Saturday 8:00 PM on BBC AmericaIn Season
David Tennant is my Doctor, and always will be. But out of the three I've watched, Matt Smith comes a VERY close second. His hyperness and eagerness are reminicent of 10, but he also brings his own sense of quirkiness to it as well. So Tennant, with Smith a couple of steps behind.
Tennant, definitely. Partly because he was my first Doctor, but also because a) I liked his shennanigans, b) he got to have Donna as his companion/best friend, and c) they wrote in really good character depth for him periodically throughout his tenure as the Doctor.
|Smith is nowhere near as good as tennant, actually smith is pretty boring, it feels like he is never really actively doing anything.|
Actually, I was going to comment on that somewhat. I don't think it's so much that Matt Smith is "boring" like you say. If you watch Matt Smith's performance (not "Smith as the Doctor" but "Smith acting and adding to the role") then you can tell that he really does have what it takes to be a fantastic Doctor. My issue is with the writers on this one. They're still writing the role very much as the 10th Doctor. They haven't quite separated and fleshed out their own 11th Doctor writing style.
I liked David better.. However that first scene with Matt Smith and the little girl Ami was priceless. I laugh and laugh when I think of the scene. BUT since then I find the doctor still is trying to remember who he is. Like someone else said David's DR seemed alot more in control. AND yes that could be the writing but it is what it is. I wish they would bring Rose and the One hearted DR back for an episode. I want to see what happened to the duplicate and Rose.
|more in control. AND yes that could be the writing but it is what it is. I wish they would bring Rose and the One hearted DR back for an episode. I want to see what happened to the duplicate and Rose.|
|Never Bring Rose Back unless it's to see her get murdered and her dead body cut by the human doctor|
I would have to say Tennant was my favoitrite. I liked his personallity and he was energetic. Matt smith is to boring to me he has no depth. tennant could have a angry side and i liked that about him. Smith hasn't really shown me that his angry side is even there. which = no depth in the charachter.
On the subject of Rose. I miss rose like crazy.. she will always be my favorite companion. But she should never come back Rose was Tennants and they belonged together even if it was his crazy half human clone thingy.
Smith hasn't really shown me that his angry side is even there.