Dexter heads to Brother Sam's funeral, which is at the same spot as the baptism. Brother Sam had left him a bible, which is caked in blood. Then, Dexter goes to visit Travis at work. Travis is worried that Professor Gellar is going to kill his sister. Dexter gets assigned to investigate a crime scene where a woman was murdered.
Dexter reads the Bible and uses it to try to manipulate Travis to cooperate with him. Meanwhile, Deb tries to get a hold of Travis and visits his sister. She finds Lisa dead with her business card pinned to her skin. Professor Gellar is trying to teach Travis a lesson about penance.
Deb is really bothered that Dexter won't open up to her. She gets suspicious when she finds a Nebraska pen in Dexter's bag. She tells her therapist about her issues with her brother. Deb confronts Dexter and insists he comes over for dinner. Bad timing, because Dexter just found out where Travis is hiding. He leaves Deb pissed to try and save Travis. Professor Gellar gets a chance to escape since he heard Dexter's car coming.