A show whose reach far exceeds its grasp, but somehow is managing to hang on to life. Satisfyingly enough, the first season got progressively (if slowly) better. It will either break out or break down in its next year.
7.2
"Good"
It's nice to be pleasantly surprised (if only a little bit) by a mainstream, crowd-pleasing, studio-friendly show. After the first episode, I was convinced that I'd lose interest before episode four. But I watched the whole season through, and am reserving final judgement until season two. One thing's for sure: it's trying way too hard to be a sexy, hip, billionaire teddy-boy version of The West Wing. A big ensemble cast with a couple of screen veterans, power-dealing breakfasts and social commentary (poorly executed, in the case of DSM) does not a Sorkin make. So they may as well give up on that and focus on what is going right.
Or, rather, on what four of the many characters are doing right. That's right folks - somehow, Dirty Sexy Money made it to a second season on the backs of four actors: Peter Krause and the ever-watchable Donald Sutherland, supported by Zoe McLellan (PK's onscreen wife) and Seth Gabel (one of the Sutherland 'children'). All four transcend the writing and their co-stars (some of whom desperately need to go) and account for everything good about the show. Oh, and the chauffeur's quite good too.
Seriously, though, practically everything else is totally bland. With the exception of the occasional excellent guest star and the intriguing concept and plot hook (Krause, aka Nick George, is a problem-solving lawyer! he looks after an insanely rich family and its self-obssessed kids! but who killed his father? was it Donny? and who was daddy really working for?), it's nothing special. Music, direction, even script - all mediocre, at best quite entertaining. But somehow, Sutherland manages to keep the audience in a continuous state of suspended ambivalence with regards to his character. 'Tripp' Darling, multi-billionaire, father of five, megalomaniac and philanthropist - he's a bad guy, but Sutherland makes him so damned nice, week after week!
How does that work? Who knows. The Fantastic Four valiantly battle their way through the shallow waters of mediocrity and make us believe in them. Yes, and even like them. And enjoy watching them play. This show is a salutory example to all the writers, directors and producers out there who think that they can take on the likes of West Wing, Studio 60, Sopranos and Firefly. Big casts, sweeping ideas and complex plot and character interactions are not for those of lesser talent. And, let's be honest, DSM is run by lesser talents.
I kept watching, though, so it's not all bad. I have a horrible feeling about series two, however. There is a lot of work to do, and if the production team can't pull something out of the bag, it'll be curtains as far as its chance of ever being 'a decent show' goes. Having four good characters and a plot that can't take much more stretching is not a stable foundation for a show only ten episodes in. Without a huge revision (like recasting, for example!) or an earth-shatteringly good idea (or three), DSM will be out of steam in another ten episodes. And by that, I mean that there isn't much story left in the old dog.
What can I possibly mean? Surely you can just keep writing and writing indefinitely? Yeah, they could kill Tripp off in the shower and then bring him back, plenty of mileage left, eh? No. Don't be silly. Good stories have a point. A story for the sake of airtime is not a story - it's a soap opera. As it stands, we're set up for either: a) a big showdown in eight episodes, or, b) three more years of Lost-like flogging of a very dead horse. And if you can't take that kind of opinion, well then I suggest you comfort yourself with an all-night Dynasty marathon. That'll make you feel better, and forget all about the nasty man and his unreasonable demands for a real story.
Dirty Sexy Money could be really good. It could win awards. It could be remembered for more than two years, and it's DVDs could fetch more than 99p on eBay. I hope it does, and then I'll happily eat my words. What are the chances? Watch this space...