Drake and Josh meet a girl and they both fight over her. Thinking that the other can totally get more girls than the other, they make a bet to see who can get the most girls in one week. Drake meets a girl at a music store named Carly while Josh is not getting any girls that easily. Drake really likes Carly and doesn't want to date anyone else, so when Carly hears about this bet, she refuses to date Drake anymore. As with Josh, he gets Audrey to help him get girls and her advice actually works. Then Drake tries to prove to Carly that he is honest while Josh goes through a whole montage of dates. After a failed attempt with Craig and Eric, Drake gathers a ton of people and shows Carly that he truly is honest. This plan works, and just as they get back together, the bet ends and Josh wins by 21 more girls.