Michelle encourages Stephanie and D.J. to have a pillow fight with her, and a window ends up getting broken during the pillow fight. Danny punishes Stephanie and D.J., but he fails to punish Michelle, who started the whole thing. This is because Danny is having a hard time realizing that his youngest daughter is old enough to be punished. When Stephanie and D.J. open Danny's eyes to the situation, they give him the courage to finally give his youngest daughter her first punishment.
Meanwhile, Jesse buys an expensive engagement ring for Rebecca, who tries to stop Jesse from selling his prized Elvis Presley-autographed guitar in order to pay for the ring.