D.J. has her first boyfriend, Michael Montfort, but she is crushed when Michael leaves her for Kathy Santoni, because he believes Kathy is prettier than D.J. is. Meanwhile, Rebecca and Danny are hosting a charity event where eligible bachelors are auctioned off to women who want a date with them. Three of the participating bachelors are Danny (who gets a date with an elderly lady), Joey (who gets a date with the same lady's granddaughter), and Jesse, who is sold to Rebecca for a record $1,700.