Personally, I thought season 1 was better because it was more creative, and the storylines were much more emotional and personal than season 2. I think that season 2 was pretty much a blow-off season because they took stories of other celebs and made it their own. I really don't like hearing the story of Britney Spears twice. I also liked the "darkness" of season 1. Season 2 was too happy-go-lucky, and Lucy also changed a lot.