Like later episode "The Day They Shot Agarn," this episode begins in medias res, with the episode beginning with O'Rourke being arrested and stripped of his rank and flashbacks filling in the story.
Edit
The episode title is a reference to the TV game show "To Tell the Truth", in which impostors try to fool a panel of judges about their identity, and which concluded with the request "Will the real ------- ------- please stand up."
Edit