Friends with Benefits
8.3
"Great"
Probably one of the most buzzed-about finales I've ever personally experienced, the media was all over the Jennifer Aniston-Courteney Cox reunion and, more importantly "lesbian kiss", for months, so I wasn't expecting too much from it, since stuff like this is always blown way out of proportion. On the kiss front, it was almost non-existent, but I did love the two of them acting together again, even though the writers could have done so much more with it.
I was expecting Tina Harrod to be an uber-b*tch of epic proportions, but she instead turned out to be a pretty caring, all-together mom who happened to be a tabloid editor. Whilst she was still an interesting character, they could have made her so much better. If I was Matthew Carnahan, I would have had a lot more fun with the Friends reunion, increasing the sexual tension between them, making Tina the aforementioned uber-b*tch everybody was expecting, and made her a threat to Lucy. Seeing as she has been intimate with her on several occasions, Tina was one of the few people with genuine power over Lucy, and it was unfortunate that such a big opportunity was wasted.
Outside of the reunion, the rest of the finale was pretty hit-and-miss. The stalker storyline had a disappointing pay-off, especially as the whole Dirt In the Trunk sweepstakes made it seem so important to the show. Instead, the revelation of the stalker's identity was dealt with pretty lazily, especially as Lucy only expressed any real sadness over it in one scene, before returning to her normal self. Plus, it would have been so much more interesting for the stalker to be somebody other than Leo. It was so obvious it would be him anyway, since he was out of the show for the episodes where the stalker was most active. Like Nip/Tuck and the Carver arc, a big mystery ended with the most likely suspect being the culprit, leaving the audience feeling slightly cheated.
The only part of these scenes that really worked for me was when Lucy begged Gareth DaSilva that the stalker isn't Don. The Lucy/Don relationship has been, by far, the best thing Dirt has produced, and I hope to see more of this evolved on if the show's renewed for a second season. This is the same with Willa, as the last shot of her promises she'll descent into complete Single White Female territory at some time down the line, and I personally would love to see that on the show.
The closing moments were so bizarre. Both Lucy and Julia are stabbed, and Lucy calls Don for help. Turning up to find her (maybe dead) body slumped on the ground, he proceeds to take a bunch of pictures, possibly hinting that Lucy wanted to be the focus of a huge story if it was her time to die. Go out with a bang that'll make history, e.g. "TV starlet murders tabloid editor". Again, another story I hope we see a pay-off to. And don't even get me started on the mystery surrounding the suicide of Lucy's dad, which completely needs a resolution.
Whilst not a perfect episode, Ita Missa Est was still an entertaining hour, with great acting and some of the best characterization on TV. I really hope FX renews Dirt for another year, as it clearly has a lot of potential, and has so far just barely scraped the surface of what it could eventually become if it's given a worthy chance.
Director: Matthew Carnahan
Writer: Matthew Carnahan
Rating: B-moreless