Although Cumberbatch is unbeatable as Holmes (and Moffat does a incredible job in both series ''Sherlock'' and ''Dr. Who''), here are some of the reasons why I think ''Elementary'' is better than the BBC's Sherlock:
1- Although not based on the originals, the scripts of the CBS show are closer to the spirit of the original stories (a reading of some of them is a must) ;
2- As a series, 42 minutes is best suited for TV than 90;
3- Holmes was not as stupid socially as Moffat's vision;
4- At least for now (5th episode) no mention of Moriarty (but now the plague is upon us).
The character of Moriarty, as Holmes's greatest enemy, was introduced primarily as a narrative device to enable Conan Doyle to kill off Sherlock Holmes, and only featured directly in two of the Sherlock Holmes stories.
IN either version, the BBC's or the absurd version of Downey Jr,
Moriarty is overused. Enough of that.
The actors are very well and possibly will improve.
REASSESSING after the 5th episode: Jonny L. Miller and are continuously improving in their roles, as well as the dialogues.
I'm in Brazil, where the TV programs are horrible, basically soap operas in prime time, so i turn to UK and USA, source of the best television on the planet.
moreless
Elementary
Thursday 10:00 PM on CBS Premiered Sep 27, 2012 Between Seasons
Previously Aired Episode
| S 1 : Ep 24 | Heroine | Aired 5/16/13 | |
| S 1 : Ep 23 | The Woman | Aired 5/16/13 | |
| S 1 : Ep 22 | Risk Management | Aired 5/9/13 | |
| S 1 : Ep 21 | A Landmark Story | Aired 5/2/13 | |
| S 1 : Ep 20 | Dead Man's Switch | Aired 4/25/13 |
Show Summary
EDIT
Elementary is a CBS television series based on Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes detective stories with contemporary twists. It stars Jonny Lee Miller as Holmes and Lucy Liu as Watson.
 Jonny Lee Miller |
Sherlock Holmes |
 Lucy Liu |
Dr. Joan Watson |
 Jon Michael Hill |
Detective Marcus Bell |
 Aidan Quinn |
Captain Tobias Gregson |
Newest Full Episode
|
Monday
No results found.
Tuesday
No results found.
Wednesday
No results found.
|
WERE YOU SURPRISED BY THE BIG REVEAL?
Elementary Season 1 Finale Review: "Menage a Trois With Moriarty"
Together, "The Woman" and "Heroine" basically served as a standalone movie.
By Lily Sparks, 3 days ago
UPFRONTS 2013
CBS's 2013-2014 Schedule: New Nights for Person of Interest and Hawaii Five-0, More Comedy on Thursdays
Elsewhere, Mondays are mostly new and Wednesdays and Sundays are as familiar as ever.
By Tim Surette, May 15, 2013
-
Heroine
S 1 : Ep 24
Aired 5/16/13
-
The Woman
S 1 : Ep 23
Aired 5/16/13
-
Risk Management
S 1 : Ep 22
Aired 5/9/13
-
A Landmark Story
S 1 : Ep 21
Aired 5/2/13
-
Jon Michael Hill on Elementary from "Pos...
© 2013 CBS Broadcasting Inc. -
Aidan Quinn and Jonny Lee Miller on Elem...
© 2013 CBS Broadcasting Inc. -
Jonny Lee Miller and Lucy Liu on Element...
© 2013 CBS Broadcasting Inc. -
Jonny Lee Miller, Lucy Liu, Aidan Quinn ...
© 2013 CBS Broadcasting Inc.
-
Episode Discussion: The Woman 1x23 and Heroine 1x24
2 days ago2Reply
-
Episode Discussion: Risk Management 1x22
05/09/131Reply
-
Episode Discussion: A Landmark Story 1x21
05/01/131Reply
-
Elementary Submission Guidelines
04/29/131Reply
-
Episode Discussion: Dead Man's Switch 1x20
04/23/131Reply
-
Interviewing A Sponsor
11/29/12 (02:08)
-
Power of Observation: Series Preview
4/1/13 (00:31)
-
Holmes Shot and Moriarty Revealed
5/16/13 (02:15)
-
A Bee Named For Watson
5/16/13 (02:45)
Related Shows & Movies
-
TesserT USER EDITOR
User Score: 537
-
neomichel
User Score: 119
-
w4u
User Score: 59
-
DexterMorgan2
User Score: 16
-
mysteriousopal
User Score: 9
-
movieguy_1000
User Score: 7
-
CameronFisher
User Score: 7
-
SrRui
User Score: 7
-
Wasserman
User Score: 5
-
Gislef
User Score: 5
More
Less