The only character that has not seen to be (at least by me) as well developed is Lt. LaGuerta. We don’t really know what drives her and her personality can go from “tough as nails and commanding” (like when she confronted Doakes last week about his affair with Kara Simmons) to kind of “weak and insecure” as she appears around Dexter. While you might argue that this range is evidence of her being well developed, her motivations for her actions and the believability of them still lack. In “Popping Cherry” an interesting series of things occur. First, there is the picking of the next victim for “Dexterization.” As Dexter tells it “Florida prisons kick free 25,000 inmates a year, they don’t do that for me, but it sure feels like it. I search for the ones who think they’ve beat the system. They’re not hard to find.” Indeed, it is from a freshly paroled group of such inmates that he selects Jeremy Downs. My first objection to this selection is that unlike other Dexter victims, Jeremy has only committed one crime. Not only this, but he has actually served time in prison for it and he is a very young man. Still, Dexter manages to convince me that Jeremy is a suitable target because as Dexter told us last week, he can very easily spot another killer. More easily than anyone else can it seems. Even the coroner in Jeremy’s case was apparently wrong, Dexter says “to the coroner the knife stokes looked random, impulsive, but I saw the work of a young virtuoso.” Further we learn that Dexter is convinced that he will strike again. “I knew who he was and what he’d do again, all I had to do was circle my calendar and wait.” So wait he does and Jeremy does in fact take another young man into a park and it indeed looks like he is going to kill him. Dexter intervenes and saves the young man and scares them both away. Jeremy’s fate is all but sealed, when Dexter confronts him to kill him, we learn Jeremy killed his first victim immediately following being raped by him. This causes Dexter to change his mind and spare Jeremy. Herein lays my dilemma. Up until now (granted only 2 episodes in) I have very much agreed with Dexter’s justice and his choices. Not this time. Assuming that Jeremy told the truth and he was raped, I believe that his killing of the young man who raped him was an extreme response. I do not condone rape in any way, shape, or form, but still a death sentence is extremely extreme. Jeremy is apparently another killer who loves to kill. Dexter claims to recognize this, he stopped Jeremy from killing what was a totally innocent victim (the second boy) and Jeremy clearly loves knives and has studied how and where to cut people. So I went from thinking he was a poor choice to be “Dextered” to believing it to perhaps be a good choice. Dexter is right, he knows who and what he is and he will strike again. Then Dexter lets him go. He not only lets him go, he lets him know who he is and where he lives. Jeremy had stolen Dexter’s wallet after smashing out the window in his car after Dexter frightened him away from killing the second boy in the park. Could it be that this is not the last we have seen of Jeremy?
I wonder if Dexter might not take him “under his wing” and teach him the ways of a killer and the “code of Harry.” Dexter has some unique insight as to where he would be without it. “Without the code of Harry, I’m sure I would have committed a senseless murder in my youth, just to watch the blood flow.” Whether I ultimately feel this episode reflects a flaw in Dexter and his ways will at last depend on what further develops from this encounter with young Jeremy. Deb is coming into her own as a homicide detective and making some keen observations, she also learned (in a harsh dressing down by the Captain) to respect the chain of command. I predict an ultimate showdown for her and Lt. LaGuerta. Doakes makes a brave (and admirable) move against Guerrero and winds up being set up by Kara’s brother (also a cop) who knows about their affair. Earlier he almost stands up to LaGuerta in defending Deb as a good cop, these two events show him to be a good cop and good man. It is the first time thus far that I found myself feeling compassion for him. I find the scenes with Rita this week to be a bit contrived, however, her line about “I can’t help it, I kill things” (in reference to fruit trees) followed by Dexter’s reply of “how awful for you!” was hilarious. We also learn that despite all his training and his code, Harry did not teach Dexter everything. “But there was something that Harry didn’t teach me, something he didn’t know, couldn’t possibly know, the willful taking of life represents the ultimate disconnect from humanity, it leaves you an outsider, forever looking in, searching for company to keep.”
Dexter started to really know this following his first ever human kill. It was the nurse who looking after Harry in the hospital (and as it turns out, slowly poisoning him). Dexter takes her out in what is a brilliant scene involving him and actress Denise Crosby (Lt. Tasha Yar on Star Trek NG). It was a messy kill, but then as Dexter himself tells us “hey; perfecting a new craft takes time.” Despite minor (and they are minor) hiccups, I am still of the opinion that it is one of the best shows currently on television. Look for some serious competition at the Emmy’s by Dexter and his gang. I give this episode a solid 9 out of 10.