Durante and Traubel proved so popular, RCA recorded their duets of "The Song's Gotta Come From the Heart" and "A Real Piano Player". They were released in March 1951 by RCA's classical "Red Seal" label on 78s and 45s.
The 1951 Emmy Awards were held January 23, 1951 at the Ambassador Hotel in Los Angeles. Four Star Revue was nominated for Best Variety Show, along with The Alan Young Show, The Ken Murray Show, and Texaco Star Theater starring Milton Berle. The winner was The Alan Young Show.